Archived material Access restricted Article
Rantburg

Today's Front Page   View All of Fri 11/14/2003 View Thu 11/13/2003 View Wed 11/12/2003 View Tue 11/11/2003 View Mon 11/10/2003 View Sun 11/09/2003 View Sat 11/08/2003
1
2003-11-14 Europe
France criticised by 22 of Europe’s elder statesmen
Archived material is restricted to Rantburg regulars and members. If you need access email fred.pruitt=at=gmail.com with your nick to be added to the members list. There is no charge to join Rantburg as a member.
Posted by Steve White 2003-11-14 12:37:16 AM|| || Front Page|| [2 views since 2007-05-07]  Top

#1 Secularity in France is different than in the USA: in France it was made by atheists against the Churchs (mainly the Catholic one but there also measures against the Protestants and Jews) were while in the USA it was made by believers except all of them were not of the same obedience and they didn't want a state favoring or prosecuting people for their religion.


In France governement forceibly closed lots of confessional schools and replaced them with state schools aimed at manufacturing good atheists.


In the US oathes are pronounced on the Bible

Posted by JFM  2003-11-14 1:07:36 AM||   2003-11-14 1:07:36 AM|| Front Page Top

#2 JFM,

The US Constitution called for no establishment of a national religion, because the forefathers saw the danger of having government using God's name for oppression - many of them felt that Anglican chruch was flawed in theis way.

For example, prior to the revolution there was a famous court case in Virgina where Patrick Henry defended local farmers that had been charged with not paying tithes to the Church. The court protcted the right of the Church to effectively collect taxes from the local populace regardless of local economic conditions.

Within the last several years the atheist crowd has used the separation of chirch and state idea that is drawn from a letter that Jefferson wrote.

The current use of this letter by the ACLU and others closely matches what is happeneing in France. The end result is that many parents are opting out of public education.
Posted by Super Hose  2003-11-14 8:47:16 AM||   2003-11-14 8:47:16 AM|| Front Page Top

#3 from y understanding of French and european history JFM is more on the mark than Super. Historically the European left wanted the govt to proactively secularize civil society - far beyond the wall of seperation idea - for reasons that go to the historic linkage of the church with rightist regimes, the left wanted to actively ban PRIVATE Catholic schooling, not just cut off state funding. There is NOTHING like that in the US, largely cause of our historic legacy of relative (if not always quite absolute) seperation.
Posted by liberalhawk 2003-11-14 9:36:38 AM||   2003-11-14 9:36:38 AM|| Front Page Top

#4 La France is a Muslim Nation, why the surprise?
Posted by Greg 2003-11-14 11:30:34 AM||   2003-11-14 11:30:34 AM|| Front Page Top

#5 


Don't let the ACLU and others transform America from a secular country into an intolerant atheistic country.


Now a few stories about France's secularity:

When De Gaulle was President and travelling in a foreign country the program set by the foreign country included a mass. Mme De Gaulle was to lift to take the communion and De Gaulle made her sit telling "We cannot do so. France is a secular country". In other words, two devout Catholics were not free to commulgate.


Before WWI, the Combes cabinet constituted files about religious practice between officers.


After WWI, the governement was not as agressive in religious matters, however General Gamelin owed his nomination as chief of staff to his atheism and the protection of Daladier, an influential atheistic politician. Gamelin was the chief of staff in 1940, he was the guy who ignored the potential of Armored Divisions and who had left the Sedan region unprotected thus allowing the Germans to surround the main body of the French Army. Paul Reynaud, the Prime Minister, had tried to fire him before the German attack but had to drop the idea due to the opposition of Daladier .

Posted by JFM  2003-11-14 3:40:08 PM||   2003-11-14 3:40:08 PM|| Front Page Top

09:10 Martin Stephen
12:12 Dan
09:11 Super Hose
03:31 Dave
01:46 Steven Den Beste
23:53 PBMcL
23:37 Dan Darling
23:35  Boris A.Kupershmidt
23:30 CrazyFool
23:26 CrazyFool
23:24  Boris A.Kupershmidt
23:22 eLarson
23:22 Robert Crawford
23:09 Gasse Katze
22:50 Mike
22:46 Jarhead
22:39 Anonymous
22:34 Robert Crawford
22:22 Stephen
22:05 Jarhead
22:04 Alaska Paul
21:52 Stonecutters
21:40 Robert Crawford
21:33 Pappy









Paypal:
Google
Search WWW Search rantburg.com