You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Half a million Pakistanis prospering in US
2006-08-22
There are 500,000 Pakistanis living in the United States and they are prospering, according to a forthcoming book by Adil Najam, a young Pakistani academic at Tufts University, Boston. The mean household income in the United States in 2002 was $57,852 annually, while that for Asian households, which includes Pakistanis, was $70,047. By contrast, about one-fifth of young British-born Muslims are jobless, and many subsist on welfare, the book says.

A report on the Pakistani community appearing in the New York Times on Monday notes, “Hard numbers on how many people of Pakistani descent live in the United States do not exist, but a forthcoming book from Harvard University Press on charitable donations among Pakistani-Americans, ‘Portrait of a Giving Community,’ puts the number around 500,000, with some 35 percent or more of them in the New York metropolitan area. Chicago has fewer than 100,000, while other significant clusters exist in California, Texas and Washington DC.”

“You can keep the flavour of your ethnicity, but you are expected to become an American...”
The newspaper report, filed from Chicago, describes in colourful terms a stretch of the sprawling city’s Devon Avenue, part of which is named for Quaid-i-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah and part for Mahatma Gandhi. Comparing Pakistani-Americans with their British counterparts, the report quotes Nizam Arain, a lawyer of Pakistani descent who was born and who grew up in Chicago, “You don’t have the same siege mentality.” Asked whether terror cells like those found in Britain could also spring up here, Junaid Rana, an assistant professor at a local university, said, “It makes it sound like it couldn’t happen here because we are the good immigrants: hard-working, close-knit, educated. But we are talking about a cult mind-set, how a cult does its brainwashing.” Omer Mozaffar, a Pakistani-American working for a doctorate at the University of Chicago, stated, “You can keep the flavour of your ethnicity, but you are expected to become an American.”

The newspaper quotes Pakistani poet, broadcaster and gay rights activist Ifti Nasim as saying that in Pakistan, his “flamboyance” would not be tolerated, but here he calls his acceptance “the litmus test of the society”. Like many, however, he has moments of doubt, saying, “Pakistani society in Chicago has made a smooth transition so far, but you never know”. Outward signs of religious devotion will arouse little suspicion in America compared with how they tend to be now viewed in Britain.

“Before, a good 70 percent of the women who came into his shop were veiled, he said. Now the reverse is true, and far fewer men wear traditional clothes”
However, a change would appear to have taken place because of recent accusations against Muslims of planning to stage terrorist acts in Europe and elsewhere. According to the New York Times report, “For the past eight years, Abdul Qadeer Sheikh, 46, has managed Islamic Books N Things on Devon Avenue, which sells items like Korans, prayer rugs and Arabic alphabet books. He says that since September 11, he has seen signs of the bias that has existed in Britain for decades developing here. He describes a distinctive fear of being seen as Muslim, even along Devon Avenue. Before, a good 70 percent of the women who came into his shop were veiled, he said. Now the reverse is true, and far fewer men wear traditional clothes.”
Posted by:Fred

#12  I'd imagine we've got very different profiles of Pakistani immigration here versus Britain. Commonwealth imigration policies had the Brits taking in many unskilled Pakistani workers in the 50s and 60s who never really integrated.

Farrukh Dhondy had a piece in the WSJ a couple of weeks ago looking at the cultural aspects of Pakistani immigration to Britain
Posted by: Classical_Liberal   2006-08-22 22:35  

#11  HOW MANY OF THEM OWN CONVENINCE STORES?
Posted by: honkey   2006-08-22 16:14  

#10  ****ANECDOTAL EVIDENCE ALERT****

In my daily life, I know a half-dozen or so Pakistani immigrants. All of them are upper-crust, educated in private schools in Karachi, speak English better than Urdu. Half are Sunni, half are Shia.

None are exactly chomping at the Islamist bit. One fellow homebrews beer in his basement, but doesn't dare tell his family back in Pakiland, who are still mad at him for marrying an American woman.

Another gal told her parents to stuff it when they wanted her to wear the headscarf when she reached puberty. She also does not identify herself as a Muslim.

Of course, it could all be a clever ruse to cause me to lower my guard and scratch them off my "Folks to Kill When Al Qaeda Nukes Chicago" list.
Posted by: Dreadnought   2006-08-22 12:29  

#9  It's as accurate as the claim of 7 million muslims in the US, or 8 million or 11 million depending on how much stress CAIR is under at the time. The most reliable survey was done in 2001 and was less than 2 million. Though the number of muslims doubled in the 1990's. (Thank Clinton) Since Sept. 2001, muslim immgration better have halted and those here encouraged to return.
Posted by: ed   2006-08-22 12:21  

#8  The Census Bureau puts the Pakistani population in the U.S. at 153,533 for the 2000 census. The number climbs to 204,309 if one includes those of partial Pakistani ancestry.

The claim of 500,000 Pakistanis in the U.S. is highly doubtful.
Posted by: Biff Wellington   2006-08-22 11:58  

#7  yes SOP, the Pak community in the US is constantly being solicited by Islamic charities and other Islamic orgs; sometimes the solicitation gets coersive

a lot of the wealthier Paks are pretty sick of this and a few Paks have decided to become non ethnic but most try to plead financial distress and some get tricked into giving more than they can afford

many more muslims who are victims of Islam
Posted by: mhw   2006-08-22 11:42  

#6  Since they are making so much money, you can bet your ass that they are major contributors to charities for "children".
Posted by: SOP35/Rat   2006-08-22 11:18  

#5  An even more simple way of saying it:

"America is a melting pot, not a salad bowl".
Posted by: mcsegeek1   2006-08-22 11:17  

#4  Â“You can keep the flavour of your ethnicity, but you are expected to become an American...”

Yes! I've been trying to find a simple, articulate sentence to express my view of immigrant integration and this man nailed it. Can we get "Explain this sentence in your own words: You can keep the flavour of your ethnicity, but you are expected to become an American..." as an essay question on the citizenship test?
Posted by: psychohillbilly   2006-08-22 10:41  

#3  Forced integration. What a wonderful policy.
Posted by: bigjim-ky   2006-08-22 09:09  

#2  Yet the Amish do not worry about being identified.....
Posted by: Bobby   2006-08-22 06:48  

#1  Sure you don't mean prospecting?
Posted by: gromgoru   2006-08-22 05:05  

00:00