Article

2004-02-15 Israel-Palestine

Bedouins protest Israeli destruction of homes, crops

Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.

Posted by Dar 2004-02-15 1:37:19 PM|| || Front Page|| [4 views since 2007-05-07] Top

#1 When I did some business in Israel back in 87, there were Bedouin in and around the hills near Jerusalem. Very poor, living in informal groupings of shanties / small houses, herding goats and sheep (but sheep need better grazing) and with small vegetable plots watered by hand.

The problem may be - and I don't have any current experience or info at all - that by tradition the Bedouin don't *own* land - they use it based on tribal traditions.

This sounds like fairly brutal measures to take, unless they were trying to stake out de facto ownership rights or they were complicit with Palestinian terror.

It's possible Israel is trying to force them out before closing the door. I think there are irrigated areas near Be'er Sheva under intensive cultivation but again I'm not sure of that. And I'm not sure where these people could go if they were forced out - they live a fairly marginal life or at least the ones I saw did 16 years ago .....

Posted by rkb 2004-2-15 2:17:41 PM|| 2004-2-15 2:17:41 PM|| Front Page Top

#2 Someone better versed than me in Arab society correct me but from my readings Bedouins are more or Arabs pariahs. They usualy aren't interested in Arab politics so it strikes me as very unusual they
resort to this kind of slogans. Looks more like there is a Palestinian opertaing them on remote control.

Posted by JFM 2004-2-15 4:31:12 PM|| 2004-2-15 4:31:12 PM|| Front Page Top

#3 The trouble here, rkb, is that the Bedouin are a wandering nomadic sort of people. Like gypsies, they prefer to drift around the land, setting up temporary lodgings when/where ever they find good grazing, and moving on when the grazing is gone.

And they DON'T like borders. To them, a fence is a silly idea that needs to be torn down as soon as possible. For that matter, many of them feel that if we silly house-bound people would just give up those damn roots and come wander with them, we'd be happier. (Or so _they_ feel..)

Ed Becerra

Posted by Ed Becerra 2004-2-15 4:32:37 PM|| 2004-2-15 4:32:37 PM|| Front Page Top

#4 I agree, Ed. I was surprised that a true Bedouin would stop long enough to build a house or plant a crop. Although Wright did mention a Bedouin working at the newspaper. I thought that was unusual also. Maybe times are changing.

Posted by GK 2004-2-15 4:56:42 PM|| 2004-2-15 4:56:42 PM|| Front Page Top

08:35 1234L
08:09 B
00:09 Lucky
23:47 Lucky
23:43 Tibor
23:43 Mike Sylwester
23:39 Lucky
23:22 Les Nessman
23:20 Zhang Fei
23:18 .com
23:18 Zhang Fei
23:11 phil_b
23:10 Seafarious
22:41 GK
22:35 AF Lady
22:32 JAB
22:21 rkb
22:20 PBMcL
22:13 Dan
22:03 Old Patriot
21:45 djohn66
21:44 Pappy
21:40 Zhang Fei
20:39 Robert Crawford