Rantburg

Today's Front Page   View All of Wed 04/17/2024 View Tue 04/16/2024 View Mon 04/15/2024 View Sun 04/14/2024 View Sat 04/13/2024 View Fri 04/12/2024 View Thu 04/11/2024
2005-03-16 China-Japan-Koreas
China's course parallels old Germany's
The country had been battered and conquered for centuries, until it finally pulled itself together, politically, militarily and economically. Flexing its newly developed muscles, the rising empire threatened its neighbors, motivating a counter-alliance.
If that sounds like China today, it also sounds like Germany yesterday. The parallels are instructive - and depressing.
Starting in the 16th century, Germany was devastated by chronic conflict. Finally strongly unified after 1871, the nation compensated for past humiliations, and then overcompensated. The Germans said they merely wanted to find "a place in the sun," but under Kaiser Wilhelm II, German power grew rapidly and was handled recklessly. As a result, other European powers lined up against the Second Reich, and war was inevitable. It became actual in 1914.
Yet, even though Germany was defeated and the kaiser deposed at the end of World War I, the arc of its power was so great that its expansionism continued, under a completely political system, until it was checked for good in World War II.
Now it seems that China is retracing at least some of Germany's fateful steps: first its decline, then its rise. China slipped into economic and cultural decay in the 15th century. After 1839, it lost a string of wars - to Britain, France, Russia and Japan - that left it with a massive chip on its national shoulder. Reunified under the Communists in 1949, the country since developed a system of guided capitalism that has astonished and rattled the rest of the world.
As part of its rising riches, China has built a state-controlled mediaplex that accentuates the positive about the Beijing government and the negative about everyone else. China Central TV, broadcasting in English as well as in Chinese, includes at least a small tub-thump for China in every story, and often a dig at the United States.
The accidental death of Nicola Calipari, the Italian rescue-agent killed in Iraq by U.S. forces, gave CCTV a chance to bare its anti-American fangs. For days, newscasters dwelt on the killing; a viewer would never know that the Italian government has remained supportive of U.S. policy all through the Calipari crisis.
Other countries, too, are judged to be deficient relative to China. On the front page of the March 3 Shanghai Daily - state-controlled, of course, and distributed for free in hotels - was this headline: "Lonely life, lonely death in alien land." The article told the sad story of a Shanghai-born woman found murdered in her apartment near the campus of the University of Canberra, Australia, where she had been a student. The paper reported that the university "has come under criticism" for failing to alert authorities that "an international student was missing." Meanwhile, the Chinese government is busy setting up agencies to look out for the interests of overseas Chinese, who number in the tens of millions.
There's nothing wrong with the Chinese using some of their newfound wealth to look out for their own. However, ominously, they insist that "looking out for their own" includes solicitude for the Chinese of Taiwan. Beijing regards that island state as a renegade province, while America and Japan regard Taiwan, for the most part, as an independent country.
When great military powers and great national egos are in tension, it doesn't take much to start a war. In Beijing's worldview, Taiwan's continuing "rebel" status is made possible only because of foreign intervention. Hence the March 7 headline in China Daily, yet another government publication: "Lay off Taiwan, U.S. and Japan told." And now a headline from The Associated Press, just on Monday: "China's president tells army to be prepared for war."
Like Germany in the 19th century, China in the 21st century is demanding its place in the sun. Today the world is witnessing a clash of national interests with no easy, peaceful solution. And it's a reminder that sometimes calamities are obvious as they go rushing down the rails, long before they reach their collision point.
Posted by Anonymoose 2005-03-16 4:54:28 PM|| || Front Page|| [4 views since 2007-05-07]  Top

#1 Excellent analysis.
Posted by Glereper Craviter7929 2005-03-16 5:12:08 PM||   2005-03-16 5:12:08 PM|| Front Page Top

#2 Article: On the front page of the March 3 Shanghai Daily - state-controlled, of course, and distributed for free in hotels - was this headline: "Lonely life, lonely death in alien land." The article told the sad story of a Shanghai-born woman found murdered in her apartment near the campus of the University of Canberra, Australia, where she had been a student.

Many Chinese aren't that gullible, which is why tens of thousands of non-students take on debt of up to $50,000 each to make it to the US via people smugglers. The general awareness that this is garbage is also why annually, tens of thousands of Chinese not only go abroad to study, but also stick around in their newly-adopted lands after graduation, despite the fact that life can actually be more materially comfortable back home (cheap domestic help, housing, et al). They just get used to the foreign lifestyle that the Chinese media routinely pans.
Posted by Zhang Fei  2005-03-16 5:19:59 PM|| [http://timurileng.blogspot.com]  2005-03-16 5:19:59 PM|| Front Page Top

#3 Oh, gimme a $#@&* break. Shanghai Daily, South China Morning Post, and all the other Party mouthpieces are regarded with derision by everyone I know. I mean, they're comically bad. Nobody I know reads them. The only reason you'd ever pick one up is because they're delivered to the rooms in 4-star and better hotels (even if you tell them not to). If you insist on using them as a source of information, stick to the weather and sports pages.

Sounds like a reporter hung around the hotel too much instead of going out, and decided to make a story about a newspaper story combined with a bunch of stuff he remembered from college history class.

CCTV-9 (the English channel) is largely ignored as well, due to its appallingly boring programming. For every anti-American news report, there are dozens of 'Bulgarian foreign minister arrives in Beijing' type stories. Again, we see the reporter hanging out in his hotel room watching hours of TV instead of getting out on the street.

Don't believe me? Watch CCTV-9 yourself (click 'Live Broadcast). A great insomnia cure.
Posted by gromky  2005-03-16 9:12:48 PM||   2005-03-16 9:12:48 PM|| Front Page Top

22:20 trailing wife
20:19 AlmostAnonymous5839
20:09 AlmostAnonymous5839
20:07 Cured Romantic
19:59 Cured Romantic
19:57 Glenmore
19:56 Glenmore
19:56 jpal
19:46 Frank G
18:40 Clolumble Omack5869
18:33 Ebbuger Whuque4103
18:16 Procopius2k
18:16 Menhadden Sheatle7781
18:09 Procopius2k
17:55 James
17:30 Richard+Aubrey
17:26 swksvolFF
17:07 swksvolFF
16:59 ed in texas
16:57 ed in texas
16:32 NoMoreBS
16:13 M. Murcek
16:09 Raj
15:58 Super Hose









Paypal:
Google
Search WWW Search rantburg.com