You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Olde Tyme Religion
Egypt: Fatwa Sparks Sunni-Shiite Controversy
2007-05-09
(AKI) - A Muslim religious edict (fatwa) issued by Mohammed Sayyed Al Tantawi, Sheikh of Al Azhar, the highest seat of Sunni learning, has pitted Muslim moderates and Shiites against Sunnis in Egypt. The fatwa states that "any Muslim offending the Prophet Mohamed or one of his associates must be considered an infidel" because "accusing the Prophet's followers of being liars amounts to questioning the truthfulness of the Koran itself." Some Shiite clerics have cast doubt on some of those associated with the Prophet during his lifetime.

Egyptian weekly 'Al Fajr' (Dawn) a few weeks ago published an article by Mohamed el Baz, in which he accused Abu Huraya, one of Mohammed's followers - and one of the main sources of 'hadith', which relate the Prophet's words and actions that are key to establish the Muslim way of life - of being a liar.

Even though there is no official data on the Shiite population in Sunni-majority Egypt, estimates range between 5,000 and 7,000 out of the 72 million Egyptian Muslims. Overall, the Shiites make up about 15 percent of the world's 1.2 billion Muslims.

Under the fatwa, el Baz can be accused of being an infidel. The researcher for his part has slammed the edict as "a way to go back to the Middle Ages" saying that "nobody has the right to tell a Muslim that they are an infidel."

Al Baz, according to whom "fundamentalists are putting pressure on Tantawi so that he issues similar fatwas," has told the local press that "the sheikh should learn to clarify that anything they say is their own personal opinion and not a principle of Islam."

'Al Fajr' is an independent Egyptian weekly. In its first edition on October 2005, Al Fajr published on its front page six of the 12 cartoons satirizing the Prohet originally published by Danish daily Jyllands-Posten, which sparked violent Muslim protests worldwide.
Posted by:Fred

#6  Any fatwa that puts the Shiites and Sunnis at each others' throats is a good thing. These stupid SOBs will all die in an attempt to be more Islamically pure than one another. Sadly, it just cannot happen fast enough.
Posted by: Zenster   2007-05-09 19:34  

#5  "a way to go back to the Middle Ages"


Certainly a feature, not a bug.
Posted by: AlanC   2007-05-09 09:08  

#4  Sunni-Shiite conflict scale

restiveness- fewer than 50 dead

disagreement-50 to 500 dead

argument-500 to 5000 dead

controversy- 5000 to 50000 dead

dispute- 50000 to 500000 dead

strife- 500000 to 1 million dead

civil war- all dead
Posted by: Atomic Conspiracy   2007-05-09 04:26  

#3  I'll wait for body counts before deciding how serious this is.
Posted by: gromgoru   2007-05-09 04:12  

#2  What? The Bukhari Hadith contains 8000 hearsay comments and stories that are accepted as originating with the Muslim "prophet" (Pig-crap Be Upon Him). But Bukhari's biographer claims the compiler gathered Hadith from collections totalling 600,000. Compilers reject based on the weight of evidence, consistency to already accepted Hadith, and obvious deceit resting on self-interest (the basis of the formation of the Shiites). If falsification was admitted by Bukhari - whose collection is deemed "holy" by the al-Azhar Sunnis - then Tantawi can hardly produce a credible fatwa that denies that Muslims have been faking Hadith from the origin of the cult. Muslim' "sacred" text should be converted to toilet paper.
Posted by: Sneaze   2007-05-09 01:53  

#1  I've been soliciting people to program an online fatwa generator, that will say things like "The Mufti of Burbank has declared putting funny hats on dachshunds to be punishable by wedgies."
Posted by: Anonymoose   2007-05-09 00:32  

00:00