You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Great Cultural Revolution
The Human Need To Feel Important -- and How Government Squelches It
2021-03-16
[Townhall] If one were to draw up a list of human needs, food and shelter would be at the top.

With great respect to Freudians, sex would not be No. 2.

The need for meaning would be second only to the need for food.

That meaning is more important to happiness than sex is easily shown. A great many people go long periods without sex, and while many of them miss it, if they have meaning in their lives, they can lead quite happy and fulfilling lives. On the other hand, few people who have regular sex but lack meaning are happy or fulfilled.

Third on the list of human needs is the need to feel important. This need is much less often cited than the need for food, sex and meaning. But it is so important that a case could be made that it is tied for No. 2 with the need for meaning.

The infamous "midlife crisis" is a crisis of importance: "I thought I would be much more important at this stage in life than I am." That mostly afflicts men -- just as feeling less important after one's children have left home afflicts mothers more than fathers.

Among the many psycho-social crises afflicting Americans is a crisis of importance. Fewer Americans feel important than did Americans in the past.

Why? What has happened?

What has happened is a steep decline in the number of institutions that gave people a feeling of importance.

Given that work is generally regarded as one of the most ubiquitous providers of purpose, and that, prior to the COVID-19 lockdown, more Americans were working than ever before, one would think that more Americans than ever before felt important.

It has not turned out that way. For many, work has not provided the sense of importance people expected it to, let alone fulfilled the other great need: for meaning. This is especially true for women, but first, we will address men.

Work used to provide many men with a sense of importance. It is simply a fact that being the breadwinner for a family means one is important. However, since the 1970s and the rise of feminism, women have not only become breadwinners, but they have increasingly become the primary breadwinner within a marriage and for a family. That has helped couples financially, but it has also deprived a great many men of their sense of importance. When regarded by a wife and children as important, husbands/fathers felt important. Progressive America mocks the 1950s TV series "Father Knows Best." But when wives and children believed that, men felt important because they were. The price for this, according to feminism, was paid by women, who didn't receive the accolades of breadwinning. And they set about changing it.

Yet, to progressives, government is, or should be, almost everything in people's lives. It should take care of as many people as possible. However, at a massive price: The more one relies on the government, the more one will inevitably lack a sense of importance.

This ideal was announced at the 2012 Democratic Party Convention, when the narrator of a specially-created Barack Obama campaign-theme video asserted, "Government is the only thing that we all belong to." The DNC also showed a fictional storybook ad titled "The Life of Julia." It portrayed a woman from childhood to old age, wholly dependent on the government. Despite her having a child, there was not a man anywhere in the story, nor, apparently, was there a man in her life. The result? More and more American women have come to rely on the government, not on a husband. The results have been calamitous.

President Joe Biden repeated this theme last week: "Put trust and faith in our government," he pleaded with Americans. One could accurately say that we are replacing America's motto, "In God We Trust," with, "In Government We Trust."

The bigger the government, the fewer the institutions in which people can feel important. Therefore, given the deep human need to feel important, people will look elsewhere for their importance -- like fighting systemic racism, heteronormativity, capitalism, patriarchy and transphobia. And, most of all, global warming -- because you cannot feel more important than when you believe you are saving the world.

Posted by:Besoeker

#7  Being Karen makes you feel important. Worrying about the environment, systemic racism and pronouns makes you feel important. It’s a form of morality you can take refuge in after abandoning everything of real importance.
Posted by: Speng Snaviting6874   2021-03-16 16:28  

#6  People can invent all sorts of silly things to "need" when not starving.
Posted by: magpie   2021-03-16 13:32  

#5  #4 You believe that the process is reversible?
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2021-03-16 13:32  

#4  RE #3: While government may be a necessary evil, keeping it limited in scope is essential. All governments tend to grow, in order to expand and feel even more important. Keeping it trimmed back is the constant work of patriots. It hasn't worked well since the beginning of the 20th century, and the government we have now is the result. We need a MAJOR pruning, perhaps even some uprooting and clearing, in order to return to what little government we truly need.
Posted by: Old Patriot   2021-03-16 12:54  

#3  ^But, frequently, necessary.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2021-03-16 08:29  

#2  Man is fundamentally hierarchical, tribal and territorial.

A lot of people just want to be left alone in a benign environment. Government (to impose one's power on others) is seldomly benign.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2021-03-16 07:16  

#1  Therefore, given the deep human need to feel important, people will look elsewhere for their importance....

"Looking elsewhere" (avoid examining the governmental process) is the goal of government. Simply stay within your row and continue to pick. Important, like-minded people, people within the beltway, the media, and Hollywood will decide your concerns and needs.

Young people awaiting birth, and old people waiting to pass on are not important. Only the deciders are important.

Posted by: Besoeker   2021-03-16 05:59  

00:00