Archived material Access restricted Article
Rantburg

Today's Front Page   View All of Sat 08/13/2005 View Fri 08/12/2005 View Thu 08/11/2005 View Wed 08/10/2005 View Tue 08/09/2005 View Mon 08/08/2005 View Sun 08/07/2005
1
2005-08-13 Afghanistan/South Asia
Indian INSAS rifles malfunction during major engagement with Nepalese rebels
Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.
Posted by gromky 2005-08-13 02:03|| || Front Page|| [5 views since 2007-05-07]  Top

#1 Well, they're still better than the Enfield rifles that Nepal started the war with.

I think I'd take my chances with the Lee Enfield.
Posted by Bulldog ">Bulldog  2005-08-13 08:00||   2005-08-13 08:00|| Front Page Top

#2 Article: "There were stoppages during the firing ... the rifles got hot and soldiers had to wait for them to cool," another officer told Reuters.

What are the odds that these were firing on full automatic? No assault rifle is designed to fire on full auto for any length of time.
Posted by Zhang Fei">Zhang Fei  2005-08-13 09:51|| http://timurileng.blogspot.com]">[http://timurileng.blogspot.com]  2005-08-13 09:51|| Front Page Top

#3 ZF - welllll at least a clip or two..
Posted by Frank G">Frank G  2005-08-13 10:28||   2005-08-13 10:28|| Front Page Top

#4 Indian army problems with the INSAS were with high altitude operation. Overheating appears to be a problem with usage - inexperienced Nepali troopers firing on full auto.



SEPTEMBER 23, 2003
THE TIMES OF INDIA

The OFB is now working on an export version of
the rifle which is expected to be ready by the
end of the year.

Some improvements are being made to the
plastic fittings which were used to keep the
weapon light. Steel plates will be inserted to
reinforce the plastic. The appearance of the
weapon is also very important for the
international market. The overall appearance will
be improved. However, the costs will be
competitive, said general manager, Rifle
Factory, Ishapore, B.C. Biswas.

The INSAS rifle which replaced the trusty but
outdated 7.62 mm Ishapore SLR rifle the
primary weapon used by Indian infantryman till a
few years ago has been plagued by complaints
from soldiers, mainly from those posted in high
altitudes. A section of OFB officials confided
that India has a long way to go so far as
metallurgy for weapons were concerned. They also
pointed towards the need for more stringent
quality control of procurements from private
agencies. The OFB procures over Rs 500 crore
worth of stores from the private sector.

There were a few INSAS rifles which suffered
from cold arrest in Siachen. An enquiry
revealed that the unit using the rifles had been
recently posted to the region from the plains. In
the plains, soldiers use lubricating oil for the
barrels. In the colder climes, soldiers are
supposed to use a kerosene mixture. The unit was
not aware of this fact explained Biswas.

OFB officials from the repair and maintenance
wing, who travel to forward areas to repair
weapons, complained of misuse. In certain
areas, the temperature falls to 50 degrees below
freezing. Soldiers are so tired that they simply
throw down their weapons when they return to the
barracks. While on long mountain treks, soldiers
often throw weapons to paths 100 feet below, to
be collected when they get there. Unlike the SLR,
the INSAS is much more sensitive and can get
damaged by such treatment, they said.

According to officials, nearly 600,000 INSAS
rifles have been issued to infantrymen in the
Indian Army. Those under production are for issue
to Central and state police forces.

Most bulk demands have been met. There are
only a few units remaining who are yet to be
armed with the INSAS. However,we are lagging in
the number of weapons in the war reserve.
Whenever there is a war, a lot of rifles are
lost. There have to be adequate rifles in stock
to replenish them said Biswas.

Posted by john 2005-08-13 10:37||   2005-08-13 10:37|| Front Page Top

#5 The INSAS looks like an AK-47 variant (or deviant) chambered in .223 with a blowback action. Nothing special here, except that they don't always work. That's a real problem for a combat gun.
Posted by Glart Sholing7898 2005-08-13 11:54||   2005-08-13 11:54|| Front Page Top

#6 Do we have a few warehouses of WWII .30 carbines we can donate or sell cheap?

I'd much rather be an embarrased soldier than a dead one.
Posted by Redneck Jim 2005-08-13 14:44||   2005-08-13 14:44|| Front Page Top

#7 No assault rifle is designed to fire on full auto for any length of time.

Let go 100 rounds from an AK47* and you won't be able to carry the damn thing, it gets that hot.

*it was an AK knock-off, maybe the real mccoy is different
Posted by Rafael 2005-08-13 15:38||   2005-08-13 15:38|| Front Page Top

#8 I take it the "7.62 mm Ishapore SLR" is their version of the Lee-Enfield?
Posted by Phil Fraering 2005-08-13 17:04|| http://newsfromthefridge.typepad.com]">[http://newsfromthefridge.typepad.com]  2005-08-13 17:04|| Front Page Top

#9 Well, a quick google revealed Wikipedia's entry on the Lee-Enfield; some interesting bits:

Ishapore-made .303 calibre SMLE Mk III* rifles have appeared with 1980's manufacture dates suggesting that it may still be manufactured in the Indian sub-continent. Attempts to contact the Ishapore Arsenal to confirm this have so far been unsuccessful.

It was at first thought that some of these may be a product of the small manufacturers in the Khyber Pass region of the Indian/Pakistani/Afghani border, but "Khyber Pass Copies", as they are known, tend to be copied exactly from a "Master" rifle, which may itself be a Khyber Pass Copy, markings and all- which is why it's not uncommon to see Khyber Pass rifles with the "N" in "Enfield" reversed, and the "VR" ("Victoria Regina") cypher from years well after her death.

It has been positied that the 1980s dated Ishapore SMLEs were made for the Mujahadeen during the Soviet invasion.

The Manufacturers Names found on SMLE Mk III/III* rifles are:


Enfield: Royal Small Arms Factory Enfield, UK

BSA Co: Birmingham Small Arms Company, UK

LSA Co L: London Small Arms Company Ltd, UK

Lithgow: Lithgow Small Arms, Australia

GRI: Ishapore Arsenal, India (GRI stands for "George, Rex, Imperator")

RFI: Rifle Factory, Ishapore (Post-Partition)

SSA: Standard Small Arms, UK

NFA: National Firearms Assembly, UK


For the Rifle, Number 4 Mk I and Mk II:


ROF(M): Royal Ordnance Factory Maltby, UK

ROF(F): Royal Ordnance Factory Fazakarley, UK

Savage: Savage Arms, USA

Longbranch: Longbranch Arsenal, Canada

POF: Pakistani Ordnance Factory, Pakistan

Usage today

Lee Enfields are still used by reserve forces and police forces in many Commonwealth countries, particularly India and Canada, where they are the main rifle issued to the Canadian Rangers. Television news footage of the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan revealed that many Afghan tribesmen were still armed with Lee-Enfields, the rifle being common in the Middle East. Bolt-action rifles remain effective weapons in a desert environment, where long-range accuracy is more important than volume of fire.


[...]

Photos from the current civil war in Nepal show that the Government troops are being issued SMLE MK III/III* rifles to fight the Maoist Rebels with. The SMLEs seen thus far are not in especially good condition, but it should also be noted that the Maoists are also armed with SMLEs (and anything else they can acquire), but as to whether the SMLEs in question are of British or Indian manufacture is unknown, as is the year of manufacture.

Posted by Phil Fraering 2005-08-13 17:18|| http://newsfromthefridge.typepad.com]">[http://newsfromthefridge.typepad.com]  2005-08-13 17:18|| Front Page Top

#10 A real problem. They are overheating. I doubt they are firing full auto, quite simply they would run out of ammo in a ten hour engagement of pray and spray. I am thinking this is a design or manufacturing issue.

I have an "Indian" Enfield in 303 and A UK built Enfield Rechambered for 7.62 NATO as well as one in 303. The fit and finish on the indian firearm is fair, good enough for an infantry weapon. A group of well drilled infrantrymen with Enfields can duplicate the effects of an LMG.
Posted by Sock Puppet 0’ Doom 2005-08-13 20:19||   2005-08-13 20:19|| Front Page Top

#11 Phil,

No, the Ishapore SLR (Self Loading Rifle) is the Indian version of the FN FAL as once used by the British.
Posted by buwaya 2005-08-13 20:20||   2005-08-13 20:20|| Front Page Top

#12 If it's a L1A1 variant It's put together poorly and with poor materials. Mine L1A1 will even fire when it won't cycle (which is most of the time) I should have never got rid of the Israeli one I had.
Posted by Sock Puppet 0’ Doom 2005-08-13 20:43||   2005-08-13 20:43|| Front Page Top

#13 I should add I can manually cycle it.
Posted by Sock Puppet 0’ Doom 2005-08-13 20:44||   2005-08-13 20:44|| Front Page Top

#14 Shades of Vietnam where reliable M-14s were replaced with screwed up M-16s that got a bunch of Marines killed.
Great information and comments, always learn stuff at Rantburg.
Posted by Rifle308 2005-08-13 23:31||   2005-08-13 23:31|| Front Page Top

#15 (Another why-do-I-bother-with-15-minutes-left post):

Shades of Vietnam where reliable M-14s were replaced with screwed up M-16s that got a bunch of Marines killed.
Great information and comments, always learn stuff at Rantburg.


I had a friend who was a company commander there; he said that the preexisting problems with the M-16 were aggravated by changes to the propellant used in the cartridges and changes of the amount of propellant (which were meant to change the rate of cyclic fire of the gun). Which brings me to Sock's comment...

Yes, the Enfield is a good rifle, and well-maintained examples in private hands shoot well (as do L1A1). It occured to me that part of the problems the Nepalese might be having with both older and newer firearms might be aggravated if they're using stuff like surplus ammo with corrosive primers, which troops in the field may not be able to use without causing corrosion.

(I've always wondered, myself, how the Russians dealt with that in WW2... did they just not bother, or did every fire team have a little spray bottle of Windex or something? Or did they actually make non-corrosive ammo?)
Posted by Phil Fraering 2005-08-13 23:40|| http://newsfromthefridge.typepad.com]">[http://newsfromthefridge.typepad.com]  2005-08-13 23:40|| Front Page Top

09:04 Janice
07:12 Janice
23:55 3dc
23:53 Cyber Sarge
23:50 Sock Puppet 0’ Doom
23:47 SR-71
23:44 phil_b
23:43 Mike Sylwester
23:42 phil_b
23:40 Phil Fraering
23:35 trailing wife
23:33 3dc
23:33 Phil Fraering
23:31 Mike Sylwester
23:31 Rifle308
23:25 ed
23:20 .com
23:17 ed
23:16 trailing wife
23:09 trailing wife
23:08 Captain America
23:05 Captain America
23:01 Captain America
22:59 3dc









Paypal:
Google
Search WWW Search rantburg.com