| Submit your comments on this article |
| Israel-Palestine-Jordan |
| What America Can Learn From Israel On The Battlefield |
| 2024-06-11 |
| [DanielGreenfield]America has never successfully liberated and held territory from Islamic terrorists. After thousands dead in Afghanistan and Iraq: both countries are now controlled by Islamic terrorists. Many top current and former defense officials who oversaw both disasters, despite a track record of zero wins, have been criticizing Israel for not following in their footsteps. Everyone from former Gen. David Petraeus to current Joint Chiefs Chair Gen. C.Q. Brown offer the familiar criticisms that Israel is not following the COIN or counterinsurgency model. "Not only do you have to actually go in and clear out whatever adversary you are up against, you have to go in, hold the territory and then you’ve got to stabilize it," Chief Brown argued. The problem with this model is that it failed and left a lot of widows and orphans along the way. The United States spent over 50 years losing wars, prestige and young men by trying to follow the familiar strategy for defeating guerrilla armies through conventional warfare followed by efforts to hold and stabilize the territories. And what exactly do we have to show for it? The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) discarded this conventional wisdom for another approach. Rather than trying to hold territory filled with an enemy population among whom the terrorists move, it has used its manpower to attack concentrations of enemy forces, moving quickly and at times unpredictably, while refusing to get bogged down by trying to ’hold’ any particular area. This strategy has frustrated the entire Hamas war plan which like that of Jihadis in Iraq and Afghanistan depended on using terror attacks to pin military units in place, forcing them to defend and patrol a territory, and then exploiting their weaknesses to launch ambushes. ...When Israel ’re-cleared’ Al-Shifa hospital, it took by surprise and captured much of the leadership of Islamic Jihad and some Hamas leaders as well. Rather than a weakness, re-clearing is a strength because when terrorists return to territory that Israel is now familiar with, it can turn the tables and launch surprise attacks on those old positions. Israel is not fighting to take land, but to grind down enemy forces wherever they operate. "The measure of effectiveness will not be enemy killed," Gen McChrystal told the Senate about his Afghanistan strategy in 2009. McChrystal’s strategy killed a lot of Americans instead. Israel is betting that McChrystal is wrong. It’s measuring effectiveness in just that way. |
| Posted by:Grom the Reflective |
| #3 See Neanderthals. |
| Posted by: Skidmark 2024-06-11 10:31 |
| #2 Lesson 1 - do NOT allow Muslim Migration Lesson 2 - refer to lesson 1 |
| Posted by: Anon1 2024-06-11 07:08 |
| #1 There won't be any place for the enemy to live after all the apartment blocks have been reduced to rubble. Then make the rubble bounce until the last few Hamas starve to death. They aren't exactly growing crops, you know? |
| Posted by: Cromonter Spawn of the Faeries8107 2024-06-11 01:03 |