Comments

You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name

Your e-mail (optional)

Website (optional)

	My Original Nic Pic-a-Nic Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Foto

Submit your comments on this article

Home Front: WoT

Ed Koch: What I said about terrorism supporters and what Newsweek published

2010-01-25

By Ed Koch

Last week, I received a call from a friend who said, "This week's Newsweek has a picture of you along with a statement that you made about Muslim terrorists. It makes you sound ridiculous."

My statement published in Newsweek was, "Though the vast majority of Muslims aren't terrorists, there are hundreds of millions who are."

I have been interviewed dozens of times on the issue of Islamic terrorism. I believe this quote was taken from my appearance on Jan. 7 on Neil Cavuto's Show on Fox News.

In response to the Newsweek piece, I sent the following e-mail to its editor:

"Your reference to my remarks concerning Muslim terrorists, which appeared in the January 18, 2010, edition of Newsweek, is somewhat misleading.

"My comments concerning Muslim terrorist are well-known. I have often said that there are about 1 billion 200 million Muslims worldwide, and that the vast majority are peace-loving and decry terrorism. Nevertheless, I believe Osama bin Laden is the most popular figure in the worldwide Muslim community. If you estimate that 20 percent of Muslims support terrorism (defined as approving the intentional killing of civilians to achieve political goals) that would add up to more than 200 million Muslim terrorist supporters.

"I concur, as was stated by Abdel Rahman al-Rashad, the head of an Arab television channel who wrote in 2004: 'It is a certain fact that not all Muslims are terrorist, but it is equally certain, and exceptionally painful, that almost all terrorists are Muslims...We cannot clear our names unless we own up to the shameful fact that terrorism has become a Muslim enterprise, an almost exclusive monopoly, implemented by Muslim men and women.'

"In my judgment those facts allow profiling as a reasonable response, and I believe most of our readers have come to a similar conclusion. Why not poll them.

"I am sorry that it did not cross the mid of anyone at Newsweek that my reference was to terrorist supporters, and that a telephone call to verify was not made."

I immediately received the following response from the magazine's letters editor which gratified me.:

"Dear Mayor Koch. We would like to use your letter on Newsweek's letters page. Our policy is to include the writer's name, city, and state, so I wanted to confirm your city and state before we run anything. If you could please reply with that information at your earliest convenience we would greatly appreciate it. Thanks very much."

The following day, I received another e-mail from the letters editor which read:

"Dear Mayor Koch. I'm sorry to inform you that it looks like we won't have a letters page in the magazine this week.

Occasionally we need the space for other content and I just learned this afternoon that we are losing the page this week for that reason. I apologize for any inconvenience."

I thought someone should read my explanation, so I'm burdening you with it and look forward to receiving your opinions on it. What people in public life treasure most is their reputation. I refer to integrity and common sense. At the age of 85, I shall continue to lift my voice and offer my opinions.
Mr. Koch: Here is your letter. Rantburgers: Should you concur, Please disseminate it. Post it/link to it EVERYWHERE..

Posted by:logi_cal

#4 I don't read Newsweek, I can already access DNC press releases on-line.

Posted by: DMFD 2010-01-25 18:09

#3 "...I have often said that there are about 1 billion 200 million Muslims worldwide, and that the vast majority are peace-loving and decry terrorism...."

Sadly, Ed Koch doesn't realize that for a lot of Muslims 'terrorism' does not include infidels being killed by muslims. For a significant number, the very existence of Israel is an act of terrorism, the fact that US troops are in Afghanistan is terrorism, the fact that the Caliphate was overthrown is terrorism, the fact that Spain is not islamic is terrorism, etc.

Posted by: lord garth 2010-01-25 11:39

#2 Koch erred only in one respect. You cannot win a fight by being purely defensive, in this case, just defending against the slander without challenging the attacker.

Instead, a few inquiries would have led to the discovery of the individuals, the people, at Newsweek who were personally responsible for the slander.

By personally implicating them, the dual purpose is made that to maintain its credibility (what little if any it retains), Newsweek needs to downsize such individuals; and as fair warning to others that Newsweek tolerates such slander, *and* that it must be assumed that the named persons will do so in the future, so should not be trusted.

Posted by: Anonymoose 2010-01-25 09:22

#1 Mr. Koch describes Newsweek's caption as "somewhat misleading." I would describe Mr. Koch's statement as "somewhat charitable."

The difference between 200K terrorism supporters/enablers/apologists versus 200K terrorists is so vast that Newsweek's caption cannot be dismissed as stupidity or carelessness.

Posted by: Free Radical 2010-01-25 09:17

00:00