You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
General Milley: ‘What You Saw Unfold' with Afghanistan Evacuation Was One of the Plans'
2021-09-05
[Breitbart] During an interview with Fox News National Security Correspondent Jennifer Griffin aired on Saturday’s "Fox Report," Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Mark Milley said that the speed of the collapse of Afghanistan’s military and government was a surprise, and "what you saw unfold with this noncombatant evacuation operation was one of the contingency plans." And "There was an extensive amount of planning in this."

Milley said, [relevant remarks begin around 2:20] "I think a couple of things. One, is the collapse of the Afghan Army happened at a much faster rate and very unexpected, by pretty much everybody, and then with that is the collapse of the Afghan government. So, that was definitely a surprise. But I will say that there was an awful lot of planning done, ROC drills, rehearsals, etc. And what you saw unfold with this noncombatant evacuation operation was one of the contingency plans. And the speed at which it was executed, the flow of the aircraft, we had planes taking off every 30 to 45 minutes or so. We had — we brought in 7,000 — or 6,000 U.S. troops, and then there [were] about a thousand or more or so Afghan troops that secured HKIA. The first day, it was clearly chaotic, no question about it. You saw that on video, etc. But within about 24 hours, that settled down and it became a much more orderly process. The security of HKIA was challenging to say the least, and we saw the bombing. But that would have happened no matter where it was. People talk about Bagram, wherever there’s a perimeter, if there’s no outside force, if there’s no Afghan force securing it, and there wasn’t any, then there’s going to be U.S. forces on the perimeter, on the edge. And they were doing what they were asked to do, which is go out and screen and process people."

He continued, "So, were there — there’s a lot of lessons learned. And I think we’re going to go through that in a very systematic way.
Posted by:Besoeker

#16  By the way Dale, before MacArthur became General he did some rather amazing things in battle.
Posted by: Ebbomoger Speaking for Boskone4589   2021-09-05 19:17  

#15  Dale,

So you want the General who is over the entire theater on the front lines where they can get shot which would give he enemy a victory and to demoralize your own troops??????? (good lord!)
Posted by: Ebbomoger Speaking for Boskone4589   2021-09-05 19:14  

#14  I think it’s safe to say Milley is Biden’s stooge
The only question is how low will be to.
Posted by: Lonzo Hapsburg5562   2021-09-05 15:47  

#13  The Vets I have talked to(who were there) said "I have returned" MacArthur arrived after the shooting stopped. Milley has a similar look to him but he was never there. As with MacArthur he had his hand picked news sources who fed him only positive information it seems.
Posted by: Dale   2021-09-05 15:19  

#12  Yeah, even with the worst of luck, they couldn't have screwed it up that badly without a plan.
Posted by: Abu Uluque   2021-09-05 15:08  

#11  Well I guess a royal fuck up is a plan... in a retarded sort of way.
Posted by: DarthVader   2021-09-05 12:38  

#10  (BAF) Biden Administration of Fools threw General Custer under the C-130. Either take the spear to deflect the wrath from Biden or we will demote you to private.
Posted by: Ebbomoger Speaking for Boskone4589   2021-09-05 12:08  

#9  #7 He wasn't relieved because we needed a hero at the time. I believe the term is "failing upwards."
Posted by: Matt   2021-09-05 12:05  

#8  "So, were there — there’s a lot of lessons learned. And I think we’re going to go through that in a very systematic way."

When the official AAR was put together by CALL of lessons learned in Desert Storm it was held up for months by the commander TRADOC because he wanted a separate 'happy and glad' report. It actually took the prodding of the GAO to get it released over the obstruction.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2021-09-05 11:46  

#7  When MacArthur became the Philippines' senior military official, he scrapped Plan Orange which called for retiring to the Bataan peninsula with supplies and stores. He instead insisted upon meeting the enemy on the landing beaches. He failed to inspect the development of the Philippine army, instead listening to 'yes' men he put in place. The the Japanese army invaded, the leaders in the field desperately tried to execute the new plan only to be undermined by an ill trained, ill equipped army lacking communications for mobile operations. Weeks were lost moving anything into the peninsula. When they did it was all too like what you witnessed in Kabul. So, yeah, technically it sort of followed the original Plan Orange, but without the substance of the plan. He should have been relieved like Short and Kimmel in Hawaii.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2021-09-05 11:42  

#6  I think we are going to need a steel gallows at Leavenworth in 2025...
Posted by: M. Murcek   2021-09-05 10:18  

#5  So... you planned to run screaming like a little girl with your tail between your legs?

And this fool is the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff?
Posted by: CrazyFool   2021-09-05 09:44  

#4  If you didn't expect the Afghan army to fall apart, then you haven't been paying attention for twenty years. I would think the Iraqis in Mosul would have shown y'all what could happen when you aren't propping them up.
Posted by: Chris   2021-09-05 09:26  

#3  As the old saying goes..... 'when you're splaining, you're losing.'
Posted by: Besoeker   2021-09-05 08:09  

#2  Looking up as black eye begins to form, "I meant to do that..."
Posted by: M. Murcek   2021-09-05 07:54  

#1  "Panicking and fleeing while screaming" is also a commonly used plan, general.
Posted by: magpie   2021-09-05 02:17  

00:00