You have commented 358 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
NYT's David Brooks wants concentration camps for the Hoi Poloi
2014-09-21
Maybe a bit unfair on my part.
Not at all. Either he is a wannabe fascist or a pampered fool.
Those are not mutually exclusive choices, particularly these days...
People seem to have a harder time building friendships across class lines. As society becomes more unequal and segmented, invitations come to people on the basis of their job status. Middle-aged people have particular problems nurturing friendships and building new ones. They are so busy with work and kids that friendship gets squeezed out.

So, in the fantasy world in which I have $500 million, I'd try to set up places that would cultivate friendships.
We already have that, it's called "Disneyworld". It even makes money which is more than your fantasy world would do...
I know a lot of people who have been involved in fellowship programs. They made friends that ended up utterly transforming their lives. I'd try to take those sorts of networking programs and make them less career oriented and more profound.
Well, David, you can try your local sports bar on a Monday night...
I simply must introduce him to my friends among the lay Dominican monks. Fellowship, utterly transformed, retreats, across class lines... of course, one must profess to be a practicing Catholic, and the ones I know are all ferociously intelligent, but surely our Mr. Brooks could fake all that for long enough.
Not a chance, the Dominicans would see through him in seconds...
To do that, you have to get people out of their normal hunting grounds where their guard is up. You also probably want to give them challenging activities to do together. Nothing inspires friendship like selflessness and cooperation in moments of difficulty. You also want to give them moments when they can share confidences, about big ideas and small worries.
Translation: Places complete with steroid thugs with search wands
So I envision a string of adult camps or retreat centers (my oldest friendships were formed at summer camp, so I think in those terms).
(Darling, you were twelve. Things are different when one is twelve. Also, all the kids you knew had parents who could afford the expense of summer camp, which means the other kids may have been from far away, but they were in the same demographic as your family.)
Groups of 20 or 30 would be brought together from all social and demographic groups, and secluded for two weeks.
And you can use trucks, paint 'em black and call them something sinister: I know: Black Marias!
What happens to the job and the kids while one is enjoying all that "me time"? There's a reason your Pops kept working while you were at the summer camp of your chilhood.
Job? What job? In this fantasy world Pops is unemployed, on the dole, and waiting for ObamaCare to take care of his broken heart...
They'd prepare and clean up all their meals together, and eating the meals would go on for a while. In the morning, they would read about and discuss big topics.
Translation: yet another "common sense" discussion, which mysteriously winds up a leftist lecture.
Pining after the bull sessions of his callow college years and the summer camp of his boyhood? The poor man must be having a dreadful time in the adult world despite his apparent success.
The 'read and discuss big topics' sounds like an self-criticism session at a corrective labor camp, where the biggest mistake you could possibly make as a kulak is to open your mouth...
In the afternoons, they'd play sports, take hikes and build something complicated together.
Like mining coal or felling trees in the Kolyma...
At night, there'd be a bar and music.
Tell you what, Mr. Brooks: you recreate one of those resorts in the Adirondacks that were so popular with Jewish families from New York City from the Thirties to the Sixties, and see if you can make a going business of it. Surely Mr. Soros and the Ford Foundation would be happy to contribute to your little exercise in guided development for the masses. And if they sponsored a children's camp next door, all worries about the kiddies would be put to rest. Whether the jobs would still be there after a two week sabbatical is a question for another day.
Posted by:badanov

#19  I worry lest Brooks' concentration
On camps doesn't spur conversation:
"Though it's clear you're sincere,
Still I fear we have here
A failure of communication!"
Posted by: Zenobia Floger6220   2014-09-21 23:54  

#18  He'd hobnob, if he had his druthers,
With rednecks and wetbacks and... others.
Upon his recovery,
He'd share his discovery,
"Oh mumsy, all men are Brooks' brothers!"
Posted by: Zenobia Floger6220   2014-09-21 23:36  

#17  Perhaps I am misinformed, it was my impression that the Jewish famlies from NYC vacationed in the Catskills and the Christian families from NYC in the Adirondacks. Well, decades ago, anyhow.
Posted by: TopRev   2014-09-21 22:37  

#16  Hello, Muddah! Hello, Fadduh!
Here I am at Camp Nirvana.
Posted by: Anice Nim   2014-09-21 21:29  

#15  Transporting the participants to the camps in railroad freight cars would help bring people together, too! We could call them re-education camps because everyone would learn so much fun, new stuff. I hear the self-criticism sessions will be killer.

Paging Naftali Frenkel. Mr Frenkel please pick up the white courtesy phone.
Posted by: 11A5S   2014-09-21 20:13  

#14  If the NYT's editorial staff, including Brooks, hadn't made a decades-long career out of calling for dictatorship in the US, it would be particularly revealing that their token "conservative" is calling for government regulation of our social lives.
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2014-09-21 19:35  

#13  Angie, the only people Brooks sees at work are exactly like him. They're all out of the office by the time the cleaning crew is allowed in.
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2014-09-21 19:03  

#12  You also probably want to give them challenging activities to do together...You also want to give them moments when they can share confidences, about big ideas and small worries.

I go to a place like this. It's called "work".
Posted by: Angie Schultz   2014-09-21 17:47  

#11  Rather ironic, considering that most of Mr. Brooks' denizens at the NYT had an active role in demolishing society (then assisting in replacing those demolished social mores with laws - but I digress.) The same NYTers, by the way, who now either live in gated communities outside NYC, or in condos with doormen and security systems.
Posted by: Pappy   2014-09-21 12:42  

#10  Friendships. MEH! They're so 1960ish!
Posted by: AlmostAnonymous5839   2014-09-21 12:08  

#9  Every Wednesday night at our church we sponsor a 'free' dinner to any and all. The rich and poor, homed and homeless, rub elbows and break bread together. David should join a church. In fact, the Hoi Polloi in Washington should all join a church.
Posted by: Total War   2014-09-21 11:50  

#8  He calls for conscription?
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2014-09-21 10:53  

#7  Cool - a multifisk! LOL - pigpile!
Posted by: KBK   2014-09-21 10:08  

#6  Sounds like boot camp for Obama's civilian army.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2014-09-21 09:39  

#5  You want to mingle? Cut all the power lines into your major urban areas, blow the Interstate and rail bridges leading into the same areas (see - Katrina). In a couple of days, you'll have a lot of mingling.
Posted by: Procopius2k   2014-09-21 09:20  

#4  from the same tool that thinks good leadership comes from sharply creased pants
Posted by: Frank G   2014-09-21 08:50  

#3  Things are different when one is twelve

Sorry TW this doesn't apply to this regime or any of their sycophants and tools.


I've got 3 words for this idiot..."Church Bowling Leagues".
Posted by: AlanC   2014-09-21 08:48  

#2  Whoa whoa whoa is Brooks suggesting non like mined people gather together? But how will the IRS and Big GIVERnment be able to know who the bad guys are? Let me guess the two like mined people who will pay for the forced friendship building: taxpayer via big GIVERnment and the Hoi Poloi.

I will agree on one point. The wealthy upper class cronies and the lower class living off the GIVERnment do have a vested interested to get to know each other.
Posted by: Airandee   2014-09-21 08:40  

#1  In the afternoons, they'd play sports, take hikes and build something complicated together.

Set up a security perimeter. Enforce noise and light discipline. Clean weapons, cross-level ammo, redistribute food, care for the wounded, children, and elderly. Continue to move away from population centers and low lying areas.
Posted by: Besoeker   2014-09-21 02:09  

00:00