You have commented 358 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
In pursuit of victory, Israel and Hezbollah are missing an important detail
2024-09-25
Direct Translation via Google Translate. Edited.
by Leonid Tsukanov

[REGNUM] For several days in a row, an intense exchange of attacks between Israel and Lebanese Hezbollah has continued, the largest in the past two decades.

In the first hours of the Israeli operation, dubbed "Arrows of the North," Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu called on the Lebanese population to immediately leave the border area and "not interfere with justice."

Soon enough, the Internet was flooded with footage of multi-kilometer traffic jams - civilians in southern Lebanon were trying to leave the escalation zone, often under Israeli bombardment. Other footage was also distributed - for example, of the hasty evacuation to bomb shelters of the population of Haifa, Israel, where they had already become unaccustomed to rocket attacks from Lebanon.

Both sides have seriously raised the stakes with the intention of forcing the opponent to “throw in the white flag” at any cost. Moreover, both Israel and Hezbollah are absolutely certain that the enemy is about to waver, and that victory over it will be quick and final.

However, recent events increasingly indicate the opposite.

SECOND GAZA
The current actions of the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) differ little from its offensive tactics in the Gaza Strip. In an effort to bleed Hezbollah dry, Israeli forces are practically non-stop ironing out Lebanon with all available means. In the last 24 hours alone, Israel has attacked more than a thousand targets in Lebanon, not limiting the geography of the raids to the border zone.

The Israelis claim that the initiative is entirely on their side. Thanks to intensive combined strikes, they allegedly managed to destroy up to half of Hezbollah's arsenal, as well as "tie up operational control" of the movement's rank-and-file fighters.

According to information released by the IDF, several dozen high-ranking Hezbollah commanders were killed or seriously wounded in the raids, including officers from the elite Radwan special forces unit and close associates of the movement's Secretary General Hassan Nasrallah.

It should be noted that Israel explains its actions against Lebanon by security considerations and the “desire to protect not only its own, but also the Lebanese civilian population,” who “found themselves hostages” of Iranian proxies.

At the same time, the notorious “pager attack,” which resulted in almost 4,000 Lebanese casualties (most of them civilians)
…the civilian thing is a lie that the Russians have repeated before. But then Hezbollah is a client of Russia’s client Iran, so Russia waxes sentimental…
and which just a week ago the Israelis themselves called a “brilliant operation by the intelligence services,” is gradually being covered up.

Thus, Israeli President Isaac Herzog publicly stated that Israel was not involved in the pager explosions in Lebanon, and that the terrorist attack against Hezbollah commanders could have been carried out by the movement’s “numerous ill-wishers.” Most likely, Herzog tried to tone down the overly bellicose rhetoric of Prime Minister Netanyahu, who threatened new retaliation against all those who support Hezbollah, even indirectly.
The president of Israel is a ceremonial figurehead, functionally an elected king hauled out to kiss babies and meet other powerless ceremonial kings. Before he was president he was a leader in various iterations of the Labour party. Naturally, he doesn’t like Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu.
BEFORE THE THROW
The ultimate goal of Israel's intimidation campaign is not difficult to determine: Tel Aviv is trying to provoke panic and discontent among the Lebanese toward Hezbollah.
At this point, in terms of power and influence in the Lebanese government, anyone not aligned with Hezbollah is a Non-Playing Character. Given that the NPCs have been fleeing Lebanon’s cities for the countryside, and even crossing into Syria, I’d say that panic and discontent have been accomplished.
It is precisely popular pressure, according to the plan of the Israeli General Staff, that should force the movement's fighters to retreat beyond the Litani River, which the Israelis promptly declared the "northern border" of their country.

This will provide the IDF with the opportunity to freely enter southern Lebanon and stop the shelling of northern Israel (by creating a “security zone” in the border area), which has not stopped for almost a year.

For Netanyahu, who has still not been able to “pick the keys” to the sympathies of northern refugees, whose number has already exceeded 100 thousand people, such a scenario seems advantageous.

However, the Israeli leadership does not rule out a more complex option, which would involve a protracted struggle with Hezbollah.

A full-scale offensive into southern Lebanon is fraught with risks. The cost of error, given previous failed Lebanese campaigns, seems too high.
The IDF seems more interested in shaping the battlefield by continuing to destroy Hezbollah’s arms caches and kill its leadership from the air, now that their communications have been thoroughly destroyed.
And among the IDF command staff there are plenty of those who personally participated in the Lebanese campaigns and are trying in every way to dissuade Netanyahu from another attempt at revenge. In addition, the country's leadership is constantly under pressure from the public, dissatisfied with the prospects of opening a "second front."
Bibi was their Donald Trump even before Trump came along. The Never-Bibi crowd can never agree that he’s right even if he is doing exactly what they would do were they in power.
In light of this, the Israeli military is looking for unconventional options to break out of the strategic impasse.

Among other things, Israel can use the Golan Heights (Syria) it has occupied
…not occupied — absorbed. Israel will never give the heights back to Syria, and when he was president Donald Trump formally recognized it…
for an offensive, where the IDF has previously promptly removed several large minefields. A thrust across the Golan Heights will allow the Israeli army not only to seize the operational initiative, but also to bypass Hezbollah's well-fortified defensive nodes in southern Lebanon, taking a bridgehead with fewer losses.
An interesting thought…
In this sense, the Israeli General Staff is taking into account the mistakes of the failed Lebanese campaign of 2006.

However, a strong pretext is needed to develop an offensive, and Tel Aviv hopes to provoke Hezbollah into a serious response.

This would allow the remaining “moral restrictions” on the operation to be lifted and to invade Lebanon without regard for US opinion.

HOW WILL HEZBOLLAH RESPOND?
Despite Israel's air superiority, Hezbollah still holds its own and even tries to respond to Israeli actions in proportion.

The first step was to increase the depth and frequency of the strikes. Over the past 24 hours, the movement has launched at least 200 rockets and kamikaze drones, some of which have managed to penetrate Israel's missile defense system. As a result, not only the northern border region has come under attack, but also calmer cities such as Haifa.

And although the damage caused by Hezbollah is nothing compared to that caused by the Israelis, the media effect of the attacks is very high. Especially since the movement, apparently, managed to hit the Haifa explosives factory, as well as the infrastructure of the Megiddo military airport.
Hitting is not the same as damaging. Was there significant damage?
Moreover, Hezbollah is trying its best to show that it is not defending itself, but the people of Lebanon – these theses have been voiced by the movement’s leaders during the last few appeals to supporters.
Not bothering to appeal ti non-supporters?
The appeal to a “common cause” is intended not only to calm ordinary Lebanese, but also to legitimize the change in the vector of Hezbollah’s operations to make them more offensive. The movement is determined not only to draw off some of the Israeli forces, but also, if necessary, to “grind” them down.

It should be noted that in some cases Hezbollah deliberately shows weakness in order to accelerate the IDF's shift in focus from the Gaza Strip to northern Israel.
Going for the Pyrrhic defeat defence, are they?
Given that most Hamas battalions maintain a relatively high level of combat readiness
…you keep telling yourselves that…
even after a year of operations in Gaza, even a slight weakening of Israeli attention to the enclave would be enough to regroup and strike at the depleted IDF contingent.

And given that Israeli society perceives the operation in Gaza as “close to completion,” any abrupt change in the balance of power is guaranteed to have the effect of a bomb exploding.

Be that as it may, both Israel and Hezbollah, in their pursuit of “final victory,” are missing an important detail: their direct clash will not be limited to local disputes, no matter how much the parties try to convince their supporters of this.

On the contrary, given the high stakes that have been placed over the past year, the conflict risks spreading to the entire Middle East and drawing into the confrontation even those powers that have tried with all their might to maintain neutrality or reconcile their opponents.
The Arabs have tried that before. Israel would beat them even if they were reduced to fighting with rocks and sticks.
However, neither side is yet willing to give in, as the confidence that the enemy is about to waver only grows stronger in the heat of the fight.

Posted by:badanov

#2  mostly agiprop but they did get one thing right namely that the effects of this conflict will be regional, not just local

and that is what Iran fears

Hezbollah has already lost $ billions in Iran supplied weapons, if Hezbollah goes down, it will shake the Mullahs to the bottom of their turbans
Posted by: Lord Garth   2024-09-25 09:16  

#1  Накоси Викуси
Posted by: Grom the Reflective   2024-09-25 02:02  

00:00