You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Europe
Paris court OKs magazine re-publishing the Mohammed cartoons
2006-02-08
Lightly EFL
A French court refused to order the confiscation of a magazine on Tuesday which local Muslim organisations tried to prevent from publishing controversial cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad.

The satirical weekly Charlie-Hebdo was due to publish on Wednesday 12 cartoons originally printed by the Danish paper Jyllens-Posten which have caused outrage in the Muslim world. "This is good news to us all," Charlie-Hebdo editor Philippe Val told reporters after the ruling. "We are defending the principle of the right for caricature and satire."

The judges rejected demands by French Muslim organisations, including the French Council of Muslim Faith (CFCM) and the Grand Mosques of Paris and Lyon, which had argued the paper was undermining the principle of the respect of faiths. The court did not rule on the contents of the claim, but rejected it on a technicality, saying the plaintiffs had failed to follow several points of procedure in filing their suit.

Sources at Charlie-Hebdo said the weekly's offices and some staff had been placed under police protection ahead of Wednesday's publication, which will also feature a cartoon of Prophet Muhammad burying his face in his hands and saying: "It's hard to be loved by fools". Oh, dear. Poor Mohammed.
Posted by:trailing wife

#4  I dont think many of these cartoons would make it into ANY US newspaper. We tend to censure ourselves, at least the Newspaper editors do.
Posted by: bk   2006-02-08 11:59  

#3  I dont think many of this guys cartoons would make it into ANY US newspaper.
Posted by: bk   2006-02-08 11:57  

#2  Hum, mods, any chance of fixing the cartoons, the formating is all mixed up?
Posted by: anonymous5089   2006-02-08 07:50  

#1  Actually, it's "it's hard to be loved by dumf*cks", but the idea is there...

Charlie Hebdo is a long-running, hard-biting, often offensive leftist satirical weekly, with caricatures I think you couldn't see in the USA (such, I don't know, as Shiraq being "persuaded" to be candidate for the 2002 presidential elections by being fellated and sodomized by Sarko and I-don't-remember-who, while doing the double "V for victory", you see the type).
I used to read them back in the olden days... they ARE funny!

Redaction is partaged between idiotarian and anti-idiotarian, apparently the latter have won.
Reason why they're antimuslim is because they're aggressively atheist and opposed to organized religion.
I've bought this issue, which apparently sells very well, well beyond usual runs, and I've got mixed feelings; editorials are pretty clear on where they stand and pull no punches, but they also shoot at "others fundamentalisms" (read : jewish and christian), so I feel they miss the point a little bit, like the Mo' cover, which doesn't acknowledge IMHO the "rotten roots" of islam as established by the Prophet(tm).

Cover of this week edition



Old cartoon from the 2002 nigerian beauty contest riots (already an organized wave of letter, threats,... at the time).
*Miss potatoes bag election, organized by Muhammad*, old Mo' : "I choose the Belle-de-Fontenay" (Miss France organizer).



*No amalgam*, "Moderate islam/Radical islam" (july 2005)



More Charlie hebdo pics, from Google, so you can get an idea of the mag.
Posted by: anonymous5089   2006-02-08 07:49  

00:00