| Submit your comments on this article |
| Israel-Palestine-Jordan |
| IDF insubordination can save Israel |
| 2009-12-02 |
| IT IS a mistake to think that the state works within the boundaries of laws. The public does not obey laws. It obeys rules within the boundaries of a triangle, the first side of which is the law. But the triangle has two other sides: common sense and ethics. What if the Knesset passed a law requiring drivers to drive in reverse all winter? That would counter the logic side of the triangle. The public's subsequent refusal would be the fault of the government, not of the public. In other words, the fact that we obey the law is not because of the law itself, but because it is logical enough to warrant our adherence. The third side of the triangle is ethics. If the government ordered us to drive our elderly and infirm out onto the frozen tundra, as per Eskimo custom, we might agree that it would logically enhance the economy. But nobody would obey, because it would be patently immoral. The party at fault for the insubordination would be the government that enacted the law and not the citizens who refused to obey. Now, why did he think of that example? How are the boundaries of this triangle determined? A government has unlimited power to enact and enforce laws. The government, with its Knesset majority, can enact a law that would postpone elections for 50 years. Why doesn't it do so? For only one reason: Because it knows that the public would not accept it and the government would subsequently lose its credibility. In other words, just like Exupery's king, the government enacts laws within the boundaries that it assumes the public will accept, both logically and ethically. Power always strives for more power and the government will always attempt to test the boundaries of common sense and ethicality. But fortunately, it is not the government that determines these boundaries, but the public. How does the public accomplish this? By using its right and sometimes its duty to refuse to obey the law. That is how the logical and ethical platform for the healthy functioning of society is created. To increase its power, the government tries to convince us that insubordination will cause the state to collapse. But that is completely false. The greatest crimes in human history were perpetrated when citizens ignored their duty to delineate logical and ethical boundaries for the rule of law. The societies in which this took place by and large collapsed. In the past few weeks, soldiers from two separate units in the IDF expressed their civic responsibility by refusing to obey orders to expel Jews from their homes. These brave young men are positioned to save Israel from collapse. Let me add that for decades Lefist elites been cheering IDF soldiers refusing legal orders that conflicted with their Leftist (EU funded) sensibilities. |
| Posted by:g(r)omgoru |
| #1 A government has unlimited power to enact and enforce laws. The government, with its Knesset majority, can enact a law that would postpone elections for 50 years. Why doesn't it do so? The author stepped into it big time right there. Such a government is a dictatorship. A republic such as ours sets limits upon government. Our government is in serious caca right now because it's decided it's going to operate on the statement at the top of this, rather than try to govern as past presidents have. The wheels have already come off the current administration and the Congress enabling it, and they're at the top of a very tall, steep mountain. The slippery brown stuff they keep spewing will make the trip to the bottom even faster. The IDF is loyal to the State of Israel. They do not question the legitimacy of their government because it is pretty regularly in accord with the founding documents of the Jewish State. This person knows far too little about what he's expounding on so loudly. |
| Posted by: Old Patriot 2009-12-02 23:43 |