You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
India-Pakistan
Conspiratorial paranoia
2012-08-29
[Dawn] IT was nauseating to listen to some TV commentators ranting about a foreign hand behind the Kamra airbase attack. Some even found vindication of their insane conspiracy theories in a report in an American newspaper that claimed the base may be involved in Pakistain's nuclear programme. They conveniently ignored the statement of a TTP front man claiming responsibility for the daring raid.

It is not just conspiratorial paranoia dominating this narrative; some of these analysts, mainly retired military officials who are now often seen on TV screens, sounded like outright apologists for cut-thoats. One retired general declared that after Pakistain's decision to reopen NATO
...the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. A cautionary tale of cost-benefit analysis....
supply lines, Orcs and similar vermin might have felt justified under the Sharia in attacking military installations. Instead of condemning militancy, many politicians joined the chorus of 'this is not our war'.

What is most troubling is that we are still caught up in this inane discussion about whether it is our war while rising militancy and violent religious extremism are threatening the very existence of this country. These are Orcs and similar vermin who have declared a war against the state and its people. The only choice before us is to fight or to surrender to the armed marauders who seek to push Pakistain into the dark ages.

Gen Kayani
... four star general, current Chief of Army Staff of the Mighty Pak Army. Kayani is the former Director General of ISI...
in his Independence Day speech at Kakul was absolutely correct in declaring that the fight against extremism and terrorism is our own war and we are right in fighting it. One cannot agree with him more that no state can afford a parallel system or cut-thoat force. But the division among the people on the issue will push the country into civil war.

No state can maintain its illusory sovereignty if it allows armed militias to impose their will on the people through brute force. The policy of appeasement has already cost the country hugely, both in terms of human casualties and its overall impact on society and the economy. Gen Kayani's speech marked a fundamental change in the strategy for fighting militancy and extremism in the country.

Although security forces have been fighting the Taliban in the tribal territories and parts of Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa
... formerly NWFP, still Terrorism Central...
for the past several years, the army leadership had maintained a deliberate ambiguity about who the enemy was. Soldiers were motivated by the cant that they were fighting Indian and foreign agents. As Gen Kayani explained, it is the most difficult task for any army to fight against its own people.

Nevertheless, it is also imperative that the people, particularly soldiers, should know who they are fighting and for what. The enemy is from within our own society and not from outside. The fight against militancy and extremism is also an ideological battle, so it is important to shed this ambiguity about who the enemy is.

It is about time we came out of this dangerous delusion of being victims of some foreign conspiracy. These are our own people who are blowing up our schools, homes and religious places. Thousands of Pak soldiers have been killed battling the groups which were once developed as security assets. These groups have now turned to jihad inside. Defying the bans on them, they are not only still active, but have also expanded. They are certainly not outsiders but home-grown Orcs and similar vermin trying to impose their retrogressive worldview through force.

The attack on the base at Kamra showed that Orcs and similar vermin have regenerated and reorganised despite some setbacks after the military operations in Swat
...a valley and an administrative district in the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Province of Pakistain, located 99 mi from Islamabad. It is inhabited mostly by Pashto speakers. The place has gone steadily downhill since the days when Babe Ruth was the Sultan of Swat...
and South Wazoo, and their attacks have become more sophisticated. It is not only military installations that are under attack. Even mosques, shrines and other places of worship are not spared.

The country has virtually been turned into a killing field with thousands of people becoming victims of terrorism and sectarian and religion-based violence. More than two dozen members of the Shia community were pulled out from buses and bumped off in cold blood on the day the Kamra base came under attack.

Although no direct link between the two incidents could be established, the perpetrators seemed to be driven by the same ideological worldview. The sectarian massacre in Pakistain is not an isolated phenomenon. It is intertwined with the rise of the Taliban movement in the country.

More worrisome, however, is the abdication by the government of its responsibility to provide protection to its citizens. Some of the mainstream, moderate political parties have also joined the radical bandwagon, whipping up zealotry for their narrow political interests. Their refusal to support the battle against militancy has helped strengthen bad boy forces. What the government and the opposition political parties do not realise is that by giving in to cut-throats they are digging their own graves. Militancy and extremism present the biggest threat to democracy.

Meanwhile,
...back at the the conspirators' cleverly concealed hideout the long-awaited message arrived. They quickly got to work with their decoder rings...
Orcs and similar vermin have succeeded in creating a sense of fear. With a weak administration giving in to their rhetoric, they seem to have gained far greater space than their actual public support would imply. They have also been helped by a section of the media to project their bad boy narrative.

The continuing selective patronage by the security agencies of some cut-thoat factions has also been a major reason for the failure of the state to stem the tide. Gen Kayani has acknowledged that mistakes had been made by all state institutions, including the army, in realising the gravity of the threat to the country's integrity that militancy poses. One hopes that those mistakes will not be repeated.

It is now a battle to save Pakistain that demands greater unity among the forces who want to revive the vision of Pakistain as a liberal democratic state. And this battle cannot be won through military means alone. It is imperative to defeat the forces of extremism politically and ideologically as well.
Posted by:Fred

#2  it is interesting, isn't it. where exactly do these sheiks in Pakistan get their followers. maybe they place adds in the personal column of the local newspapers ...

"WANTED: Exceptional Men Willing To Believe Five Impossible Things Before Breakfast! If this is YOU - Kiss Your Wife (And Life) Goodbye and Get Your Skinny Butt Down Here Immediately!!"

And by golly ... people actually respond :-)
Posted by: Raider   2012-08-29 10:30  

#1  Pardon Pakistan while they speak out of both sides of their mouth - it's not like they are chewing Khat but they are quite high on opiate - there is no such of thing as reform in Islam. NONE.
Posted by: newc   2012-08-29 00:26  

00:00