You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Politix
Elderly Moving Against ObamaCare
2009-09-29
America's elderly are finally realizing that Obama's healthcare changes are largely financed by cuts in Medicare and are rallying against his proposals in increasing numbers.

The latest poll by Scott Rasmussen not only shows national opposition to Obamacare rising - now it is 41-56 against - but also shows the elderly moving against it even more strongly, by 33-59, or almost 2:1.

And well they should! Three-quarters of ObamaCare is to be financed by slashing $500 billion from Medicare over the next 10 years. That comes to an 8 percent cut. Next year's total Medicare spending, for example, will be about $500 billion by itself, so this is like having one year without Medicare at all! Obama's fatuous claim that the cut will not affect care for the elderly is specious, as any thinking person would realize. We have gone through previous incarnations of those who wanted to slash Medicare and pretended that it would not affect the elderly. Newt Gingrich tried to sell this act of alchemy in 1995, and the elderly didn't buy it then and aren't buying it now!

It is obviously impossible to cut Medicare reimbursement without slashing the time doctors spend with patients. It is equally obvious that you cannot cover 30 million new patients without more doctors and nurses. And the Medicare cuts in doctors' fees will, of course, cause a decrease in the number of medical professionals. Investors Business Daily conducted a poll in September that showed that 45 percent of all doctors said they would seriously consider retiring or closing their practices if the Obama bill passes. A larger number will likely refuse to treat Medicare patients. Indeed, current law provides for a 21 percent cut in Medicare fees to doctors next year and a 6 percent cut the year after. The new $500 billion in cuts are on top of these reductions! What kind of medical care do we expect our elderly to receive when the doctor they visit is getting $35 or $40 for seeing them!

But the Senate appears ready to ram this bill through regardless of what the public or the elderly think. They have 60 votes and they won't listen to anyone. But we have to make them listen!

PLEASE take two steps right now.

1. I have persuaded the League of American Voters to run 10-second advertisements in key states that show an elderly person saying: "Senator _________: Please don't cut my Medicare by $500 billion. I need my Medicare." We need to get these ads on in the key states.

Obama would like us to believe that the key issue is whether or not to have a public option, precisely because he is prepared to concede the point (and have a co-op that would be run by the government for at least the first three years instead). But we need to focus attention on the cuts in Medicare. It is slashing services to the elderly that is the key point!

So please go here and give very, very generously. This is the key moment and you can make all the difference in the world. With pressure such as the elderly are bringing to bear, the Senate would not dare pass this benighted plan!

2. If you live in one of these key swing states, PLEASE write the senator I have indicated. To get talking points for your letter, consult our book Catastrophe. But write today:

Arkansas: Blanche Lincoln and Mark Pryor
Louisiana: Mary Landrieu
Nebraska: Ben Nelson
South Dakota: Tim Johnson
North Dakota: Byron Dorgan and Kent Conrad
Montana: Max Baucus and Jon Tester
North Carolina: Kay Hagan
Indiana: Evan Bayh
Connecticut Joe Lieberman
Maine: Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins

Thank you very much. Time is running short!
Posted by:GolfBravoUSMC

#10  I guess they want the govt to keep its hands off medicare.

It's the old hard decision of "do you want to drown with the water rising up to your head, or getting thrown in with cement shoes on?"

Either way, you lose. Just one is less dramatic than the other.
Posted by: Pappy   2009-09-29 22:26  

#9  ObamaCare for the elderly:
Posted by: DMFD   2009-09-29 22:17  

#8  The "greatest" generation is just about paid off. It's time to recognize that Medicare has been a disaster and is at the root of much of our medical cost problems. Both Medicare and Social Security are Ponzi schemes worthy of Madoff and should be phased out as soon as possible. Otherwise they will destroy our country. And they are far more likely to succeed than Iran.
Posted by: Nimble Spemble   2009-09-29 17:33  

#7  I am 70 and I don't trust anything about this crowd in Washington. I don't trust them to tell the truth and I don't trust them with the country. I'm with your 85 year old mother Woozle Uneter9007. Thank your mother for her sacrifice for the country--she paid a dear price.
Posted by: JohnQC   2009-09-29 17:17  

#6  I think many of the elderly in this country are quite aware of the assaults on Medicare by both sides over the years. It does become somewhat compounded and perhaps more frightening to some when close associates of the president such as Dr. Ezekial Emanuel (sometimes known as the president's rationing czar) weighs in with statements that we Americans have too much health care.

In addition to cutting spending, he would advocate redefining the duty of physicians; instead of focusing solely on a patient's needs, they must consider the greater good of society.

The elderly in this country (including my 85 year old mother) don't need a roadmap to figure out what that means.
Posted by: Woozle Uneter9007   2009-09-29 16:36  

#5  Sounds like your Mama is one smart cookie, Woozle.
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2009-09-29 15:40  

#4  During 2007, the Republicans made an effort to make some of the same cuts as the Dems are looking at in 2009.

Back then, the Dems succeeded in mobilizing the elderly to attack the cuts.

This is basically a economic political policy version of blowback.
Posted by: lord garth   2009-09-29 15:16  

#3  I guess they want the govt to keep its hands off medicare.

Posted by: liberalhawk   2009-09-29 15:11  

#2  If the Elderly don't notice they are not paying attention.

My mother just turned 85. She has convinced herself that if Obamacare passes, and should she need medical attention, she will be among the first to be 'ignored', so to speak.

Sad. This is a woman who has twice in her lifetime heard the words, "Please accept this flag on behalf of a grateful nation".
Posted by: Woozle Uneter9007   2009-09-29 13:29  

#1  Fact is we don't have money for social security and medicare. Fact is as the boomers retire it will get worse. Far worse.

The solution that Obamacare dares not speak, is to cull the herd. If the Elderly don't notice they are not paying attention.
Posted by: rjschwarz   2009-09-29 13:14  

00:01