You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq
Think We're Losing Iraq? Take a Look at the Dinar
2007-01-20
War rages in Iraq. America is preparing to launch an offensive in Baghdad, Iranians are infiltrating the country, and, according to the United Nations, civilians in Iraq are dying at a rate of 100 people a day.

Yet the Iraqi currency is rising in value. Tuesday, the rate of exchange had reached 1,308 dinars to the American dollar — up from 1,470 last November. Money changers in Baghdad say they cannot keep up with the demand and that Iraqis who used to hang on to their American dollars for dear life are rushing to exchange them.

What gives? The answers are as murky as anything in Iraq, and the actions of both good and bad guys seem to be helping the dinar.

On the good guys' side, the Iraqi Central Bank is getting its act together after having built foreign currency and gold reserves of at least $16 billion, up from a mere $5 billion in 2005. That is serious enough to create a strong backbone for the local currency. On its Web site, the central bank noted that it has increased its main interest rate to 16% from 12% — a move that has boosted the dinar, too.

For its part, the American Army, or some units of it, is beginning to pay contractors in "dinar checks" instead of dollars. That has the double benefit of reviving the moribund banking system — you've got to go to a bank to cash it — while boosting the local currency.

Bad guys are doing their bit too, interestingly. Corruption is said to account for perhaps as much as 500,000 barrels of daily oil production "disappearing," which means stolen. Even when disposed of at a discount, this stolen oil would fetch a minimum of $20 million American dollars a day for those corrupt officials siphoning it off. Experts are certain that not all of this leaves the country, however. At least half the money ends up being "recycled" into the Iraqi black economy to buy loyalties, services, arms, protection, and villas with swimming pools. In the end, this money creates jobs and demand for more dinars.

Ironically, both Iran and Syria, which are working hard to undermine Iraq, are boosting the dinar too. By pumping millions of dollars to support Shiites and Sunni insurgents, buy arms, and make bombs, they are also ratcheting up demand for dinars, since the fighters, the militias, and the secret cells all need to be paid in local currencies instead of dollars so as to keep a lower profile.

The biggest spender in town, the American Army, seems to be deliberately helping with the new pay-in-dinar policy, as noted by Major Richard Santiago, commander of 3rd Finance Company, 3rd Soldier Support Battalion, Division Support Brigade. "Issuing dinar check payments improves the economic and financial stability of Iraq by promoting the Iraqi banks while using their local currency. It also decreases the cash requirements our finance offices need in order to meet mission requirements," Major Santiago told the defense-oriented Web site GlobalSecurity.org a few days ago.

Of course, the dinar has a long way to go against the dollar. In its heyday in the 1980s, one dinar fetched almost three dollars compared to the present — reverse — ratio of one dollar to more than 1,300 dinars.

How long this is going to last is anyone's guess.

It could be argued that, in a sinister way, everything terrible that could have happened in Iraq has happened, so what else could sap confidence in the dinar — short of an abrupt American withdrawal? A good point indeed. The same logic applies to oil, which has been falling in price like a rock even though demand has not diminished. As with oil, the dinar was pushed by psychological factors that attached a monetary premium devaluing it. As Iraqis get used to the fear, the premium lifts.
Posted by:Steve White

#5  For some reason, Shipman, I'm not able to get your link to load. Anyways, it seems that I remember reading somewhere that in late 2005/early 2006, when gas here was over $3/gallon (and for at least a quarter, or maybe even 6 months) that China's demand had dropped by 1/3! They just simply couldn't afford it. India was probably in the same boat. That probably carried over and impacted the total somewhat.

Add to that the fact that an entire city (New Orleans) pretty much lost every single car (and bus) in it's perimeter. Those who stayed behind in Mississippi didn't fare any better. These "little things" add up to some serious drop in demand (worldwide).
Posted by: BA   2007-01-20 20:43  

#4  From the link above
Jet fuel demand declined by 2.8 percent to 1.6 million barrels a day, as airlines conserved fuel as best they could.
That's about 10 times what what Nazi Germany ran Europe with.
Posted by: Shipman   2007-01-20 12:25  

#3  Oddly enough especially in light of what Glenmore says petroleum demand dropped last year. I can't tell if that's just imports or drawdowns from inventory tho.
Posted by: Shipman   2007-01-20 12:04  

#2  And if the GWOT (and Iraq Campaign) are going so badly, why is the price of oil dropping? The Dow is high and unemployment low, so it's not that the US economy is collapsing and dropping demand for oil. And if the US economy is strong, the world economy can't be but so bad. Conservation efforts are a slow process. That leaves increased supply (Sunni Gulf nations putting economic pressure on Iran via the oil pump?) and decreased risk perception as major factors. Either or both signal progress on the Islamofascist front.
Posted by: Glenmore   2007-01-20 10:57  

#1  J. Paul Bremer should get the lion's share of the credit for the incredibly difficult and unrewarding job of laying the foundation for Iraq's economy in the future.

Taking a page from MacArthur's restoration of Japan, but doing him one better, Bremer has assured, all else being equal, that Iraq will be the powerhouse of the Middle East in the future.

Ironically, what he did will become textbook for nation building in other countries. For example, since Iraq was a "tabula rasa", a blank slate, he could choose from the very best economic innovations and practices from around the world, with utter pragmatism.

Even better, in other countries, those practices were never "perfect", because of the process they had to go through to be used in the first place. Unnecessary baggage that inhibited them, and mistakes made in innovating them.

But in Iraq's case, Bremer had the ideal situation found only in games like "Sim City", except as created by the finest capitalist economists in the world, in Bremer's opinion.

So Iraq has been given the best in the Middle East in banking and finance, stock markets, insurance and currency. Again, all else being equal, all it needs is time and some degree of stability.

Eventually, I expect the Iraqi Dinar to be one of the top currencies in the world, and their stock market to be followed as closely as the DOW and NASDAQ.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2007-01-20 09:36  

00:00