| Submit your comments on this article |
| Science & Technology |
| Rich and Poor Battle Over Bird Flu |
| 2007-04-25 |
| Bird flu has largely flown off the radar of the Western world, but people are still dying from it nearly every week in Indonesia. Since the first case was reported two years ago, government officials have reported 74 deaths from the H5N1 strain in Indonesia -- more than a third of the world's total. And it's not just the virus this nation is battling. It's also struggling to ensure that poor countries get their fair share of any new vaccine developed to stem the spread of a possible global flu epidemic. Indonesia has refused to share its samples of bird flu virus with the World Health Organization since January. Jakarta fears a vaccine produced from its specimens would be out of reach for its own citizens -- too expensive and controlled by wealthy nations. Some global health officials have accused Indonesia of holding the virus hostage and keeping experts from monitoring whether the bug is mutating into a dangerous form that could potentially spark the next pandemic that kills millions. But government officials continue to hold their ground in a showdown with WHO -- despite agreeing last month to resume sending samples. They are using the viruses as leverage against a system they say caters to the developed world's whims instead of promoting access for all. "Exploitation by industrialized countries toward poor countries is not something new," Health Minister Siti Fadilah Supari wrote in an Indonesian newspaper editorial recently. "This situation brings poverty, suffering and stupidity." Some experts say she has a point, and that Western governments should realize a pandemic that starts in Asia would not only kill indiscriminately but would also cripple economies everywhere. There is capacity for producing only up to 500 million doses of flu vaccine a year -- far short of what would be needed in a pandemic. "It's not just about altruistic public health," said Michael Osterholm, a University of Minnesota infectious disease specialist. "When we realize Southeast Asia and China are shut down economically from a pandemic perspective, so goes our economy. So goes many critical products and services that we count on every day." The WHO hasn't counted any Indonesian bird flu cases since the country stopped sending samples, keeping its official count at 63. Indonesian officials have recorded 11 deaths since then. But the U.N. health agency has been careful not to criticize the government. It has worked to smooth tensions by meeting with developing countries in Jakarta last month to ensure the poor are not left out as they have been historically -- ranging from a lack of access to expensive AIDS drugs to seasonal flu vaccines available only to rich nations. At the end of the meeting, Indonesia said it would resume sending specimens, provided that drug companies be required to seek permission before using its viruses to make vaccines. That is a major departure from the WHO's free sharing system used to develop seasonal flu vaccines. The temporary deal applies only to Indonesia, and all other governments are expected to continue providing samples unrestricted, said Dr. David Heymann, WHO's top flu official. WHO Director-General Margaret Chan met with Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono earlier this month in Jakarta and played down the standoff, hailing the government for bringing attention to the issue and vowing to establish a global vaccine stockpile. Another meeting on this issue will be held this week at WHO headquarters in Geneva. Bird flu has killed at least 172 people worldwide since it began its spread through Asian poultry in 2003, according to WHO. Most human deaths come from contact with infected birds, but experts fear it could mutate into a form that spreads easily among people. |
| Posted by:Anonymoose |
| #7 A: Who's got the new vaccine. C: What vaccine ? A: Vaccine for the bird flu. C: Who's got the flu ? A: No, no, Who's got the vaccine. C: I don't know. I don't even know who's sick. A: They're not. |
| Posted by: wxjames(channeling) 2007-04-25 18:32 |
| #6 Nonono: WHO is on First,please keep the lines straight. thanks. |
| Posted by: Ghost of BudnLou 2007-04-25 18:12 |
| #5 Ya, WHO's on third. |
| Posted by: DarthVader 2007-04-25 16:10 |
| #4 um, Darth? gotta a punchline? |
| Posted by: Uninetch Dark Lord of the Geats5647 2007-04-25 15:51 |
| #3 Article: "Exploitation by industrialized countries toward poor countries is not something new," Health Minister Siti Fadilah Supari wrote in an Indonesian newspaper editorial recently. "This situation brings poverty, suffering and stupidity." We create a vaccine where none existed before, and we're exploiting them? These people really have a sense of entitlement. What's theirs is theirs and what's ours is theirs, too. I look forward to the day an uncontrollable pandemic breaks out there, and foreign countries implement a travel and trade embargo against Indonesia. |
| Posted by: Zhang Fei 2007-04-25 14:00 |
| #2 Sounds like the old joke: "WHO is in London?" |
| Posted by: DarthVader 2007-04-25 10:28 |
| #1 It remains highly unlikely that Indonesia has the lab capability to verify bird flu. Indonesia is not the only nation to have withheld samples from WHO. China is another. There are several reasons, the major one being the arrogance of the WHO who presume to dictate to third world nations from their cozy offices in Zurich or London. WHO does not ask, it demands. It does not request, it dictates. For Indonesia, an island nation with severe transportaion difficulties and a native culture that operates far slower than the Swiss do, the WHO is disrespectful and insulting. The nation is still dealing with the aftermath of the earthquakes and tsunami and the few deaths due to bird flu are seen as less important in the overall scheme of things. When tens of thousands die in a matter of moments, 74 dead over the course of two years is trivial. The University of Rochester just had an A)H5N1 vaccine approved. It is believed to immunize 40% of adults innoculated. Hardly encouraging. |
| Posted by: Chuck Simmins 2007-04-25 10:11 |