| Submit your comments on this article |
| Afghanistan |
| German officer reportedly violated NATO bombing rules |
| 2009-09-10 |
| Col. Georg Klein overstepped his authority and poorly evaluated the situation, said the NATO report following last FridayÂ’s air strike in the northern province of Kunduz which killed dozens. It is "completely clear" that Klein did not respect decision-making procedures, a high-ranking German NATO officer told the daily. Such a decision should have been referred to the headquarters of the NATO-led International Security Assistance Force (ISAF), he said. Klein called in US warplanes last Friday to bomb two coalition fuel trucks that had been captured by Taliban militants, fearing they would be used as truck bombs against NATO forces. The preliminary report concluded however that ISAF troops were not in imminent danger as the trucks were stuck in the sand and were being closely monitored. ISAF has acknowledged that civilians who had gathered around the tanker trucks seeking fuel were killed and injured in the attack, but have not provided any figures. Local Afghan officials have said at least 54 people were engulfed in the inferno. A spokesman for the German Defence Ministry declined to comment to the Munich-based paper, saying it preferred to wait until the official report had been completed. The German government has so far reacted cautiously to the attack, which sparked intense anger in Afghanistan and beyond. German Chancellor Angela Merkel on Tuesday expressed her "deep regret" for any civilians killed, but said she "will not accept any premature judgements" on the raid. The bombing has revived debate within Germany on the deployment of its troops to Afghanistan, less than three weeks before general elections. To put this event into perspective: The Taliban stole these fuel trucks in order to turn them into truck bombs with which they would have attacked German forces, inflicting heavy casualties. The political result of this would have been a complete German withdrawal from Afghanistan well before year's end. Bombing these trucks at the time saved the mission for the time being. If it is indeed the official policy of NATO that the life of a NATO soldier is worth less than the life of an Afghan Looking at the commentary here and on other US blogs I suspect the above might be true not only for Germany. NATO is losing the hearts and minds of the people at home. |
| Posted by:Shinerong Flomonter6687 |
| #8 I look forward to the final report on this thing, although that probably won't placate the light-minded among the German voters. |
| Posted by: trailing wife 2009-09-10 23:10 |
| #7 It is "completely clear" that Klein did not respect decision-making procedures, a high-ranking German NATO officer told the daily. This report is from The Local, "Germany's news in English". We didn't do this to you, European Conservative, although I agree it stinks to high heaven. The problem is, as Shinerong Flomonter6687 states, If it is indeed the official policy of NATO that the life of a NATO soldier is worth less than the life of an Afghan illegal combatant war criminal Taliban civilian |
| Posted by: trailing wife 2009-09-10 22:57 |
| #6 But we've got better relations with our EUropean allies now that we treat them the same way they treat us. |
| Posted by: Nimble Spemble 2009-09-10 20:36 |
| #5 "realizing that this is a war and act accordingly and then you stab them in the back?" That's Bambi's fall-back position, too, EC. Sorry. Does it help to realize that he's busy stabbing his fellow US citizens in the back, too? :-( |
| Posted by: Barbara Skolaut 2009-09-10 19:33 |
| #4 The day after the Left (Die Linken, ex East German Commies) polled 4% stronger and the CDU/FDP lost absolute majority. They may deny it like hell but we might face a dark red/green coalition in a few weeks. Finally you have the Germans realizing that this is a war and act accordingly and then you stab them in the back? |
| Posted by: European Conservative 2009-09-10 19:11 |
| #3 "If that's an Obama plot to boost the Commies... well done." Whaddaya mean "if," EC? That's pretty much Bambi's fall-back position. |
| Posted by: Barbara Skolaut 2009-09-10 19:07 |
| #2 Frankly, everyone with good will in Germany is puzzled. If that's an Obama plot to boost the Commies... well done. |
| Posted by: European Conservative 2009-09-10 16:53 |
| #1 Sure it wasn't Col. Klink? |
| Posted by: CrazyFool 2009-09-10 16:41 |