Article

2010-01-08 Home Front: Politix

Petition to Recall LA Senator Mary Landrieu (not legal)

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by Sherry 2010-01-08 11:30|| || Front Page|| [4 views ] Top

#1 Can they do it in time?

Posted by Iblis 2010-01-08 12:19|| 2010-01-08 12:19|| Front Page Top

#2 this is almost impossible

Posted by lord garth 2010-01-08 12:30|| 2010-01-08 12:30|| Front Page Top

#3 I'm fairly sure it's not legal. State recall provisions don't apply to federal offices. There is no provision in the US constitution for it.

I favor a repeal of the 17th amendment, though.

Posted by Pstanley 2010-01-08 13:16|| 2010-01-08 13:16|| Front Page Top

#4 I favor a repeal of the 17th amendment, though I favor a Constitutional amendment to allow recall of Senators & Congressmen, and clawing back their pensions if successful.

Posted by Anguper Hupomosing9418 2010-01-08 13:24|| 2010-01-08 13:24|| Front Page Top

#5 AH9418, that's about as likely as an amendment requiring term limits for Congress critters.
Since the first step in introducing an amendment is to get through Congress, neither will ever happen.

Posted by Rambler in Virginia 2010-01-08 13:43|| 2010-01-08 13:43|| Front Page Top

#6 I don't favor recall of federal office holders, and particularly Senators.

Our founders were wise men, many of them were well versed in government theory, Montesquieu in particular. By the time 1787 rolled around, they knew what they were doing, because they'd had ten years of practical experience.

Shortly after the start of the revolution, the colonies, having dissolved ties with Britain, adopted new constitutions. A couple of states had fairly radical provisions. Pennsylvania adopted yearly election of state legislators.

John Adams, quite radical himself, was skeptical of the arrangement because of his schooling. He was proved correct, and became well-acquainted with Pennsylvania's problems as the British moved into Philadelphia while congress fled to York. The turmoil in Pennsylvania that followed was not a boon to the patriot cause. The constant churning and the endless election year made it difficult for the legislature to proper administer proper discipline and control of the militia, and to support the Continental Army, which wintered at Valley Forge. The short election cycle made it impossible for the Pennsylvania legislature to enact unpopular but necessary policies.

Ten years later at the constitutional convention, the founders made the lower house closest to people, with direct elections. But bi-annual elections, because annual elections get nothing done. Constant recall elections would be indistinguishable from annual elections.

The founders also intended that the upper house be doubly insulated from the passions of the people, by having the Senate term last 3x that of the house, and by deciding against direct election. The 17th amendment has already cut a part of that, and recall would undermine it completely.

I do not live in a democracy, nor would I care to.

Posted by Pstanley 2010-01-08 14:04|| 2010-01-08 14:04|| Front Page Top

#7 I'm not so sure that provision doesn't apply to senators. IIRC, the election of congresscritters is controlled by state law with respect to filing deadlines, primaries, nominating petitions, and all that, so why wouldn't state law recall procedures also apply?

Posted by Mike 2010-01-08 14:06|| 2010-01-08 14:06|| Front Page Top

#8 John Adams did not foresee the capture of the national legislature by special interests, and the nearly-complete failure of the legislature to do its duty. We live neither in a republic or a democracy. Nobody's yet coined a word for the rule of anarcho-tyranny.

Posted by Anguper Hupomosing9418 2010-01-08 20:42|| 2010-01-08 20:42|| Front Page Top

23:59 JosephMendiola
23:59 JosephMendiola
23:57 JosephMendiola
23:42 borgboy
23:40 borgboy
23:34 Don Vito Uleash
23:20 Big Phugum2142
22:57 Old Patriot
22:49 abu do you love
22:44 Pappy
22:42 Pappy
22:40 gorb
22:40 abu do you love
22:37 Old Patriot
22:33 746
22:32 gorb
22:31 746
22:28 phil_b
22:24 SteveS
22:24 trailing wife
22:23 SteveS
22:19 remoteman
22:16 Pappy
22:13 Pappy