You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Submit your comments on this article
India-Pakistan
Pakistan army failures 'put the West in peril'
2008-02-13
The West remains at constant risk of large-scale al-Qa'eda terrorist attacks because the Pakistani military requires years of training before it will be able to combat militancy, a Western military official has warned.
They may not be any good at combating militancy but they sure are good at supporting it
More than six years have elapsed since the September 11 attacks on the United States but the Pakistan army remains unequipped and untrained for counter-insurgency and counter-terrorism operations, the official told The Daily Telegraph.
their business is terrorism, not counter-terrorism
He gave a comprehensive account describing how al-Qa'eda has been able to preserve its sanctuary in Pakistan by backing an insurgency in the lawless border tribal areas.

"If we [the West] have a reasonable degree of co-operation it may take two to three years for them [the Pakistan military] to be bought up to a level," he said. "But realistically the way things are going it will take five years," he added.

As a result, he warned, there is a possible "worst case scenario that there will be another catastrophic event in the West and then everything else in between."

He described the Pakistan military as a "dinosaur of an institution" despite the $10 billion (£5 billion) that it has received in US military aid over the past five years. "We have not being getting the bang for our buck," he said.
But the Pakistanis got the bang for other people's bucks: the Pak Generals are all millionaires and they have shiny toys to fight India
He added that a lack of transparency on the Pakistan government's part had led to payments worth millions of dollars for operations in the US-led war on terror having being suspended in the past.

The official listed the Pakistani military's deficiencies ranging from the army's incapacity to launch multiple operations, poor military intelligence, hostility to Western military training and a denial among many officers that militancy poses a threat to Pakistan.
Offiial motto of the Pakistani Army is "Iman-Taqwa-Jihad fi sabilillah "(Faith, Fear of Allah, Jihad in the way of Allah). Do you really expect Officers sworn to jihad to actually fight jihadists?
His warning came as a senior US official in Washington claimed that Osama bin Laden and the Taliban leader Mullah Mohammad Omar were operating from Pakistan's tribal areas, in what was the most explicit claim of its kind made in recent years by America.

Pakistan dismissed the claim as "baseless," adding that Islamabad would take action if the US provided it with intelligence to support the statement.

President Pervez Musharraf recently said that Pakistani troops were making no particular effort to hunt al-Qa'eda as they were focused on fighting Taliban militants. A suspected senior al-Qa'eda operative, Abu Laith al-Libbi, was killed in what is believed to have been a US missile strike in North Waziristan tribal area earlier this month.

The Western military official said that al-Qa'eda supports local Pakistani Taliban, which have united under Baitullah Mehsud, who was blamed for the assassination of former prime minister, Benazir Bhutto. Pakistan has deployed about 100,000 troops to the tribal region where about 1,000 of them have been killed.
But the offensive units of the Pakistani army remain at the Indian border
The official said that more local soldiers have been killed or wounded in the past seven months than in the previous five years as the military has stepped up its operations. But, he added: "I really can't say they have a strategy that is coherent. They act in a tactical way, meaning they concentrate their forces on very small elements."

US military advisers are helping the Pakistanis double the size of their elite commando force and teaching specialised fighting techniques, such as helicopter assaults.
the better to infiltrate Kashmir with
The US has started a five-year programme to train and equip the Frontier Corps, a colonial-era paramilitary unit.
But the 700,000 strong Pak army itself remains uncommitted...
Posted by:john frum

#2  The West remains at constant risk of large-scale al-Qa'eda terrorist attacks because the Pakistani military requires years of training before it will be able to combat militancy

Also putting the West at constant risk: The funding of al-Qa'eda terrorist attacks by the Pakistani military.
Posted by: Excalibur   2008-02-13 09:21  

#1  Instead of throwing money into Pakistan's army we should let it fall apart (accelerate it if we can) and in the meantime put money in the Afghan Army and have it invade Pakistan and conquer the tribal zone.

Pakistan is a state who needs fundamentalism for its survival. Without it Pahstoons, Balochs and Sindhs would notice tehy have no business staying in Pakistan and its elites, specially their military/ISI elites would lose their lucrative positions. A strong Afghanistan could be an enemy while Pakistan is s structural one.
Posted by: JFM   2008-02-13 05:19  

00:00