You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Afghanistan
Indian soap operas ‘addiction’ in Afghanistan
2006-05-18
Afghanistan is a deeply conservative Islamic society where family problems are invariably kept hidden behind a veil of privacy. The Indian soap operas are gaining popularity with every passing day DonÂ’t telephone an Afghan at 8.30 in the evening. Chances are, he or she will be settled down in front of the television for a daily fix of an Indian soap opera. And they wonÂ’t want to be disturbed.

The series “The mother-in-law was a daughter-in-law once too”, or “Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi” in its original Hindi, has transfixed the country. Men, women, young and old - anyone, it seems, with access to a television - is enthralled by the family drama. It centres on Tulsi, a young bride from a poor family who married because of love and is persecuted by her evil mother-in-law. For the first time, Afghans have been able to see a long-running family drama that explores so many of the issues they encounter in their own lives, said television commentator Farzana Samimi. “It shows problems that are so common in Afghan families in terms of the relationship of brides in the family, especially with the mother-in-law,” said Samimi, who presents a programme on women’s issues on Tolo TV, which broadcasts the series. Afghanistan is still a deeply conservative Islamic society where family problems are invariably kept hidden behind a veil of privacy. The series gets people thinking about such problems, Samimi said. “It enlightens the minds of people in the family, not only of brides or mothers-in-laws, but others too.”

The cultural context of the Indian soap opera was also very easy for Afghans to relate to, she said. “People are interested because our culture is so close to India, their way of daily life, the hierarchical system in the family,” she said.

Whatever the reason, the soap opera is AfghanistanÂ’s most popular ever television programme and fans refuse to miss an episode. Generator shops in Kabul have reported heavy sales since the series caught on because so many people want to ensure the cityÂ’s frequent power cuts donÂ’t interrupt their viewing. Many fans who canÂ’t afford a generator have rigged up their televisions to car batteries to beat the black-outs.

Tolo TV, the most popular channel to appear since the ouster of the Taliban in 2001, says it is amazed by the success of the series. It declines to say how much it paid to broadcast it. “It’s our biggest series. We’re surprised to see so many people interested in watching it so keenly,” said Saad Mohseni, a Tolo director.

Tolo began running the soap opera, dubbed into Afghanistan’s Dari language, this year. It began in India several years ago and is still running, so Tolo has lots more episodes to run. Every day, the TV station gets calls from people asking for the episodes to be extended and complaining about the interruptions for advertisments, said another Tolo official, Ahmad Tawab Niazi. Some fans have begged Tolo to change the broadcast time because it coincides with congregational prayers at mosques, he said. Some postpone their prayers. “Let’s pray later, I can’t miss Tulsi,” a man murmured to his friend recently in a restaurant in the western city of Herat.

The show was about to begin on a television in the restaurant. “It’s like an addiction,” the man said. Mohseni said he had heard stories of a wedding banquet being interrupted so the guests could huddle around the television for half an hour.

Some are taking advantage of the obsession. Robbers in the northern city of Mazar-i-Sharif stripped a vehicle of its wheels and mirrors recently, confident they had a mid-evening window of half an hour when they wouldn’t be caught. “Thanks Tulsi,” one of the robbers scrawled in paint on the side of the car.
Posted by:Fred

#10  
#8: Agreed!

#9: Agreed!

Goodnight gentlemen!

-M
Posted by: Manolo   2006-05-18 23:18  

#9  "Do you really believe there are communal viewing venues in every podunk little village in Afghanistan?"

No, I don't - and I didn't say that - I said it would be wasted on the jaded Kabulis. The Nat Geo documentary was filmed in Kabul. It wasn't staged in some studio. So I guess it was real, since the station manager proudly displayed about 500 movie tapes and they showed the audience watching an evening's fare. Yeah, it was real.

We agree a taste of the outside world would do the people out in the sticks a lot of good.

No grief was intended. I hope for the best in Afghanistan and currently have only the performance of their Army and Karzai's growing confidence to speak openly about ISI subversion to be somewhat happy about. Have a nice evening, gentlemen.
Posted by: eniac   2006-05-18 23:15  

#8  no flame - I just think that whatever the viewing rate, and I have no reason to doubt you, it's a start....just like Iran's edict to remove Sat dishes (roundly disobeyed) - it helps to liberate thought and in Iran's case, delegitimize regime authority
Posted by: Frank G   2006-05-18 22:52  

#7  
Do you really believe there are communal viewing venues in every podunk little village in Afghanistan? Oh, NatGeo, well then it must be true. They have their agenda too.

I've traveled the rural areas in Afghanistan, Pakistan and India. Recently. They're pretty much the same, that holds true for the cities for the most part.

The difference between city dwellers and rural folk (villagers) is quite similar. The difference is that in India, 20% of the population is educated. Afghanistan and Pakistan... 10% and 15% respectively.

As for servants, those with money never do their own cooking and cleaning...etc. That is how it is that part of the world. CHEAP labor is plentiful.

In that part of the world, one $hithole is pretty much the same as another. And Delhi is most definitely a $hithole. So is Kabul.

True, Frank G, Kabul isn't Delhi, but the differences are not that great. The majority of the population never gets to see these Soap Operas, and it's the ones that don't get to see them that could benefit the most from them.

Still it is a start.

Both you guy's, I'm not looking to start a flame fest, but until you've been there and seen for yourself, don't read too much into what you read in the Daily Times of Pakistan. It's even less reliable than the NYT! And that ain't sayin' much.

Chalo then.

-M
Posted by: Manolo   2006-05-18 22:47  

#6  Delhi ain't Kabul, neh?
Posted by: Frank G   2006-05-18 22:15  

#5  Oops! You're right Manolo - it will be wasted on those jaded Kabulis. I think a couple of things differ between Afghanistan and India, however. There are communal viewing venues in Kabul - for movies and TV - saw it in a NatGeo documentary produced within a month after the fall of the Taliban. And yes, there was a TV station back in operation in a month - with a cache of movies that had been hidden, LOL. They were wildly popular. As for domestic servants, hmmmmmmm. I'd bet only the UN folks would be hiring people who aren't family or trusted members of the Warlord's domain - for security reasons - among those who can afford servants. And I think the "theaters" will stay open for reruns as long as there are paying customers. Commerce is one thing the Afghanis do well.

Ah well, too bad. I guess I let my optimism get the best of me. Thanks for the post - I learn or remember something here every time I drop by. :)
Posted by: eniac   2006-05-18 21:59  

#4  
"...never been exposed to anything but what passes for normal in their village."

Well...in the VAST majority of the "villages" they do not have: full time electricity, running water OR TV's!

So the only places these shows are being watched is in the cities. City folk are a whole different breed from the country bumpkins that live in the villages.

The majority of the village folks that come to the big cities live in slums, no TV there either. What TV the do get exposed to is in the homes of the middle class, where they work as domestics, and have scant time for watching TV.

Kind of shoots your theory down.

How do I know all this? I live in Delhi 6 months a year, I'm married to an Indian.

-M
Posted by: Manolo   2006-05-18 18:36  

#3  -- “LetÂ’s pray later, I canÂ’t miss Tulsi,” a man murmured to his friend recently in a restaurant in the western city of Herat.--

BINGO!
Posted by: anonymous2u   2006-05-18 13:51  

#2  Well said, Anonymoose. Some don't realize that many people have never been exposed to anything but what passes for normal in their village. Ideas, new ideas, amazing ideas, blasphemous ideas, acted out as though normal. 'twill boggle, at first, then be contrasted against wild-eyed raving Holy Mokes and repressive rules... Then the questions come. We should collect donations to buy them popcorn.
Posted by: eniac   2006-05-18 02:04  

#1  This is excellent. It opens the door, big time, for exploration of social issues that have no other forum in Afghanistan. Suddenly everybody is on the same sheet of music.

Instead of broaching the subject directly, which in such a conservative society would be risky, they can just say, "Did you see the show last night?" If they answer "Yes", the ice is broken.

Just a little more diplomatic niceties to find out if you can talk about it, and most of the time you have a good hour-long discussion or argument about whatever it was. And it's not like it is *your* opinion. It's just something you both saw on TV. And how about that?
Posted by: Anonymoose   2006-05-18 00:23  

00:00