You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
The Palestinian delusion
2020-01-20
[Arutz 7] - "From beginning to end, the conflict with Israel is all about Islam," writes world-renowned jihad watcher Robert Spencer in his latest superlative book, The Palestinian Delusion: The Catastrophic History of the Middle East Peace Process. He documents in detail how jihadists and their allies worldwide have skillfully weaponized an invented Palestinian Arab identity against the Zionist struggle for a Jewish state.

Spencer dissects a decades-old "propaganda success that Josef Goebbels and the editors of Pravda would have envied," namely the global myth that Palestinians are an "indigenous population." So declare institutions like the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR), while Palestinian leaders fantasize about a "link between the ancient Canaanites or Jebusites and the modern-day Palestinians." In reality, Roman occupiers in 134 first derived the name Palestine after the "Israelites’ ancient enemies, the Philistines," in order to eradicate the identity of defeated Jewish rebels. The self-named "Palestinians" descend from the Arabs who invaded in the 7th century.

In subsequent centuries most Jews entered diaspora exile, leaving their ancestral homeland to decay under largely disinterested imperialists such as various Muslim powers following seventh-century Arab conquest. Mark Twain's 1869 travelogue The Innocents Abroad thus states that "Palestine sits in sackcloth and ashes." Historian William B. Ziff wrote in 1938 that at the 20th century’s beginning Palestine's 40,000 Jews "and about 140,000 others of all complexions...had no other feeling for this pauperized, diseased-ridden country than a fervent desire to get away."

This wasteland transformed when Zionist Jews, beginning in the 1880s, sought to reestablish a Jewish state. Their regional development investment ironically increased the Arab population which came seeking employment. Particularly the League of Nations Palestine Mandate entrusted to Britain in 1922 as a "Jewish national home" on territory lost by the collapsing Ottoman Empire in World War I witnessed significant Arab immigration.

Egyptian, North African, Syria, and even Ethiopian names among Arabs evince immigration waves into what the British and Zionist institutions (e.g. the Palestine Post newspaper, now Israel’s Jerusalem Post) then called Palestine. "Most 'indigenous' people of Palestine, like Los Angelenos, seem to have come from somewhere else," Spencer writes. Contrastingly, during this "period, the Arabs of Palestine generally considered themselves to be Syrians, and Palestine to be Southern Syria" and rejected any foreign Palestine designation.


Posted by:g(r)omgoru

#4  Dragging up truly ancient history does nobody any good. Just like talking about pre-1947 borders is stupid. They are completely and utterly irrelevant to the matter at hand. The question of if the Palestinians have any claim to any part of Israel is not relevant. They lost a war. They cannot enforce their claim. They must now accept that reality or accept that they will live and die in the miserable poverty of tiny settlements on the edge of the borders between Israel and its neighbors. End of story. If the Palestinians were able to accept their defeat and culturally move on, they would not be so badly off. It is because they focus on their own version of ancient events that they cannot move on.
Posted by: Vernal Hatrick   2020-01-20 12:48  

#3  Ah, yes, the Philistines.

Posted by: Abu Uluque   2020-01-20 12:41  

#2  Mark Twain traveled through the area prior to the Zionist movement and found it mostly empty. I believe the Jews came and the area prospered and Arabs followed.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2020-01-20 09:55  

#1  Most 'indigenous' people of Palestine, like Los Angelenos, seem to have come...

Goddammit, I knew it !
Posted by: Dron66046   2020-01-20 04:41  

00:00