[WASHINGTONTIMES] America’s most iconic youth organizations — the Boy Scouts of America and the Girl Scouts of the USA — have been jolted by unprecedented one-year drops in membership, due partly to the pandemic, and partly to social trends that have been shrinking their ranks for decades.I think it was the social trends that dunnit.
Membership for the BSA’s flagship Cub Scouts and Scouts BSA programs dropped from 1.97 million in 2019 to 1.12 million in 2020, a 43% plunge, according to figures provided to The News Agency that Dare Not be Named. Court records show membership has fallen further since then, to about 762,000.
The Girl Scouts say their youth membership fell by nearly 30%, from about 1.4 million in 2019- 2020 to just over 1 million this year.
Both groups, like several other U.S. youth organizations, have experienced declining membership for many years. The Girl Scouts reported youth membership of about 2.8 million in 2003. The BSA had more than 4 million boys participating in the 1970s.
Reasons for the drop include competition from sports leagues, a perception by some families that they are old-fashioned, and busy family schedules. The pandemic brought a particular challenge.
In Lawrence, New Jersey, 8-year-old Joey Yaros stopped attending meetings while most in-person gatherings were shut down, and might not go back, even though his father and three brothers all earned the elite Eagle Scout rank. Joey was already struggling with virtual school classes, and the family didn’t pressure him to also participate in virtual Cub Scout activities.
"If there are den meetings in the fall, we’ll see if he gets back in the swing of it," said his father, high school history teacher Jay Yaros. "There are a lot of interesting things for kids to do these days, and scouting doesn’t seem to be keeping up."
The Boy Scouts’ problems are compounded by their decision to seek bankruptcy protection in February 2020 to cope with thousands of lawsuits filed by men who allege they were molested as youngsters by scout leaders. The case is proceeding slowly in federal bankruptcy court as lawyers negotiate the creation of a trust fund for victims that will likely entail hundreds of millions of dollars in contributions from the BSA and its 252 local councils.
To provide those funds, some councils may have to sell cherished camp properties, the BSA’s president and CEO, Roger Mosby, told the AP.
"We understand that this is a difficult and often emotional decision, but in some instances may be a necessary step as we work toward our shared imperatives of equitably compensating survivors and continuing Scouting’s mission." Mosby said in a written reply to AP’s queries.
The pandemic, the membership drop and rising costs of liability insurance have strained BSA finances. A disclosure statement in the bankruptcy case says its gross revenues dropped from $394 million in 2019 to $187 million last year.
In response, the Boy Scouts’ annual youth membership fee will rise from $66 to $72 on August 1. The BSA also says some councils may merge to consolidate resources.
The Girl Scouts have bureaucratic complications of their own. There is ongoing litigation pitting the national headquarters against two of the 111 local councils- based in Fairbanks, Alaska, and Nashville, Tennessee - which refuse to implement a nationwide technology platform.
Despite the varied challenges, Mosby and other Boy Scout officials, as well as the Girl Scouts’ leadership, insist there’s reason for optimism. They say their summer camps are full, special events are sold out, and they’re expecting many thousands of families — some new to scouting, some who left during the pandemic — to sign up now that activities are occurring in-person rather than virtually.
"We knew some girls would take a pause," said Girl Scouts spokeswoman Kelly Gay Pareei. "But as the pandemic goes in the rear-view mirror, we’ve seen a substantial rebound... We feel really good going into the fall recruitment."
Membership in the Boy Scouts’ Longhorn Council, which serves parts of Central and North Texas, dropped by 44% from 2019 to 2020, said its chief executive, Wendy Shaw. But she is buoyed by surging interest this year from families considering their first foray into scouting; the council has scheduled 12 special events for them.
Manny Ramos, chief executive of the BSA’s Seattle-area council, said pandemic-related restrictions on group activities were rigorous in his area — a factor in recruiting only 500 scouts last fall instead of the normal 3,000 or more. To maintain interest, his staff held numerous outdoor activities, including winter camping, and now anticipates a large influx of families who skipped scouting last year.
There was an enormous stink a few years ago about the Boy Scouts allowing openly gay scout leaders. If I recall correctly (and I do) I said to wait for the lawsuits from outraged parents. Confession: I quit the Boy Scouts after my first camping trip. I was still too young for that stuff. I doubt if I was the only kid in the country who was scared off. And I wasn't approached by the scout leader -- it was the other kids.
The Girl Scouts' problem is slightly different, not that I have any idea what goes on in girls' camping trips. But I expected membership to drop about the time they decided to become a branch of Planned Parenthood.
My granddaughter (twelve years old, about the same age I was then) is a member of the Scouts BSA. I'm not sure what the B stands for anymore; it used to be Boy Scouts of America, but they now take both sexes. I was initially against the both sexes idea, but once I thought about it for awhile it made more sense. The idea of tossing a salad of kids approaching or arriving at the stage of sexual curiosity hath its own dangers, but mixed sexes also means mixed leadership. That means they can keep an eye on each other, which I would expect to introduce a safety factor.
Related:
Boy Scouts: 2020-12-03 Anne Has a Plan
Boy Scouts: 2020-11-17 Good afternoon
Boy Scouts: 2020-11-17 More than 80,000 sexual abuse claims expected against US Boy Scouts
Boy Scouts: 2020-12-03 Anne Has a Plan
Boy Scouts: 2020-11-17 Good afternoon
Boy Scouts: 2020-11-17 More than 80,000 sexual abuse claims expected against US Boy Scouts