You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
Ukraine's Kherson Campaign - Lessons & Implications of the Southern counterattack- Perun
2022-11-21
[YouTube] While much of the narrative around the early stages of Russia's 2022 invasion center on the battle for Kyiv and the reverses Russia suffered there, in the South, the Russian invasion was altogether more successful in its opening moves.

Advancing from Crimea, the Russians rapidly secured a number of critical positions in the South of the country, including a regional capital on the right bank of the Dnipro, the city of Kherson.

The fighting to take back Kherson would be some of the hardest for Ukrainian forces. They would face a number of high quality Russian units who were heavily dug in, and they would do it over unfavourable ground.

The fighting would take months and claim many lines before the final Russian withdrawal in November.

This is the story of that campaign - from the city's fall to its liberation, along with some of the lessons and observations that we can (with admittedly low confidence levels) make using the data available so far.

Caveats:
Data quality and certainty will always vary video to video. In the case of this video, the topic in question is battlefield movements and the conduct of operations. As such, there is a considerably lower level of confidence than there are over major economic patterns for example.

I expect that at least some of this analysis will be refuted or augmented by later discoveries or data releases - at which point I will prepare an update. But given the implications of this campaign, I thought it best to try and tell the story now, with the best information we currently have available.
Posted by:DarthVader

#2  In a different metaverse, maybe. One side quit. That's not hard fought.

You need to take a better look at the data from both sides. This was a modern WWI style slug. Lots of artillery with attacks over very flat and open terrain. The Ukrainians took pretty heavy losses compared to their other attacks. What they did is make the Russians use their artillery at such a rate they couldn't replace it over the damaged bridges fast enough. Food, replacements and ammo were all being rapidly drained from the constant attacks by Ukraine until the Russians had to pull back and quit before they ran out of everything.

Watch the video please.
Posted by: DarthVader   2022-11-21 23:10  

#1  "The fighting to take back Kherson would be some of the hardest for Ukrainian forces."

In a different metaverse, maybe. One side quit. That's not hard fought. The spoils of victory: The gains in Kherson are such that Ukraine has conscripted the males of the city and have ordered the city's evacuation.

Maybe the better decision was the housing voucher Russia was offering...

The end of this narrative arc we see both sides have deemed the City of Kherson as not being strategically important enough at this time in the war to garrison and occupy it.
Posted by: mossomo   2022-11-21 12:47  

00:00