| Submit your comments on this article |
| Home Front: Culture Wars |
| Academics in Wonderland |
| 2014-01-19 |
| ...Academics are good at theory, not just the theory of riding a bicycle as opposed to the physical act of riding one, but of inhabiting a universe entirely based on that theory. An academic can create a theory in which bicycles cannot be ridden or in which cars have no mass and exist indefinitely in that world. If his theory is trendy enough, if he recruits enough students who become faculty who recruit more students into his peculiar world, the theory will spill over into the real world and begin to affect it. Some insane obsessions that can exist only in academia stay there. The taxpayers finance them, but they rarely have to hear about them except when a tabloid looking for a few inches of column outrage reveals how many millions are being spent on studies on why lesbians drink too much or a professor who has spent his entire career writing papers on the gay subtext of Sears catalogs from the 1950s. Others don't stay there. Our modern obsession with racial subtext is largely the work of academics. Sociology has done more damage to American society than crack cocaine, economists who make a living telling government officials that money can be printed infinitely are a political disease and anything to do with the climate has been so thoroughly contaminated with bad motives and bad science that it might as well involve JFK assassination or moon landing conspiracy theories. Americans got used to the idea that academia was an eccentric place full of wacky professors who occasionally came up with brilliant ideas. This was a convenient myth to cultivate because it obscured the more problematic fact that outside the sciences, the professors were rarely brilliant and their eccentricity wasn't an individual habit, but a collective political reality distortion field. And I wouldn't excempt the sciences nowadays |
| Posted by:g(r)omgoru |
| #4 The insane are leading the blind off a cliff that the blind can't see and that the insane insist isn't there. That sounds like what is currently going on in Washington. History is fairly bleak in regards to academics leading this country. Woodrow Wilson comes to mind as to what happens when Americans leave their common sense and elect a progressive. |
| Posted by: JohnQC 2014-01-19 17:15 |
| #3 Any system which is self selecting runs the danger of inbreeding that actually shuts out creativity and awareness. It's just not academics - see DoD, Air Force fighter mafia and Army Heavy Divisions types didn't actually prep their services for the real war 2001-present - and see how much they want to scramble back to the 'good old days'. |
| Posted by: Procopius2k 2014-01-19 12:14 |
| #2 This was a convenient myth to cultivate because it obscured the more problematic fact that outside the sciences, the professors were rarely brilliant and their eccentricity wasn't an individual habit, but a collective political reality distortion field. A "Collective Political Reality Distortion".... and "convenient myth" which will be cultivated in a similar venue tomorrow. |
| Posted by: Besoeker 2014-01-19 11:34 |
| #1 [O]utside the sciences, the professors were rarely brilliant and their eccentricity wasn't an individual habit, but a collective political reality distortion field Pretty much what one thinks when one reads The American Interest. |
| Posted by: Pappy 2014-01-19 10:40 |