You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Fifth Column
Progressives are too Conservative to Like Capitalism
2006-10-08


EFL for fair use and length. I wish that I had written this one-EB


Most "progressives" (meaning those on the left to far left who prefer that term) would freak if they were called conservative, but what I mean by conservative in this context is not donate-to-Jesse-Helms capital-C Conservative but fearful of change and uncomfortable with uncertainty conservative.

OK, most of you are looking at this askance - aren't progressives always trying to overthrow the government or something? Aren't they out starting riots at G7 talks? The answer is yes, sure, but what motivates many of them, at least where it comes to capitalism, is a deep-seated conservatism...

[...]

...Progressives who support the right to a person making unfettered choices in sexual partners don't trust people to make their own choice on seat belt use. Progressives who support the right of fifteen year old girls to make decisions about abortion without parental notification do not trust these same girls later in life to make their own investment choices with their Social Security funds. And, Progressives who support the right of third worlders to strap on a backpack of TNT and explode themselves in the public market don't trust these same third worlders to make the right decision in choosing to work in the local Nike shoe plant.

Beyond just the concept of individual decision-making, progressives are hugely uncomfortable with capitalism. Ironically, though progressives want to posture as being "dynamic", the fact is that capitalism is in fact too dynamic for them. Industries rise and fall, jobs are won and lost, recessions give way to booms. Progressives want comfort and certainty. They want to lock things down the way they are. They want to know that such and such job will be there tomorrow and next decade, and will always pay at least X amount. That is why, in the end, progressives are all statists, because, to paraphrase Hayek, only a government with totalitarian powers can bring the order and certainty and control of individual decision-making that they crave.

More at link
Posted by:Ernest Brown

#4  They're also blue-noses that make the Pilgrims look like libertines. Sure, they don't care how you reach an orgasm, but just *try* to light up a cigarette, enjoy the wrong movies, or the wrong books.
Posted by: Rob Crawford   2006-10-08 18:18  

#3  Oh that's a *good* article - it's almost like the old Kirk 'confuse the robot with a paradox and watch it pop it's clogs' ploy....
Posted by: Tony (UK)   2006-10-08 14:01  

#2  Yeah, that's why I call them "regressivists." They're all Miniver Cheevy wannabes, going right back to Marx.

Even obvious things need to be articulated well, especially when too many people profess to see invisible clothes.
Posted by: Ernest Brown   2006-10-08 13:06  

#1  Hardly news here. All 'progressives' (a term I detest) are social (and historical) determinists precisely because they crave certainty of outcome. They are pathologically averse to anything genuinely new.
Posted by: phil_b   2006-10-08 13:01  

00:00