You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Caucasus/Russia/Central Asia
More than 50 high-ranking Ukrainian officers and generals were destroyed by Russian missiles
2022-06-20
Direct Translation via Google Translate. Edited.

Commentary by Russian military blogger Andrey Chervonets

Yesterday at 12:30, sea-based missiles "Caliber" hit the command post of Ukrainian troops near the village of Shirokaya Dacha, Dnepropetrovsk region.

At that moment, there was a working meeting of the command staff of the operational-strategic group of forces "Alexandria."

"As a result of the strike, over 50 generals and officers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, including the general staff, the command of the group of forces "Kakhovka," air assault troops and formations, were destroyed, operating in the Nikolaev and Zaporizhzhia directions,” the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation reported.

Added information from blogger L Vershinim:

Firstly, I saved myself from the temptation to giggle in the morning on the topic "50 generals and officers", according to the gene. Konashenkov controlled by the blessed fire on the southern front. I wanted to, because it was too much, but I decided to wait - and thank God, otherwise I would now be in an awkward position. Now, having received accurate information from people who are absolutely in the know, I inform you: yes, the Holy Fire descended, exactly on a solid headquarters, head to head at the time of an important meeting, and several dozen high-ranking officers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine (including two with stripes) out of order, most of them forever.
Russian Major General Igor Konashenkov, spokesman for the Russian ministry of defense
Secondly, the same people who are absolutely in the know confirm that the Kyiv Nazis have finally taken, and their Western curators have approved the decision to attack on about. Serpentine with the aim of deblocking Odessa and ousting the Russian Navy from the western Black Sea region. For this, in the opinion of the enemy command, enough forces and imported equipment have been accumulated - first of all, anti-ship missiles and air defense systems - to seriously count on success. If you ask what is good here, I answer: all this, from "a" to "z", is not a secret for anyone, primarily for the command of the Coalition.

Wunderwaffe is not a wonderwaffe

[Chernovec] Every third M777 howitzer has to be taken for repairs after the first artillery duel

Deputy Minister of Defense of Ukraine Sharapov shared his feelings about the tenderness and unreliability of the advertised "three axes", their poor suitability for artillery duels

Gun nodes are damaged by debris from the arrival of shells, which, according to the deputy minister, indicates the fierceness (and effectiveness) of the counter-battery fight.

Sharapov also complained about the problems with the repair of these guns, in particular, the lack of spare parts, since the United States simply did not supply them.

But experts warned back in early May that the Armed Forces of Ukraine would not be able to repair American military equipment.

And this artillery system is very capricious. In the United States, during exercises in range conditions, these howitzers required repairs after an average of 4 days of firing.

Artillery design was sacrificed in order to reduce weight. In combat conditions, this led to many complaints : the

howitzer is too light and fragile for powerful 155 mm ammunition. This led to the fact that the recoil absorption mechanisms in the M777 wear out dangerously quickly in combat conditions

. The American howitzer has serious problems with metal fatigue, instability when firing, the barrel often fails, since the M777 cannot be fired with a rate of fire of more than 2 rounds / min .

Here it must be remembered that India at one time refused the contract for these howitzers, after one fell apart during demonstration firing. Moreover, there were cases of similar destruction in other countries.

Posted by:badanov

#4  Another Russian design principle is that equipment/personnel have a life expectancy. Why bother with repair/rebuild/refurbish if you are going to just expend it anyway? Certainly cuts down on log tails. If you have no problem with 'burning through your manpower and equipment' in the first couple of waves, the degree of finesse in that equipment or troop skills is much lower.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2022-06-20 13:32  

#3  ^^ Word.
Posted by: badanov   2022-06-20 12:08  

#2  More than you probably wanted to know about the M-777

BLUF: Every design is a compromise. This time, it is weight vs continuous fire.

The M-777 was designed to be a lightweight howitzer that could be transported by helo in the mountains of Afghanistan. The use case is sniping at clusters of jihadis, so fire rate is not important.

In Ukraine, the game is protracted (if not continuous) rounds of artillery ping-pong. The important parameters are continuous fire rate and range. Having to take tubes offline for repair is not good.

One big difference between the US vs Russian styles of war is maintenance. We assume the tools, manuals, and spare parts will be readily available. Classic Russian equipment is designed to be fixed in the field by semi-literate peasant conscripts with no Pep Boys around for 500 kilometers.
Posted by: SteveS   2022-06-20 12:01  

#1  Any objective observers out there that can verify this about the M777?
Posted by: AlmostAnonymous5839   2022-06-20 11:04  

00:00