| Submit your comments on this article |
| Europe |
| Dutch report on Islam stirs up controversy |
| 2006-04-22 |
| A new report submitted to the Dutch government has sparked controversy by arguing that Islam does not conflict with either human rights or Dutch values. Islam has been a hot topic in the Netherlands since the killing of a controversial film-maker, Theo van Gogh, by a young Muslim in 2004. In a country traditionally seen as one of the most liberal and tolerant in Europe, Islam and Muslims are now viewed with suspicion. The report is the fruit of three years' work by the Scientific Council for Government Policy (WRR), a think-tank in The Hague which advises the government. It examines the evolution of thinking about democracy and human rights in a dozen Muslim countries, ranging from Egypt and Iran to Indonesia. Jan Schoonenboom, a member of the council who supervised the research, says it highlights the variety and dynamism of Islamic activism. While there are radical, jihadi trends, there are also more mainstream Islamic movements which are moving, albeit slowly, towards democratisation. The report has already been roundly attacked. The Somali-born Dutch MP Ayaan Hirsi Ali, a well-known critic of Islam, has said it lacks professionalism and undermines free speech. On the contrary, Mr Schoonenboom told the BBC, by discussing Islam in this way the report is opening up serious debate and challenging widely-accepted stereotypes. He and his colleagues take issue with Ms Hirsi Ali and others who say Islam is not compatible with democracy or women's rights or Dutch values. Such generalisations, he says, are not just wrong but dangerous - creating a divide between us and them. The report also looks at the topical issue of how the world should respond to the growing influence of Islamist groups such as Hamas in the Palestinian territories, the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt and Hezbollah in Lebanon. Rather than isolating these groups, it argues, the Netherlands and the European Union should reach out to them to encourage progress towards democracy. By cutting aid to Hamas, says Mr Schoonenboom, the United States and EU have created a gap which countries like Iran and Qatar are rushing to fill. The 250-page report was handed in to the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs on 12 April. Supporters and opponents are now waiting for the government to submit its formal response to parliament. |
| Posted by:Dan Darling |
| #10 "By cutting aid to Hamas, says Mr Schoonenboom, the United States and EU have created a gap which countries like Iran and Qatar are rushing to fill." That's quite a gap to fill. The cut was (IIRC) a billion dollars, and the Iran/Qatar pledge is 1/10 of that. |
| Posted by: James 2006-04-22 17:30 |
| #9 The Sharia for Muslims is comparable to the Ten Commandments for Christians, in the researcher's view. No, there are only 10 commandments in the Ten Commandments, and they apply very specifically to the individual's own behaviour, not about regulating others. The Sharia applies to all aspects of behaviour, and requires that they be imposed upon the entire world. |
| Posted by: trailing wife 2006-04-22 16:45 |
| #8 my guess is there were no Mohammed cartoons in the report. I'd like to see the reaction to it if it did.... |
| Posted by: Frank G 2006-04-22 16:20 |
| #7 According to Schoonenboom "we should not be so spastic about the Sharia." It may be that the system leads to corporal punishment in countries like Saudi Arabia and Sudan, "but under the Sharia in Morocco, family law has been reformed, very much to the advantage of women's rights." The Sharia for Muslims is comparable to the Ten Commandments for Christians, in the researcher's view. "It is God's plan for human nature." |
| Posted by: john 2006-04-22 15:48 |
| #6 Spot on SPoD - a TRANZI report designed to gloss over the real issues. 'Roundly attacked?' - sounds like the sheeple are beginning to whiff a rat! |
| Posted by: Tony (UK) 2006-04-22 15:00 |
| #5 arguing that Islam does not conflict with either human rights or Dutch values. And we'll kill anyone who says it does! |
| Posted by: VAMark 2006-04-22 10:32 |
| #4 Islam does not conflict with either human rights or Dutch values. Ripe for plucking. |
| Posted by: gromgoru 2006-04-22 09:41 |
| #3 Poor, deluded bastards. These people have become terminally tolerant; in a couple of decades they'll be living under shariah. |
| Posted by: Dave D. 2006-04-22 08:44 |
| #2 From the outside, self-hating cultures appear to behave in bizarre ways. |
| Posted by: gromky 2006-04-22 05:53 |
| #1 A report by TRANZIs that intends to white wash reality. Who am I going to trust some Socailist eggheads or an ex-muslim who lives under police guard becdaue of the real threat of death from muslims? |
| Posted by: SPoD 2006-04-22 02:12 |