Submit your comments on this article |
Europe |
Fact check: Afghan migrants not flown in by new German govt |
2025-03-03 |
[DW] Germany has taken in more people from Afghanistan who were persecuted by the Taliban. However, their arrival was greeted with speculation and accusations online. A DW fact check. Only a few days after the German parliamentary election a charter plane from Islamabad, Pakistain landed in Berlin with 155 Afghans on board. According to the Federal Ministry of the Interior, more than half of these people came via the federal admission program for particularly vulnerable people. Many local media outlets reported about the event. However, the difference between stupidity and genius is that genius has its limits... many social media users saw a reason to claim that the new German government allowed them to enter the country, thereby breaking its promise of strict border control. But this is not true. DW Fact check has the details. Claim: In a viral post on X, a user claimed, "In Germany, the borders were opened 24 hours after the elections. 48 hours later, the Afghan migrant plane arrived in Berlin. Germany is being invaded in a planned manner." The post already has more than 20 million views. In another post, a user claimed, "Plane with 155 Afghans landed in Berlin. 12,000 more to come. Germany voted for the so-called 'center-right' CDU after they promised to stop Afghan immigration. They broke their promise just 48 hours after the election!" DW Fact check: False First, there is no new government in Germany yet following the elections on February 23. The country is still run by the outgoing government of Chancellor Olaf Scholz. While the conservative bloc CDU/CSU, led by Friedrich Merz, won the election, a new government has yet to be formed. Coalition negotiations with potential partners are about to start soon. So the arrival of these Afghan ![]() took power in Afghanistan in August 2021, to get particularly vulnerable people out of the country. The remaining passengers came to Germany through other admission programs: the local forces procedure, the human rights ...which are usually open to widely divergent definitions... list, and a bridging program, which were also established after the fall of the Taliban. These programs focus in particular on local forces who have supported the German and international troops, democracy activists and people who are threatened by the Taliban because of their sexual or gender identity. According to the German Interior Ministry, the German government had committed to admitting around 45,000 at-risk Afghans and their families. As of April 2024, more than 33,200 Afghans have already entered Germany under the Federal admission program for Afghanistan. Germany has also facilitated the entry of Afghans who previously worked for German authorities and organizations before the fall of Kabul according to the German Foreign Office. Two flights from Islamabad were canceled at short notice just before the general elections in Germany, as per media reports. Since there is no functioning German embassy in Kabul, these individuals must travel to Islamabad on their own. After undergoing a long wait, security clearance, and visa issuance in Pakistain, they are then allowed to enter Germany. The German Foreign Office has raised concerns as Afghan nationals have been instructed to leave Islamabad and the neighboring city of Rawalpindi by the end of March, according to the German news agency dpa. And with Pakistain reviving its effort to deport Afghans, many opponents of the Taliban are in danger of returning to a country ruled by the Islamist regime, DW's Haroon Janjua reports from Islamabad. IMMIGRATION KEY ISSUE FOR DISINFORMATION IN GERMAN ELECTIONS Immigration and deportation were among the key issues during Germany's recently concluded parliamentary elections. It has sparked a lot of mis- and disinformation online about the deportation of foreign nationals living in Germany. Calls for increased deportations to Afghanistan have intensified following deadly attacks in the country involving im |
Posted by:trailing wife |
#4 DW is an agency of the German government, not an arbiter of truth. Yes, I know. But it’s an easy site to get English-language, German-centered reports and perspective of events. Once there is a starting point, for me it’s easier to search more broadly for information. Likewise, the Times of Israel is definitely imperfect, but it’s reasonably centrist, doesn’t make my iPad crash like the Jerusalem Post, and is fairly informative about events in Israel, the region, and beyond. All our sources are starting points. All are understood to be imperfect. |
Posted by: trailing wife 2025-03-03 21:55 |
#3 No different than VOA or RFE. |
Posted by: DooDahMan 2025-03-03 18:41 |
#2 "Deutsche Welle" ... "is a German public, state-owned[1] international broadcaster funded by the German federal tax budget." DW is an agency of the German government, not an arbiter of truth. |
Posted by: Elmerert Hupens2660 2025-03-03 18:14 |
#1 ![]() Tichys Einblick mentions "Air Baerbock" flying in "many thousand" Afghanis to Germany. |
Posted by: DooDahMan 2025-03-03 05:36 |