You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
-Lurid Crime Tales-
Manacled, starved, beaten: a terror suspect's claims
2008-03-14
Khaled al-Maqtari's nightmare began when American troops arrived at the al-Ghufran market in Fallujah in January 2004. He was arrested along with other terrorist suspects and taken to Abu Ghraib jail. For the next four years he was held captive, moved from country to country and suffered, he says, appalling torture. Mr al-Maqtari, from Yemen, was one of the many inmates in the US's secret "ghost detention" who disappeared into an international network of prisons, their whereabouts unknown to family and friends. British soldiers, he claims, were involved in investigating him although they did not play any part in the abuse.
These are all allegations. Maqtari doesn't have any proof of any of this, and we (of course) are not talking. Let's remember that al-Qaeda commands its people to lie to the West when captured, to claim that they've been abused and tortured, and to do everything possible to use our legal system against us.
Details of what Mr al-Maqtari, 31, says was done to him emerge after a recent admission from the Foreign Secretary, David Miliband (after previous denials) that the island of Diego Garcia, a British territory, had been used in American rendition flights. Amnesty International, in a report into the Yemeni's case, has called for an independent inquiry into the extent of the UK's role in the US's "war on terror" and, especially, rendition flights. An investigation across the Atlantic into the subject was also necessary, says the human rights group, to bring the torturers to justice and provide compensation for the victims.
Assuming that there was any torture, which AI is always ready to believe. They're rather gullible that way.
During his incarceration Mr al-Maqtari was moved from Baghdad to a prison near Kabul in Afghanistan and later in Yemen. In between he was taken to another country, but does not know which.
Might as well blame everyone then. Maybe we moved him to North Korea? Or Zimbabwe? Perhaps it was France. Never can tell.
What remained constant, he says was mistreatment which included beatings, cigarettes being stubbed out on his body, being hung upside down, the use of disorienting music and light, starvation, sleep deprivation and being kept naked, hooded and manacled.
Any cigarette burns on him? Maybe he smoked in bed. Dangerous, that. Any x-rays with old fractures?
Mr al-Maqtari was born in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia, but had lived most of his life in Hodeidah on the Red Sea coast of Yemen. His reason for travelling to Iraq in early 2003 remains unclear as do the reasons for his stays in Mosul, Ramadi and Fallujah, cities which became centres of the Sunni insurgency.
He was just a missionary. Or a student. Or doing charity work. Distributing arms alms to the poor, that's it.
Civil rights groups stress, however, that any involvement by Mr al-Maqtari in acts of violence against the Americans does not justify what he says was done to him.
If indeed anything was done to him, which we still haven't established.
Mr al-Maqtari was working part time in an internet centre in Fallujah ...
... what an interesting place to be, right where he can handle communications ...
... when he was arrested in January 2004, seven months after the US-led invasion, a time when insurgents were stepping up their attacks on American forces. According to the US military, its operation "market sweep" led to the confiscation of rifles, machine guns, grenades and mortars. Mr al-Maqtari vehemently denies any connection with this although he was repeatedly questioned about his supposed knowledge of terrorist weapons caches.
"Lies! All lies!"
It was during the searches for hidden weapons that, Mr al-Maqtari claims, British troops became involved. A unit of UK special forces working with the Americans took him from Abu Ghraib to a location in Baghdad, but no arms were found.

Ben Griffin, a former SAS man who was stationed in Baghdad in early 2005, told Amnesty that British special forces would not have taken part in interrogations, but would have been aware of the methods likely to be employed in Abu Ghraib. Mr al-Maqtari said one of the American interrogators used him as a footstool, trampled on his face and put a cigarette out on his shoulder while shouting, "I'm from New York, the place you Arabs tried to destroy."
We're being conned once again. Magtari has no proof of any mistreatment but he's going to shout from the rooftops. AI and the other gullible lefties have swallowed whole all his allegations, and no amount of 'investigating' will ever convince them otherwise. As was said in Through the Looking Glass, verdict first, trial later. If ever.
Posted by:ryuge

#19  Maybe in his next life, to make up for this bad karma, somebody will really torture the crap out of him!

We can hope...
Posted by: 3dc   2008-03-14 23:25  

#18  actually i think he is more used to pitching than catching
Posted by: Abu do you love   2008-03-14 22:00  

#17  I bet he'd be more cooperative locked up in Folsom with his new boyfriend Bruce.....on second thought, he might actually like that.
Posted by: Grand Proconsul Sock Puppet   2008-03-14 21:24  

#16  Of course, it is an honor when the AoS - or any of the great moderators here - adds any comments or pictures to one of my posts. I'm always proud to contribute to Rantburg in any way. I wouldn't be surprised if we see Al-Maqtari's name in Rantburg again before too long. Let's hope that it's for nothing more serious than being a jihadi display victim.
Posted by: ryuge   2008-03-14 18:24  

#15  this just brought a tear too my eye, never mind it was saw dust
Posted by: sinse   2008-03-14 17:13  

#14  tu - You can borrow my electric femtoviolin, if you've got the equipment to play it. It makes lovely music. It's just the thing for heart-broken ayrab terrorists who got caught. Makes 'em cry, it does, especially when the amp's cranked up to 250dB.
Posted by: Old Patriot   2008-03-14 15:55  

#13  Hmmm did we cut off his head? His fingers and mail them home? No in that case I don't frggin care.
Posted by: Cyber Sarge   2008-03-14 13:58  

#12  Salmon comments are mine; I added them after ryuge posted. I appreciate his posting this since I wanted to tee off on the story.

AoS
Posted by: Steve White   2008-03-14 11:27  

#11  Fantastic job, ryuge (though far too cool and gentle in its sarcasm, given the moral imbecility of the usual suspects). Great comments,too. I think this is one area where our characteristic silence has got to be altered, to specifically and decisively refute slanderous errors of fact and interpretation.
Posted by: Verlaine   2008-03-14 11:14  

#10  So you'd have gone easy on him, #8 bigjim?
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2008-03-14 10:44  

#9  Mr al-Maqtari was born in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia, but had lived most of his life in Hodeidah on the Red Sea coast of Yemen. His reason for travelling to Iraq in early 2003 remains unclear as do the reasons for his stays in Mosul, Ramadi and Fallujah, cities which became centres of the Sunni insurgency.

At least we know that a Saudi, hailing from Yemen and travelling extensively throughout Anbar prior to the Coalition invasion, couldn't possibly be a member of Al-Q tasked with preparing the battlespace, securing Saddam's weapons stocks and training up the locals, since the NYT tells us so.

That poor dear, bet he misses his Mom.
Posted by: Seafarious   2008-03-14 10:42  

#8  Manacled, starved, beaten
He's lucky I wasn't his interrogator, we'd have a lot more information, and he'd have a colostomy bag and 3 missing toes to go with his complaint.
Posted by: bigjim-ky   2008-03-14 10:24  

#7  Manacled, starved, beaten

Client #7? And paid how much per hour?
Posted by: Procopius2k   2008-03-14 10:03  

#6  Ben Griffin, a former SAS man who was stationed in Baghdad in early 2005,

Mr. Griffin appears to be uncharacteristically forthcoming with his both his SAS forces affiliation and assignments. I'm afraid the rubbish flag must be thrown on this one.
Posted by: Besoeker   2008-03-14 09:38  

#5  You have a 'story' about someone (who apparently offered not a single shread of evidence - no scars from cigarettes or anything) from an organization who are trained to claim mistreatment (I'm talking about both Al-Q and AmNasty International here)

Add a few references to retention flights and voila - you have the next big story about what meanies Americans are.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2008-03-14 09:22  

#4  Because as every Lichtensteiner knows, retaliation for any act of violence against America is just...mean!
Posted by: Creling Darling of the Lichtensteiners8341   2008-03-14 08:37  

#3  Civil rights groups stress, however, that any involvement by Mr al-Maqtari in acts of violence against the Americans does not justify what he says was done to him.

they're right. We should've executed him. He didn't deserve the kid-gloves treatment. "Civil rights groups" can FOAD
Posted by: Frank G   2008-03-14 08:22  

#2  Geez, I'm out of tissues and my violin's broke...
Posted by: tu3031   2008-03-14 08:21  

#1  I meant to post this to page 2, sorry.
Posted by: ryuge   2008-03-14 08:11  

00:00