You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Syria-Lebanon-Iran
Asian evacuation from Lebanon flounders
2006-07-21
HONG KONG - Asian governments struggled on Thursday toevacuate nationals from war-torn Lebanon, with some coming in for criticism, as the Philippine president asked for 30,000 Filipinos trapped by the conflict to be spared.
Guess we're not the only ones a little slow off the mark.
President Gloria Arroyo, facing criticism for failing to do enough for the stranded Filipinos, many of whom are female domestic workers, insisted her government was doing everything it could.

But Filipino officials have conceded they are unable to evacuate thousands of people on their own and have asked foreign governments for help. “The Philippines makes a special appeal to all combatant forces to spare Filipino nationals who have no wish other than to be taken out of harm’s way,” the president said in a statement. “In the name of humanity, I ask the combatants not to harm them,” she added, while appealing for other countries to “help us in the evacuation process.”

The foreign ministry said a majority of thw workers wanted to stay with their employers and the decision on evacuation was up to them. But Connie Regalado of suppport group Migrante International denied most Filipinos wanted to stay. “There is just neglect in the slowness by which the government responded,” Regalado said as she led families of workers stuck in Lebanon in a protest outside the ministry.

Criticism of AustraliaÂ’s evacuation effort also mounted Thursday. The effort has suffered several setbacks, including the failure of a chartered ferry to arrive at BeirutÂ’s port Wednesday because it was double-booked.

Foreign Minister Alexander Downer said hundreds more Australians were left stranded on the dock after Israel refused to extend a deadline and guarantee a Greek navy rescue ship safe passage. He said six ships were scheduled to arrive in Lebanon from Friday to evacuate around 6,000 Australians, providing the ships could get into BeirutÂ’s packed port.

“People have the impression that the evacuation is a farce and the government does not care,” Keysar Trad, the outspoken founder of the Islamic Friendship Association of Australia, told AFP. Sections of the Australian press were also critical. “Exodus descends into farce,” said The Sydney Morning Herald in its front-page headline.

Australian Prime Minister John Howard rejected criticism. “The main message I want to convey to distressed relatives in Australia and indeed through them to their loved ones in Lebanon is that we are concerned, we have not abandoned them,” he said.

Canberra said there were some 25,000 Australians in Lebanon, although the majority have dual nationality and did not plan to leave.
Posted by:Steve White

#6  It's not just me then, questioning the nationalilty of these "evacuees" the abilty to speak fluent english/hindi/spanish whatever! and a single nationality passport should be a prerequisite.
Posted by: pihkalbadger   2006-07-21 14:26  

#5  I don't think we should be responsible for paying for the exit of dual-nationals unless they can prove they have a residence in the USA and were just visiting. People make a choice to keep dual nationality.
Posted by: 2b   2006-07-21 10:57  

#4  and the Toronto Sun lets us hear from the grateful "Canadian" lebanese evacuated yesterday:

LARNACA, Cyprus -- The first group of Canadian evacuees fleeing war-torn Lebanon began the day on a hellish boat ride marked by seasickness, sunstroke and dehydration -- and they ended it aboard the prime minister's plane.

About 260 weary evacuees disembarked yesterday from the Blue Dawn, with passengers describing the trip across the eastern Mediterranean as difficult -- without air conditioning, adequate water and provisions for the ill.

"It was hell,"cried one woman, wheeling her baby away from the boat in a stroller.

"Everybody was vomiting on everybody," said Caroline Nohra of Montreal. "It was very miserable. The kids were scared, screaming, panicking."


But the owners of the boat clear up a few things..
Ian Wilson, engineering consultant to the owner of the ship, denied that the ride was out of the ordinary. He said people get seasick on every ride, especially those who ride boats for the first time.

The Canadian government didn't put enough water on the boat, which has air conditioning, Wilson said, but passengers kept opening the windows.


Whining muslims, right through the rescue. Appalling. Should've left them there. Same whining women flew back to Canada on Harper's plane - still bitchin'.

I say leave the remaining 49,000 in southern Lebanon where they are. Most haven't been in Canada in decades. Canadians of convenience. It's not convenient to come get your Hezb-loving asses.
Posted by: Thinemp Whimble2412   2006-07-21 10:03  

#3  anybody in Lebanon, knowing it was on the frontlines of a war zone, should STFU and quit bitching cuz their ass isn't being pulled from the fire fast enough. Has Hezbollah been a secret? No. Has the Syrian/Lebanese conflict been a secret? No.
Posted by: Frank G   2006-07-21 09:24  

#2  Some Asian governments are evacuating just fine



Foreigners of mainly Indian nationality queue up next to the INS Mumbai, as they wait to be evacuated at the Beirut port
The evacuees are being ferried to Larnaca in Cyprus by INS Mumbai, which reached the Beirut port earlier in the day as part of the mission -- 'Operation Sukoon'. After reaching Larnaca tomorrow morning, they will be airlifted to India by special flights of Air India. Two more warships -- INS Shakti and INS Betwa -- are near the Beirut port and will enter the harbour one by one to rescue about 12,000 Indians living in Lebanon.

Posted by: john   2006-07-21 09:08  

#1  If Ameica went in and pulled every filipino out the government would bitch that we did not pull them first. That country sell their people for near slave labor, human services is their #1 export, and then begs for help when trouble arrives. Leave them there, make arroyo responsible for her own. Rememder how they cut and run from Iraq over one hostage.
Posted by: 49 Pan   2006-07-21 07:38  

00:00