You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Signs, Portents, and the Weather-
The Geopolitics of American Fear
2020-03-18
Hattip Alaska Paul. Long, historic perspective, and elaborates on the Churchillian observation, “Americans will always do the right thing, after exhausting all the alternatives.” A taste:
[PeterZeihan] Third, Americans are cocky. When your national founding myth is one of achievement with minimal adversity, it is eaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaasy to become convinced you are the Chosen People and life is simply about navigating oneself from success to success. Of course, I think we all realize this isn’t how things actually work. From time to time something or someone punches you in the face. And when that happens to Americans, we absolutely, positively, lose our shit.

Americans have no sense of proportion. The same thing that gives us our can-do optimism and arrogance means that when we face unexpected challenge we fear the covenant with God has been broken and doom doesn’t so much beckon, but instead will crash down upon us presently. And so we panic. We overreact. But we overreact with the power of the world’s largest and most stable and most technologically advanced economy. We overreact with the strength of a continent. We overreact with the world’s most powerful long-range military, a military that absolutely controls all global waterways. And in doing so we reshape the world. Not on purpose, but simply as a side effect of our panic.

Apparently, viruses can trigger America’s fear-response too.

In the past 96 hours the United States has gone from functionally zero actions against coronavirus
...the twenty first century equivalent of bubonic plague, only instead of killing off a third of the population of Europe it kills 3.4 percent of those who notice they have it. It seems to be fond of the elderly, especially Iranian politicians and holy men...
to among the world’s most invasive. And unlike other countries ‐ China comes to mind ‐ who have only instituted constraints on specific areas where there are known coronavirus outbreaks, the Americans have instituted their restrictions nationwide. America now hosts the largest population in the world under lockdown.

The speed and depth of the change is something only Americans can culturally manage, and this is only the beginning.

The scale of resource application that is about to occur is nothing less than historically unprecedented, rivaled only by American actions in previous fear-response incidences.
  • The Federal Reserve’s new bond-buying program to support the markets? Its only analogue is what the same Federal Reserve did back during the 2008 Financial crisis, but this time it was done in a day instead of a month.

  • The industrial plant’s re-tooling to make medical supplies? Completely unprecedented…unless you compare it to America’s post-Sputnik industrial overhaul.

  • Want to see something really impressive? Watch the process for crafting, manufacturing and distributing the coronavirus vaccine. The US just [started] human trials on March 16. That’s a solid two months faster than any such trials, ever.

Americans are capable of incredible ideological, economic, technological, logistical, military, and cultural leaps when the panic sets in. The coronavirus
...the twenty first century equivalent of bubonic plague, only instead of killing off a third of the population of Europe it kills 3.4 percent of those who notice they have it. It seems to be fond of the elderly, especially Iranian politicians and holy men...
crisis is by no means anywhere close to being over, but the switch has been flipped. Now comes mobilization.

These are "merely" things the United States is doing at home. With a few weeks (maybe days?) the Americans are going to do what they’ve done during every other fear-response. Apply (perhaps unfairly) that fear to all aspects of all of their international relationships.
Posted by:trailing wife

#13   Anyone been watching the talk shows?

You mean like The View? Though I think them as more harping than talking...
Posted by: CrazyFool   2020-03-18 21:35  

#12  ^ Anyone been watching the talk shows? I confess I haven't (almost never do), but that'd probably be a better predictor of togetherness than whatever we might notice locally.
Posted by: Oscar Bluetooth4930   2020-03-18 20:45  

#11  In the past wars brought the nation together. Hopefully the silver-lining of the virus will be that it brings the nation together again.
Posted by: ruprecht   2020-03-18 18:56  

#10  So when do we (U.S.) start reopening everything? ANybody have a plan for how to get out of this thing?

Unless it's 'elect anybody but Trump and we'll fix it then'.
Posted by: Bobby   2020-03-18 16:31  

#9  (iii) This is a good shakedown cruise to prepare for the real thing... and for any and all disasters coming down the pike. It should also change a bunch of national conversations as the sillier among us come to terms with their experience facing the gods of the copybook headings.
Posted by: trailing wife   2020-03-18 15:11  

#8  ^
(1) Not talking about minorities: ethnic, or sexual - f*ck them all, and their sense of entitlement, with a broom handle. Talking about oddballs people who think differently & follow different lifestyle.
(2) Right now it takes a great deal of nonconformist bravery fir one to stand up and call bullshit on this pseudo-pandemic that is clearly not much worse than a bad flu season

(i) Don't be so sure it's not much worse than flu.
(ii) It's an opportunity to correct 30 years of wrong policy toward China.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2020-03-18 08:55  

#7  Grom - I don't deny that we "tolerate outsiders." Political tolerance and a strong legal framework for preserving minority rights is not at all incompatible with what I said, which pertains to the overall cultural predilections of most people.

That culture can be heavily religious and still zealously protect the rights of atheists and religious minorities, for example.

Right now it takes a great deal of nonconformist bravery fir one to stand up and call bullshit on this pseudo-pandemic that is clearly not much worse than a bad flu season. I don't see much aptitude or desire for such truth-telling in either our political or our popular cultures right now.

YMMV.
Posted by: Lex   2020-03-18 08:37  

#6  Don't be frightened of coronavirus, be proud of the response
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2020-03-18 04:20  

#5  #1 Bull Lex. USA - even compared to Israel - is incredibly tolerant to outliers: the odd, the unconventional, the surly curmudgeon. And since all progress comes from such people ...
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2020-03-18 03:50  

#4  The industrial plant’s re-tooling to make medical supplies? Completely unprecedented…unless you compare it to America’s post-Sputnik industrial overhaul.

Not WWII?
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2020-03-18 03:47  

#3  Victor Davis Hanson on our absurd over-reaction:

Last week, Ohio governor Mike DeWine, in heartfelt worry and with understandable concern, tweeted a statement from his state Director of Health: “I know it is hard to understand #COVID19 since we can’t see it, but we know that 1 percent of our population is carrying this virus today—that’s over 100,000 people.”

In translation, that would mean that DeWine and the director already also “know” that somewhere between 1,000 to 2,500 elderly Ohioans of that infected 100,000 right now, at a minimum (if the case load stays at the static figure of 100,000 and the current death ratios are accurate), are infected and will die in the next one to three weeks. At the time of the governor’s disclosure, there were five known cases of corona virus reported in the state.
Posted by: Lex   2020-03-18 02:50  

#2  Why the fook are we destroying our economy and with it our children's hopes of getting jobs, building savings, starting families?

Just so we can lower the mortality rate from 99.98% to 99.92%?

Have we lost our minds?
Posted by: Lex   2020-03-18 02:38  

#1  We are actually not an individualistic culture.

Americans again and again show themselves to be conformists above all, with an instinctive talent for organizing that just as often manifests as drone-like getting in line-- and toeing the line. This allows us to pull off Grand feats of engineering and business success, but it's frankly a bit scary how quickly Americans are willing to follow their less-than-brilliant leaders' directives.

By what right, exactly, do all our little Mussolinis - in Champaigne IL and NYC and across the land - assume authority to lock down anyone?
Posted by: Lex   2020-03-18 02:35  

00:00