You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Syria-Lebanon-Iran
Iran and America are suddenly both naked
2020-01-09
[Tabletmag] Iran’s ability to respond to the U.S. was already limited by the fact that its conventional military forces are old and rusting away. Yes, IRGC speedboats can harass, and target, the U.S. Navy in the Persian Gulf. But it can’t move large land forces into Iraq, never mind drop them into Florida or Alaska.

A good measure of Iran’s military weakness is that Qassem Soleimani was commander not of its regular army but rather the Quds Force, the expeditionary unit of Iran’s parallel military structure, the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC). The Quds Force is relatively small, with estimates ranging from 3,000 to 15,000 fighters–i.e., a force the size of Hezbollah. For protracted campaigns like the Syria war, the Quds Force relies on what Israeli analyst Shimon Shapira calls the Shiite International—paid militias drawn from Middle East and Central Asian countries with Shiite populations, like Lebanon, Iraq, Syria and Afghanistan.

The threat that Iran poses to a superpower America is “asymmetric”—kidnappings, embassy attacks, hijackings, bombings, etc., typically conducted by Iranian proxies. The military experts and political scientists who coined the term usually fail to note that the ability to wage “asymmetric” warfare is wholly dependent on an adversary’s willed blindness. If Iran’s targets decide to unsubscribe to the fiction that the Islamic Republic is not directly responsible for the actions of its proxies, Iran is rendered virtually powerless–with terror attacks being met with direct military hits on Iranian bases, airfields, ports, power plants, dams, and other infrastructure.

It is only because Americans and other Western powers have declined to call out Iran and have instead appeased it, that an obscurantist regime whose major exports are energy, pistachios—and terror, of course—appears like a formidable adversary.

In making Iran accountable, Trump has knocked Iran down to its natural size—and likely made Americans safer from Iranian aggression than they have in fact been at any point in the last 40 years, during which Iranian proxies have repeatedly killed large numbers of Americans. Killing Soleimani is a much more important operation than those targeting ISIS leader al-Baghdadi and even bin Laden, since it will likely shape the future actions of a state, not the leadership rotation of terror groups.
Posted by:3dc

#7  We can only hope.
Posted by: Whiskey Mike   2020-01-09 17:52  

#6  The message Trump sent with the Soleimani strike is the exact opposite of the message the US sent by negotiating with the Taliban.

Will the Trump administration now whack a couple of Taliban who were thought to be off limits due to political considerations and start a unilateral, precipitous withdrawal?
Posted by: Elmerert Hupens2660   2020-01-09 15:53  

#5  the ability to wage “asymmetric” warfare is wholly dependent on an adversary’s willed blindness.

Part and parcel of the problem with treating acts of terror as civil law violations. "Everyone knows Y is a proxy for X, but do we have *proof* X was involved?". By whacking Soleimani, Trump just short-circuited that nonsense. I'd be surprised if future Iranian attempts to invoke plausible deniability were not met head-on with an American (or Israeli) response.
Posted by: SteveS   2020-01-09 11:49  

#4  The military experts and political scientists who coined the term usually fail to note that the ability to wage “asymmetric” warfare is wholly dependent on an adversary’s willed blindness.

Or, in case of Israel, external constraints.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2020-01-09 07:26  

#3  
Posted by: Creamble Omomonter4968   2020-01-09 07:08  

#2  
Posted by: Creamble Omomonter4968   2020-01-09 06:52  

#1  
Posted by: Jack Barnsmell4237   2020-01-09 06:50  

00:00