| Submit your comments on this article |
| Britain |
| Why is there more intellectual freedom in Bucharest than Cambridge? |
| 2019-11-28 |
| h/t Instapundit [Spectator] ’You can talk about anything you like,’ said Radu, a young Romanian academic when he invited me to a conference in Bucharest. The theme was ’Real liberty or new serfdom?’ marking the anniversary of the fall of Nicolae Ceausescu 30 years ago. The audience was made up of Romanian undergraduates. The keynote speaker, a German federalist, was planning on making the classical liberal case for the EU, which made the title of my lecture ‐ ’The classical liberal case against the EU’ ‐ a no-brainer. But I was nervous when I told Radu what I wanted to talk about. Thirty years ago, Romanians had been ruled by a man who literally gave his critics cancer. Would fears of criticising the powerful die hard in Bucharest? I waited for the explanation that there had a been a mix up, that my lecture would be cancelled, and... ’Excellent!’ replied Radu. ’That’s exactly what we need.’ A week later I was preparing to talk to a student politics society at Cambridge and I suggested the same subject. Only this time I did get the explanation. ’The problem is... we’re looking for something a bit more mainstream.’ Mainstream? But this is broadly the view of 52 per cent of the UK population! ’Right. It’s just that we had a pro-Brexit speaker once and it all got a bit uncomfortable, a bit... controversial.’ Controversial ideas? At a university? Whatever next? He was quite honest about it. It seemed like his society’s director had introduced a policy of no-platforming Brexiteers. I spared him the thoughts crystallising in my mind about Cambridge as the scholarly heart of the English Reformation and the Parliamentarian struggle against arbitrary power. ’Something on China, perhaps?’ he suggested. An authoritarian regime that suppresses free speech. Yes, I can see why that would go down better at Cambridge. Back in Romania, we all got together in a hotel in Bucharest. The German federalist did his thing: Kant, perpetual peace, the brotherhood of Europe like the good old days of the Holy Roman Empire (never mind the Thirty Years’ War). He was asked how he squared this vision with the mess the EU is in today. ’We need to squash down these nation states, that’s the way,’ he said cheerfully. He ended with a flourish, explaining how ’these days, under the EU system, Bratislava for example is a great German, I mean European, city.’ Nervous laughter; polite applause. ...The students in Bucharest were doing what students are supposed to do: hearing each side of the argument. They didn’t show any of the symptoms of intellectual decay that I often encounter among students in the Anglosphere ‐ in particular, using someone’s dissent from progressive orthodoxy to exclude, purge, persecute, or otherwise gain power over them (I mean no-platforming, social-media mobbing or denouncing in an ’open letter’). But there is another malady that afflicts so many of our students, and is often indicative of an authoritarian mindset: they are so boring. |
| Posted by:g(r)omgoru |
| #6 Why is there more intellectual freedom in Bucharest than Cambridge? Easy: having won their freedoms, Romanians appreciate them. The West's PC and Woke crowds haven't the faintest idea of what freedom means, or how it's earned and what it takes to defend it. |
| Posted by: Lex 2019-11-28 17:05 |
| #5 Domo arigato, TW. |
| Posted by: g(r)omgoru 2019-11-28 08:40 |
| #4 Note to self: Don't post before coffee. Fixed. Caffeine in any form is a good thing. |
| Posted by: trailing wife 2019-11-28 08:38 |
| #3 ...kill the student loan program and the invisible hand of the market place will kick in. Toss in the endowments as fully taxable entities and watch the wailing begin. |
| Posted by: Procopius2k 2019-11-28 06:56 |
| #2 So, so sad what's happened to our universities. |
| Posted by: Herb McCoy 2019-11-28 03:13 |
| #1 Note to self: Don't post before coffee. |
| Posted by: g(r)omgoru 2019-11-28 02:45 |