Article

2007-03-22 Iraq

Petraeus: "We are attriting them at a fearsome rate"

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by Anonymoose 2007-03-22 00:00|| || Front Page|| [11125 views since 2007-05-07] Top

#1 Great job on most of those points, Gen. Petraeus.

But I don't think the rate of attrition is near fearsome enough. Nor the rate of emigration/displacement in Sunni areas that show the slightest support for the enemy cause.

I know, easy for this armchair general to say. But I do have this little thing about saving lives (both American and Iraqi), and common sense and history show that truly fearsome aggression is by far the most efficient and humane way to defeat an enemy. I'm all for winning over tribes or sheikhs or parts of neighborhoods - but even those gambits will be easier to accomplish if we convince folks that opposition is a true dead end.

Posted by Verlaine 2007-03-22 00:22|| 2007-03-22 00:22|| Front Page Top

#2 It goes to the US-Allies' LR regional-global strategy. Radical Islam is well aware that Amers like fighting short wars, but they also are aware that something milpol detrimental to the USA occurs in near-term [now-Year2020], the odds are the HYPERPOWER+ USA WILL ONLY GET STRONGER + WILL PROTRACTIVELY STAY IN THE ME FOR AS LONG THE US OR ALLIES WANT, which by extens basically means Radical Islam plus aligned Commies-Socialists, etc. either regionally andor globally have failed. THE GREATEST OR ULTIMATE BATTLE IN THIS WOT IS THE BATTLE FOR THE USA VIA BATTLE FOR CONTROL OF WASHINGTON DC, CONGRESS CRITTERS, US GOP-DEM NPE, and US NATIONAL-FOREIGN POLICIES. Year 2014-2018 [2020] > Russia-China have stated that WAR AGZ USA IS NOT ONLY POSSIBLE BUT DESIRED/REALISTIC > means USA must M-U-S-T ADOPT OWG + SOCIALISM , OR THE USA WILL BE ATTACKED AND DESTROYED BY ANY MEANS NECESSARY, VOLUNTARILY = FORCIBLY. 2008 > POTUS elex may be the last "peacetime", traditional elex held in free, officially non-Socialist America. *WORLDNEWS > BOSTONHERALD > US-CHINA: PACIFIC POWER PLAY IN THE WORKS. Gist- No matter how you meaure it, CHINA IS GOING ON THE [anti-US]REGIONAL = GLOBAL = SPACE OFFENSIVE.

Posted by JosephMendiola 2007-03-22 01:22|| 2007-03-22 01:22|| Front Page Top

#3 I hope our guys and gals in theater, like you just were Verlaine, like what Petraeus is saying. The critical bit about consistent ROE and Iraqis flooding them with Intel sure sounds good to me.

Posted by RD 2007-03-22 01:27|| 2007-03-22 01:27|| Front Page Top

#4 I suppose President Bush feels that he is displaying loyalty to his subordinates by refusing to replace them for inadequate performance, but that is counterproductive as public policy (Michael Brown at FEMA, etc.).

General Petraeus has been one of our leading experts on counterinsurgency (he has figuratively AND literally written the book on it) and he should have been installed in this position years ago. Far greater progress at quelling the violence there would have been made a lot sooner and even the results of the recent elections would likely have been different.

I only hope that the political climate has not eroded to such an extent that the mission will be fatally undermined just as we are making progress.

Posted by Grumenk Philalzabod0723 2007-03-22 01:35|| 2007-03-22 01:35|| Front Page Top

#5 "I've made two things clear," Petraeus emphasized: "My ROE may not be modified with supplemental guidance lower down. And I've written a letter to all Coalition forces saying 'your chain-of-command will stay with you.' I think that solved the issue."

This one is LONG overdue - blanket folders ahve been adding layers of restictions on things to the point where combat troops havent a clue if they are violating the ROE until after they call up the chain. Makes for escaped terr and US casualties. Fixing this is one of the best thigns he did. Get the damn non-cobat officers back in their concrete bundkers in LSAA out of the loop and let the field commanders command.

Posted by OldSpook 2007-03-22 01:44|| 2007-03-22 01:44|| Front Page Top

#6 I concur with all the other comments just made (well, Joseph, I THINK I agree with you, or something).

RD, I felt fortunate to work in-theater at all, and I felt like I was abandoning post when I left, but .... I want to emphasize that I was a rear-echelon MF, at best. Mostly in the IZ, and when outside not actively looking for trouble like the awesome folks at the tip of the spear (and all my helicopter travel was before the nitwits came up with their truck-mounted AAA gambit). When I was there, and now as I write this, I have felt tremendous frustration at not being able to do a lot more.

Posted by Verlaine 2007-03-22 02:32|| 2007-03-22 02:32|| Front Page Top

#7 I'm glad they finally changed the ROE. They have been fucked up since Vietnam when dealing with non-conventional situations (and a lot of conventional situations too). Makes it easier to do your job as infantry when you don't have to consult the CoC and all their fucking JAG lawyers before you pull the trigger.

Posted by DarthVader">DarthVader 2007-03-22 09:05|| 2007-03-22 09:05|| Front Page Top

#8 JM, your CapsLock button seems to be malfunctioning.

Posted by Captain Lewis 2007-03-22 09:06|| 2007-03-22 09:06|| Front Page Top

#9 General Petraeus has been one of our leading experts on counterinsurgency (he has figuratively AND literally written the book on it) and he should have been installed in this position years ago.

While I agree that General Patraeus is one of our current leading experts on counterinsurgency, he most definitely did NOT write the book on it. Figuratively, or literally.

He has however, added a few chapters and updated some as well.

JM, your CapsLock button seems to be malfunctioning.

Captain, you're new here, aren't you? JM, is...well...JM. Should you ever begin to understand even half of what he writes, be afraid. Be very afraid!

Posted by Chiper Threreger8956 2007-03-22 10:14|| 2007-03-22 10:14|| Front Page Top

#10
JM wrote the book on counterinsurgency.

Posted by Master of Obvious 2007-03-22 11:36|| 2007-03-22 11:36|| Front Page Top

#11 In all seriousness, I think Joe is a Rantburg asset. Reading his comments is like decoding a legal contract -- a few minutes of unyielding concentration and you've really learned something. Although it helps to take notes.

Posted by Jonathan">Jonathan 2007-03-22 13:02|| 2007-03-22 13:02|| Front Page Top

#12 I've seen Joe be quite lucid, and brief.

And worthwhile.

But he could use a bit more space between paragraphs, I think.

Does space take much bandwidth, I wonder?

Posted by Bobby 2007-03-22 14:29|| 2007-03-22 14:29|| Front Page Top

#13 well you can't expect total civility in iraq when you can't get in gherros across the US. Look at how long the bloods and crips and other gangs have been killing each other off and is still going on

Posted by sinse 2007-03-22 16:29|| 2007-03-22 16:29|| Front Page Top

#14 I think it has something to do with the previous generation of idiots being killed off before they can learn a lesson, so the next generation starts off without a hope or a clue.

Posted by gorb 2007-03-22 16:36|| 2007-03-22 16:36|| Front Page Top

#15 Chiper Threreger8956 -

I suggest you go here. Scroll down and see who's signature is on the document. I've worked at CAC. He may not have written every word, but he made sure that it said what he wanted after numerous edits and reviews.

Posted by Procopius2k 2007-03-22 18:29|| 2007-03-22 18:29|| Front Page Top

#16 I aproach JM's stream of consiousness posts the same as I approach an episode of LOST, after I have missed the prior two or three.

Posted by Capsu 78 2007-03-22 18:39|| 2007-03-22 18:39|| Front Page Top

#17 It's a real shame it took so long for Petraeus to gain command. Had he been in charge 18 months sooner Washington might look very different now. I'd've rather had him in Baghdad instead of Leavenworth. Bush has no one to blame but himself. His loyalty to subordinates is misplaced and has wounded him more than once. Clearly Casey and Abazaid were unable or unwilling to do what works.

I look forward to his presidential run.

Posted by Nimble Spemble 2007-03-22 18:45|| 2007-03-22 18:45|| Front Page Top

23:48 USN, ret.
23:45 JosephMendiola
23:43 JosephMendiola
23:42 USN, ret.
23:41 Frank G
23:40 Frank G
23:38 Shipman
23:34 49 Pan
23:24 WTF
23:16 SteveS
23:03 3dc
23:00 Jackal
22:59 OldSpook
22:57 ed
22:56 OldSpook
22:53 trailing wife
22:53 Jackal
22:52 3dc
22:52 OldSpook
22:50 OldSpook
22:46 OldSpook
22:43 OldSpook
22:42 OldSpook
22:42 Zhang Fei