You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: WoT
US Supreme Court to hear Muslim surveillance case tossed due to ‘state secrets’
2021-11-09
[IsraelTimes] Southern Caliphornia, an impregnable bastion of the Democratic Party, men filed class-action lawsuit for violation of rights after community was targeted in FBI
...Formerly one of the world's premier criminal investigation organizations, something for a nation to be proud of. Now it's a political arm of the Deep State oligarchy that is willing to trump up charges, suppress evidence, or take out insurance policies come election time...
surveillance op; government says case too confidential for trial


The US Supreme Court
...the political football known as The Highest Court in the Land, home of penumbrae and emanations...
is preparing to hear a case about the government’s ability to get lawsuits thrown out of court by claiming they would reveal secrets that threaten national security.

The case before the high court Monday involves a group of Moslem men from Southern California. They filed a class-action lawsuit claiming that the FBI spied on them and hundreds of others in a surveillance operation following 9/11. The group, represented by lawyers from the American Civil Liberties Union and others, claimed religious discrimination and violations of other rights, saying they were spied on solely because of their faith.

A lower court dismissed almost all their claims after the government said allowing the case to go forward could reveal "state secrets" — whom the government was investigating and why. But an appeals court reversed that decision, saying the lower court first should have privately examined the evidence the government said was state secrets to see if the alleged surveillance was unlawful.

The Biden administration (aka the Wilmington comorra)
...the collection of boodlers, grifters, hangers-on, and self-proclaimed experts affiliated with the Biden Crime Family. Entrusted with an entire nation as the result of a suspicious election, they set about happily implementing stuff they absorbed in college, all of which blew up and splattered the rest of us...
, like the Trump administration before it, is telling the justices that decision is wrong.

The case involves a confidential informant, Craig Monteilh, the FBI used from 2006 to 2007. Monteilh pretended to be a new convert to Islam as a way to become part of Southern California’s Moslem community.

Monteilh told people he was a fitness consultant, but he was really working as part of a surveillance program known as Operation Flex. Monteilh regularly attended the Islamic Center of Irvine in Orange County and has said that he was told to collect as much information on as many people as possible. He gathered names and phone numbers and secretly recorded thousands of hours of conversations and hundreds of hours of video using a camera concealed in a shirt button.

Ultimately Monteilh’s handlers told him to ask about jihad and express a willingness to engage in violence. Those questions caused members of the community to report him to the FBI and other authorities and seek a restraining order against him.

The FBI has acknowledged Monteilh was an informant, and the story was covered in the news media including on the National Public Radio show "This American Life."

Three of the men Monteilh allegedly recorded sued seeking damages and asking the government to destroy or return the information it had gathered.

This is the second case the court has heard involving the state secrets privilege since beginning its new term in October. Last month the court heard a case involving a Guantanamo Bay detainee that also involved the state secrets privilege.
Related:
Craig Monteilh: 2011-02-24 Orange County Muslims sue FBI for violating First Amendment
Craig Monteilh: 2010-12-06 Mosque shuns FBI informant
Craig Monteilh: 2010-08-13 CA judge weighs former FBI informant's lawsuit
Related:
Islamic Center of Irvine: 2009-03-19 Muslim Groups Consider Breaking FBI Ties Over Irvine Case
Islamic Center of Irvine: 2009-02-26 Man says he was informant for FBI in Orange County
Islamic Center of Irvine: 2007-07-01 Judge orders man to leave Irvine mosque alone
Posted by:trailing wife

#2  /\ Has the FBI ever cracked a terrorism case that it didn't start itself?

Or watch helplessly as it was permitted to turn into an epic human disaster.
Posted by: Besoeker   2021-11-09 07:16  

#1  The case involves a confidential informant, Craig Monteilh, the FBI used from 2006 to 2007. Monteilh pretended to be a new convert to Islam as a way to become part of Southern California’s Moslem community.

Has the FBI ever cracked a terrorism case that it didn't start itself?
Posted by: Omomolet Phutch9064   2021-11-09 07:09  

00:00