You have commented 358 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Submit your comments on this article
Home Front: WoT
Appeals court rules Brooklyn federal judge went easy on ISIS wannabe
2019-12-30
[NYPost] An appeals court ruled Friday that a Brooklyn Federal judge went easy on an ISIS-terrorist wannabe by giving him a “shockingly low” 17-year sentence, according to court papers.
Your supervisor would like to make it very clear that he is not in the least bot pleased with you. Or more briefly: You screwed up; fix it.
Judge Margo K. Brodie
...an Obama nominee born in Antigua...
sentenced Fareed Mumuni
...the nice college boy whose name was also reported as Fereed Mumuni and Freed Mumuni, who through co-conspirator Munther Omar Saleh (sentenced to 18 years) was connected to Junaid Hussain, the ISIS recruiter/hacker/English footballer previously known for marrying elderly rocker chick Sally Jones before being droned in Raqqa. Their little cell of six included Nader Saadeh (sentenced to 10 years after being arrested in Jordan), Alaa Saadeh (sentenced to 10 years) — the Saadeh lads being dual citizens with Jordan, whose parents were expelled a decade earlier for credit card fraud — half-Jewish convert Samuel Rahamin Topaz (sentenced to 8 years), and youngster Imran Rabbani (sentenced to 20 months)...
in February 2017 after the failed terrorist was convicted of trying to provide support for ISIS and for stabbing an FBI agent on Staten Island 2015.

Circuit Judge Jose A. Cabranes said Friday that the sentence meted out to Mumuni, 23, was 80% below the advisory guidelines of 85 years — and he sent the ruling back to the lower court for possible resentencing.
Given the sentences received by the other lads from this judge, more resentencings will likely appear on the docket in the near future.
Prosecutors in June 2018 had asked that Mumuni receive 85 years. His lawyer argued that he should get much less time because he was a victim of ISIS recruiters.
That’s certainly one perspective.
Brodie called the idea of 85 years “excessive” at the sentencing and cited Mumuni’s age and lack of criminal record in her decision.

“This clearly erroneous assessment of the evidence leaves us with the definite and firm conviction that a mistake has been committed,” Cabranes wrote for the majority in the new ruling. “[It was] a mistake that resulted in a shockingly low sentence that, if upheld, would damage the administration of justice in our country.”
Related:
Fareed Mumuni: 2017-02-11 Queens ISIS wannabe pleads guilty to attacking FBI agent with a knife in the name of the terror group
Related:
Fereed Mumuni: 2017-02-11 Queens ISIS wannabe pleads guilty to attacking FBI agent with a knife in the name of the terror group
Fereed Mumuni: 2015-06-18 Feds: NYC man tried to stab agent during ISIS-related probe
Related:
Freed Mumun: 2017-02-11 Queens ISIS wannabe pleads guilty to attacking FBI agent with a knife in the name of the terror group
Freed Mumun: 2015-06-19 Fourth alleged IS suspect arrested in New York area
Related:
Junaid Hussain: 2018-02-08 College student is jailed for 18 years after helping ISIS plot a pressure-cooker bomb attack on New York City
Junaid Hussain: 2017-12-20 Man gets 28 years in plot to behead conservative blogger
Junaid Hussain: 2017-09-21 Trial opens for final American in Islamic State-linked police beheading plot
Related:
Nader Saadeh: 2018-05-01 Man faces sentencing for assisting in terror plot
Nader Saadeh: 2015-08-12 Jordanian-U.S. Suspect Nabbed in NY Area IS Ring
Related:
Munther Omar Saleh: 2018-02-08 College student is jailed for 18 years after helping ISIS plot a pressure-cooker bomb attack on New York City
Munther Omar Saleh: 2017-02-11 Queens ISIS wannabe pleads guilty to attacking FBI agent with a knife in the name of the terror group
Munther Omar Saleh: 2015-06-19 Fourth alleged IS suspect arrested in New York area
Related:
Alaa Saadeh: 2018-05-01 Man faces sentencing for assisting in terror plot
Alaa Saadeh: 2016-05-11 American jailed for 15 years for trying to join ISIS
Alaa Saadeh: 2015-08-12 Jordanian-U.S. Suspect Nabbed in NY Area IS Ring
Related:
Samuel Rahamin Topaz: 2015-06-19 Fourth alleged IS suspect arrested in New York area
Related:
Imran Rabbani: 2016-08-10 N.Y. teen charged in Islamic State probe gets 20 months in prison
Posted by:trailing wife

#4  ...and then a Juris Doctor in 1991, University of Pennsylvania Law School.

It ain't you, Besoeker - Liz Warren was a U Penn from 1987 to 1992. Coincidence?
Posted by: Raj   2019-12-30 09:25  

#3  /\ Is it just me, or is a pattern developing ?
Posted by: Besoeker   2019-12-30 08:33  

#2  Re: Judge Margo K. Brodie. Judge, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York Nominated by Barack Obama on June 7, 2011. Confirmed by the Senate on February 27, 2012. Brodie was born Margo Kitsy Williams in St. John's, Antigua. She earned a B.A. degree in 1988 from St. Francis College, Brooklyn and then a Juris Doctor in 1991, University of Pennsylvania Law School.
She joined the court in 2012 after a nomination from Obama. At the time of nomination, Brodie was an Assistant United States Attorney in the Eastern District of New York, a position she had held since 1999.
Posted by: b   2019-12-30 08:29  

#1  His lawyer argued that he should get much less time because he was a victim of ISIS recruiters.

Seriously?
Posted by: gorb   2019-12-30 00:42  

00:00