You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
China-Japan-Koreas
Kim Jong-un Unlikely Candidate for NK Leader
2009-06-10
By Andrei Lankov

North Korea watchers are a seriously overworked group these days as important and often unexpected events happen in a quick succession. A missile launch in early April was followed by a nuclear test in late May, and now an ICBM is being moved to a launch pad. A consensus is that all these moves are primarily aimed at the US on assumption that a tougher position will allow them to squeeze more aid from Washington eventually.

We have seen this before, but this time the North Koreans behave with unusual intensity, so many observers came to suspect that this intensity is somehow related to North Korean domestic issues.

Of all possible explanations, the coming succession is mentioned most frequently. North Korea is a hereditary dictatorship, and Kim Jong-il is becoming visually old and fragile, so a decision on succession is widely expected to come soon.

It was against this background that some major South Korean news outlets reported early this [N.B. last] week breaking news from Pyongyang. If these reports are to be believed, Kim Jong-il's youngest son, Jong-un, has been secretly anointed as a successor to his father, and now full-scale preparations for a dynastic transfer of power have began. These reports are based on a secret telegram, which was allegedly sent from Pyongyang to the North Korean overseas missions.

This telegram was cited by National Intelligence Service officers who briefed the National Assembly's Intelligence Committee last Monday.
Posted by:Steve White

#5  The lessons internalized and the motions one goes through to satisfy family/rise through the ranks are not the same. Do you speak or do everything on your mind at work or home? Once secure as the new Great Dear Spiffy Leader, he may decide to try a better way, even if only at the margins at first. It is a possibility, not a prophecy.

The Soviet leadership didn't know the extent Gorbachev would liberalize the USSR's oppressive machinery. When they finally decided to take action to remove him, it was too late. That little wedge of freedom brought down an empire.
Posted by: ed   2009-06-10 10:43  

#4  I've been waiting for someone to say that.

You might want to stop and ask yourself why the Kim dynasty doesn't consider it threatening to send its potential successors to that sort of school.
Posted by: Thing From Snowy Mountain   2009-06-10 09:51  

#3  This could work out to our, and the oppressed NKors, advantage. Since he spent his youth getting a western liberal education and got to know the lifestyle and people, he may be sympathetic to a "Glasnost" opening. Hopefully, he's compared the relative efficiency, prosperity and peace during his Swiss education with the starving concentration camp that is NKor and is young and idealistic enough to want to change the system.
Posted by: ed   2009-06-10 09:33  

#2  The Kims' right to rule has always been justified by references to their superhuman wisdom, leadership qualities and other individual virtues, not to some special role of the family as such. When in the 1970s Kim Jong-il was appointed a successor to his father, it was never explained as because of their blood relations.

The propaganda machine insisted that Kim Jong-il's own unique virtues and his unprecedented popularity among the 'working masses' made him a successor.


The unstated assumption of the neo-confucianism of the Qing (and from what I can gather, the Kim) Dynasties is that it is the blood relative of the ruler who is going to be the person who is going to be that wise or that capable of going to the golf course and getting those nine holes-in-one the first time out.

They talk about how wise Kim Jong-Il is, not that he's a blood relative, but how come it's HIM they're talking about being all-wise and all-knowing and not some random peasant? Or the chief of staff of Kim Il Son's army?
Posted by: Thing From Snowy Mountain   2009-06-10 09:01  

#1  Neither was his dad.
Posted by: g(r)omgoru   2009-06-10 06:49  

00:00