You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq
Last Marine getting ready to turn out the lights in Fallujah
2008-10-17
WASHINGTON — When Marine Maj. Gen. John Kelly deployed to Iraq in February, the violence had fallen so low in Anbar province that he began figuring out how to start closing bases and prepare to go home.

In the last 10 months the Marines in Fallujah have done what was unthinkable before the surge began — they have quietly transferred out of one of Anbar province's largest cities. FOX News has learned in an exclusive interview with Kelly from Fallujah that 80 percent of the move is complete. In February there were 8,000 Marines living at Fallujah base. Now there are about 3,000 left. By Nov. 14 there will be none.

"We will shut down the command function here and I will move; my staff has already started to move," Kelly, the commander of Multinational Force-West, told FOX News in an exclusive interview via satellite. "We will turn the lights off here."

They will hand the Fallujah base over to their Iraqi counterparts on Nov. 14, having relocated themselves and thousands of combat vehicles to the desert base of Al Asad to the west. Marines will no longer be seen in city centers such as Fallujah — a major step toward leaving Iraq, and one step closer to Iraq's goal of having U.S. troops out of its population centers by mid-2009 — one of the key points enshrined in the Status of Forces Agreement being reviewed on Capitol Hill today.

On Wednesday, to little fanfare, the Marines quietly closed down Al Qaim base near the Syrian border. Now it is run by Iraqis.

In Fallujah, where the U.S. Marines once had three large mess halls to feed troops, they are now down to one. The Marines have quietly disassembled the entire infrastructure of the base.

"We probably had several thousand of those large metal containers — tractor-trailer containers," Kelly said. "I bet we don't have 200 of them here now."

Of the thousands of vehicles once parked at the base, now there are only 300 left. Their transfer occurred at night, between 9 p.m. and 5 a.m., over the past 10 months so as not to disturb Iraqi drivers and clog the roads.

They dubbed it "Operation Rudy Giuliani" because they were cleaning the streets up and returning Fallujah to normalcy — taking down barbed wire and tearing down checkpoints and Jersey walls that made Anbar look like a war zone.

"There is almost no barbed wire left anywhere in Fallujah," Kelly said. An Iraqi no longer sees barbed wire when traveling in and around the city.

Between 300 and 400 concrete barriers that divided the city were removed by Navy Seabees.

One of the big changes Kelly made when he took command in Anbar was to remove fixed checkpoints, and Iraqi vehicles no longer had to pull off to the side when a military convoy was on the road. His troops risked car bombs, but the gamble paid off in what had once been Iraq's most dangerous province. The new road rules instantly lowered the tension between military and locals. Soon he transitioned to moving military convoys only at night, so they would not encounter locals. This also stymied many of the insurgents laying IEDs or roadside bombs, which they often had done at night.

Another change for the better since Kelly arrived in February: He pushed the central government to provide more fuel to the people of Anbar, so the mostly Sunni population is now happier. In February, Anbaris were receiving only 8 percent of their allocation of fuel from the central government of Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki. Now it's 90 percent — eliminating one of their main gripes.

But perhaps the biggest sign that the situation has changed for the better for Sunnis living in Anbar: With the help of the Marines and the Iraqi police, nearly 100 percent of the eligible voting population were registered a month ago to vote in upcoming provincial elections.

"They seem to add another political party every day," Kelly said. "We didn't have a single security violation of any kind. They're at least going to give the electoral process a shot Â… at least going to give democracy a chance."

The Sunnis, who fueled a large part of Iraq's insurgency, boycotted the last election for Parliament with only 3 percent of Sunnis participating. Now they feel they have a stake in the government.

"This is an amazing indicator as to where this province is," Kelly said.

He and the Marines no longer use violence as an indicator of how much progress they have made. Two years ago they had 400 attacks — roadside bombs or shootings — at U.S. forces every week. In February it was down to 30 attacks per week. Now it is down to under 12 attacks per week. There hasn't been a Marine death in a few months.

Troop numbers have dropped, as well — down by 40 percent since February. About 26,000 Marines still serve in Anbar.

"In Anbar there is no longer an insurgency," Kelly said. "Unless someone does something stupid (for instance, if the Coalition were to accidentally kill a large number of civilians), this place will not go back to the way it was."

In football terms, Kelly says, the Marines are "in the last 10 yards of this fight."

"Could it go back? I don't think so," he said firmly. "We are winning this thing."

Posted by:GolfBravoUSMC

#12  This will be Bush's positive legacy (sorry, but his utter mis-handling of the domestic situation may well overshadow his foriegn policy effort). I very much hope it endures.

Remoteman, I'm calling you on that. Please explain precisely how Bush "mis-handled" the "domestic situation".

McCain was right. The economy was in good shape. Last January there was no one mainstream who saw this credit crash coming. Sure, there were a number of worried people. McCain. Bush. A small but persistent group of financial analysts who had been preaching doom so long (over 10 years) that no one was listening any more.

Who do you think Bush is? King of the USA or something? He gave it a good shot, but it was clear that no one was listening or wanted a party pooper around.

What They Said About Fan and Fred

A Mortgage Fable

Who caused “the biggest financial crisis since the Great Depression?”

Actually, the timing of the crash was remarkably good. Those balls had been in the air for years. I'm not sure how Soros triggered it, but I'm betting he did. Note that I'm not saying he had the power to set up the house of cards; we all did that, from the irresponsible house buyers to the greedy bond buyers in Norway. But there's a good chance he pulled out a couple of cards at the right moment. It didn't take much.
Posted by: KBK   2008-10-17 19:51  

#11  Don Vito Omeling5062: a partial comparison is not with Arabs, because the British never developed Arab armies to any great extent. However, India was a different matter. The Indians and Sikhs were a quick study, and to this day have a very British way of doing military business.

But that was the 19th and early 20th Century way of training. Today, if you were to go to Iraq and to a far lesser extent, Afghanistan, you could probably tell who the American trainers were who trained a particular unit.

The USMC is extremely stylized in its training and operations, and it has been noted that the Iraqis military wants *everything* the USMC has, as far as equipment. Ironically, these Iraqis will probably call those units the Arabic equivalent of "Marine", though they will never go to sea.

Everything the Marines do, even just stylistic things, will be copied and mimicked. I would not be surprised in a few years if the Iraqis develop a similar dress uniform.

Eventually, the Iraqis will have truly "elite" units, prestige units, unique among Arab armies.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2008-10-17 19:27  

#10  I pray Moose is spot on, but I suppose we'll see. I wonder if it's succeeded in an Islamic setting before - the British history is probably the closest counterpart, with Pakistan and India the obvious data control sets.

I see success in stages, and we're clearly about done with the bare minimum, for us and Iraq, but the ultimate would be an Iraq nationalism completely devoid of the hallmarks of Arab nationalism, and tranquil, if not lucratively friendly commercial relations with Israel - the ne plus ultra canary in the Arab coal mine.
Posted by: Don Vito Omeling5062   2008-10-17 16:18  

#9  We've come a long way since that dark day in 2004:

Ghastly barbaric murder of four foreigners in Falluja

Lest we forget:
Wes Batalona
Scott Helvenston
Mike Teague
Jerry Zovko
Posted by: Atomic Conspiracy   2008-10-17 15:49  

#8  The Marines generally leave a legacy behind when they depart an area. In this case, for at least two or three generations, the Iraqis they trained will do their best to be as much like the Marines as they can.

It is more than just the training itself, it is the osmosis from soldier to soldier, the culture, great and small. The concept that we do it this way, because that is the way it is done.

I imagine that the Iraqis will make a lot of deals with the US to continue to have USMC advisers doing quality control in their training programs. Those IA who have worked with the Marines will demand it.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2008-10-17 14:39  

#7  History will be the judge of whether we won this war or not. But I am hopeful that this is a sign that Iraq can and will emerge from this war a stable and gorwing country.

Should there be peace and the establishment of a persistent democratic process over the next 10 years, the prospects for the country are indeed very bright.

This will be Bush's positive legacy (sorry, but his utter mis-handling of the domestic situation may well overshadow his foriegn policy effort). I very much hope it endures.
Posted by: remoteman   2008-10-17 13:23  

#6  Thank you for a job well done.
Posted by: Richard of Oregon   2008-10-17 12:33  

#5  But perhaps the biggest sign that the situation has changed for the better for Sunnis living in Anbar: With the help of the Marines and the Iraqi police, nearly 100 percent of the eligible voting population were registered a month ago to vote in upcoming provincial elections. "They seem to add another political party every day," Kelly said. "We didn't have a single security violation of any kind. They're at least going to give the electoral process a shot ... at least going to give democracy a chance."

Very well done, all!
Posted by: trailing wife    2008-10-17 11:56  

#4  The Marines have done a tremendous job in Fallujah---from the fight to the finish now. Their sense of dedication and professionalism is a beacon of light for this country. And unwittingly, it shows the shallowness and depravity of many in Congress, especially the likes of Jack Murtha and Harry Reid.

Without dedicated people like these Marines protecting the nation, parasites like Pelosi, Murtha, Durban, et al, would not get the time of day.
Posted by: Alaska Paul   2008-10-17 11:47  

#3  Reid's not senile. He knows what he's saying and why he's saying it. Him and his fellow donks wanted defeat in Iraq just like they want a depression now so they can blame it on Bush and the Republicans and win the White House.
Posted by: Abu Uluque   2008-10-17 11:15  

#2  April 2007 "I believe ... that this war is lost, and this surge is not accomplishing anything, as is shown by the extreme violence in Iraq this week," Reid told journalists.
If they held a senility contest I wonder who would win? Reid or Murtha?
Posted by: GK   2008-10-17 10:42  

#1  This is absolutely tremendous news. It's the victorious end of a truly major battle in a very tough war--a war we've all but won. It's a pity that so few Americans will ever hear about it.

Our MSM is so traitorous the vast majority of them ought to be shot and the rest deported.
Posted by: Jolutch Mussolini7800   2008-10-17 10:32  

00:00