You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Israel-Palestine-Jordan
Netanyahu's secret commitment to Obama
2016-09-17
[Ynet] Analysis: Following Sen. Lindsey Graham's objection to the Memo of Understanding (MOU) signed between US and Israel, the prime minister was forced to write a letter in which Israel pledges not to request any additional aid from the two Houses of Congress

The memorandum of understanding on a military aid package, which was signed in Washington on Wednesday between the American administration and Israel, is a generous move, which points to the B.O. regime's dedication to Israel's security and to its devotion to the commitments he gave Democratic senators during the battle over the nuclear agreement with Iran.
A bribe to Israel to shut up about Iran, and it mollifies those Democrats who still stand with Israel.
Thirty-eight billion dollars is a huge sum, which no other country has received, regardless of how good its relationship with the United States is. This was done by President Barack Obama
I bowled a 129. It’s like — it was like Special Olympics, or something...
, no one else. He deserves gratitude.
That's certainly one perspective...
Nonetheless, the tensions between Jerusalem, the Republican Congress and the White House left their mark on the agreement. Obama sought to put an end, once and for all, to Congress' involvement in the administration's relations with Israel.
He is only a president, not a king. Constitutionally speaking, Congress is required to advise and consent to all arrangements with foreign countries. It is also only Congress that has the power of the purse, not the president. But the package at issue -- $38 billion over ten years starting after the current package ends in 2018 -- would be executed by the next president and the next Congress, so President Obama's little executive plan is not binding on any of the parties after he leaves office. It's vaporware.
He achieved it in the current agreement.
...such a lovely bit of Kabuki theater...
Israel will allegedly not be able to play with the different authorities in Washington, receive something at the White House and then send the Jewish lobby to the senators in an effort to receive more.

After Republican Senator Lindsey Graham
... the endangered South Carolina RINO...
, chairman of the Appropriations Committee, announced that he was not bound by the MOU,
..and so he isn't...
and that he would provide Israel with aid in addition to what it receives in the agreement, the White House threatened to cancel the agreement. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was forced to write a letter which has yet to be published. In this letter, Israel pledges not to request any additional aid from the two Houses of Congress. It provides another commitment: If it receives any aid from Congress without asking for it, it will return the money to the administration.

This is an unusual commitment. On the positive side, it indicates that the two most important political institutions in the world are competing against each other over who will give Israel more; on the negative side, it points to the administration's suspiciousness towards the Israeli government and Israel's friends in Congress.

The agreement also determines that two bonuses that were given to Israel in the previous MOU will be canceled: The allotment of $400 million a year for fuel purchases will be canceled as soon as the agreement takes effect, on October 1, 2018. The allotment of $850 million a year for the IDF's purchases from Israel's defense industries will be canceled gradually. The fuel budget was a nice gift at the time, but is unnecessary now that Israel has become a gas power. The budget for purchases in Israel harmed the American defense industries, so its cancellation is justified.

The Americans should be given credit for not cutting those sums from the total military aid. That means, on a practical level, that Israel will be able to purchase another group of F-35 stealth fighter jets as part of the aid. The aid packages secures Israel's qualitative advantage in the purchase area in the next 12 years. That also applies to the anti-missile defense systems: The agreement puts Congress's allotments for the development of missile plans at the basis of the budget. The sum is identical.

In total, the aid will grow by $200-300 million a year, which is a nice sum but much lower than the sum discussed before Netanyahu's Congress speech. When inflation is taken into account, the sum gets close to the reality today.

In a conversation I had with White House officials Wednesday evening, they stressed that the agreement was flexible. If Israel faces a state of emergency, a war or a serious intifada, discussing an increase in the aid will be possible. The following sentence is my interpretation: All options are on the table, apart from a game between the White House and Congress.
Posted by:trailing wife

#4  The Iranian Bomb is gonna do a metric shitload more damage than 38 billion dollars.
Posted by: Thing From Snowy Mountain   2016-09-17 13:17  

#3  It reads like there is a bidding war is going on for taxpayer money between Congress and the Executive Branch to provide aid.
Posted by: JohnQC   2016-09-17 08:39  

#2  This [agreement] was done by President Barack Obama, no one else. He deserves gratitude.
It reads like there is a bidding war is going on for taxpayer money between Congress and the Executive Branch to provide aid.

I’ll reserve my gratitude for Obama the day he steps down.
Posted by: JohnQC   2016-09-17 08:38  

#1  Since the next admin (whether Hillary or Trump) is not going to respect Obama's commitments...
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2016-09-17 04:59  

00:00