You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Politix
Dean Claims Iraq War Gaffe Taken 'Out of Context'
2005-12-08
Democratic Party Chairman Howard Dean said Thursday his assertion that the United States cannot win the war in Iraq was reported "a little out of context," saying Democrats believe a new U.S. strategy is needed to succeed there. Seeking to clarify a statement in a Texas radio interview that Republicans harshly assailed and some Democrats questioned, Dean said, "They kind of cherry-picked that one the same way the president cherry-picked the intelligence going into Iraq."

Dean was questioned on CNN about an interview he gave Monday to radio station WOAI in San Antonio. "The idea that we're going to win this war is an ideal that unfortunately is just plain wrong," the former Vermont governor and unsuccessful 2004 presidential candidate said. His Republican counterpart, Ken Mehlman, called Dean's prediction "outrageous" and said it "sends the wrong message to our troops, the enemy, and the Iraqi people just 10 days before historic elections."

On Thursday, Dean stressed at several junctures in the interview that Democrats support U.S. troops struggling to secure Iraq. He seemed to be striving to counter charges that statements by some Democrats suggesting a pullout are having the effect of undermining U.S. servicemen and women. Democrats have been struggling to find party unity on Iraq. Dean's broadside Monday, likening Iraq to the Vietnam experience, went beyond an earlier call by Rep. John Murtha, D-Pa., to begin to pull troops out. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., embraced Murtha's position Wednesday. But other Democrats have been more cautious about second-guessing President Bush on this issue.

Sen. Joseph Lieberman, D-Conn., said earlier this week that Democrats "undercut the president's credibility at our nation's peril."

Asked Thursday to defend his statement in the Texas radio interview, Dean said: "It was a little out of context. ... We can only win if we change our strategy dramatically. ... We want to serve our troops well. They're doing a fantastic job in Iraq." Dean charged that Bush is "going in the wrong direction. We'll go in the right direction and save soldiers lives while we're doing it." "We can and we have to win the war on terror," the Democratic Party chairman added. "We can't do it with this kind of approach."

Asked about Lieberman's statement, Dean replied, "I am not as worried about the president's credibility. ... We need to redeploy our troops and stop making our troops the target over there. We believe that talking about the president's failed strategy is not unpatriotic. It may undercut the president but it does not undercut the troops. We are for the troops and we are going to support the troops." He acknowledged, however, that Democrats "may have some small disagreements" on the timing of any withdrawal.
Posted by:Steve

#19  With nut cases like screamer Dean and Hillary as elected "representatives of the people," it is really no wonder the rest of the world thinks were a bit off.
Posted by: Besoeker   2005-12-08 20:28  

#18  Tape recorded statements are a bitch, arent they, Hard as hell to say"I didn't say that" when it's recorded.
Posted by: Redneck Jim   2005-12-08 20:23  

#17  Nothing says "I support you" quite like "You're doomed; you're all gonna die." That's good support, Doc.

Nimrod.
Posted by: eLarson   2005-12-08 19:34  

#16  Some how the word "context" just doesn't seem to apply to anybody as far out-there as Dr Dean.

context - dean
dean - context
scream - dean
scream - context

no ... doesn't work.
Posted by: 3dc   2005-12-08 15:19  

#15  Dean can cram his defeatist attitude where the sun don't shine. WITH WALNUTS!
Posted by: Zenster   2005-12-08 15:13  

#14  Has anyone ever seen Dean and Bagdad Bob at the same place at the same time? Ever?

Explains a lot.
Posted by: CrazyFool   2005-12-08 15:12  

#13  Dean can cram his defeatist attitude where the sun don't shine. WITH WALNUTS!
Posted by: Zenster   2005-12-08 15:12  

#12  Looks like Dean and ol Bagdad Bob may have been seperated at birth.
Posted by: 49 pan   2005-12-08 14:30  

#11  I do not take anything out of context. I never worked an honest day in my life. I have nothing better to do than listen to dean natter natter.
Posted by: newc   2005-12-08 12:37  

#10  I wonder how well Dean expressed himself as a doctor. "Dude, when I told you you had two weeks to live, I didn't exactly mean you had two weeks to live. You took that one little remark out of context. You're really doing quite well, for a guy on death's door, I mean. Aaarrrgh!"
Posted by: Matt   2005-12-08 12:34  

#9  Howard Dean has his Ahmadhinejad moment. He says something dangerous, undeniable, memorable and quotable. What part of "just plain wrong" don't we understand, doctor?
Posted by: Grunter   2005-12-08 12:20  

#8  House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., embraced Murtha's position Wednesday.

AFTER the Presidents speech Pelosi said...
"We should follow the lead of Congressman John Murtha..."
But of course there is that little vote thingy...403-3...Sorry Nancy...you wern't even one of the 3.

And the President has a credibility problem?
Posted by: DepotGuy   2005-12-08 11:52  

#7  Fish in a barrel. I love this shit!
Posted by: The Evil Karl Rove   2005-12-08 11:32  

#6  Yeah, I meant to say "We don't want us to win in Iraq". Thanks for the opportunity to clarify that.
Posted by: Howard Dean: Important Guy   2005-12-08 11:30  

#5  Asked Thursday to defend his statement in the Texas radio interview, Dean said: "It was a little out of context. ... We can only win if we change our strategy dramatically. ...

"The idea that we're going to win this war is an ideal that unfortunately is just plain wrong,"


"Out of context"? Sounds like a pile of crap to me.
Posted by: Bomb-a-rama   2005-12-08 11:27  

#4  Dean said, "They kind of cherry-picked that one the same way the president cherry-picked the intelligence going into Iraq."


Dean's really into cherry-picking ... is he a gynecologist?
Posted by: The Happy Fliegerabwehrkanonen   2005-12-08 11:15  

#3  We are for the troops and we are going to support the troops.

"'Cause we'll catch hell if we spit on them like we want to..."
Posted by: Pappy   2005-12-08 11:09  

#2  Not "taken out of context." But "taken a little out of context"
Posted by: 2b   2005-12-08 11:08  

#1  In other news, Saddam Hussein said that the war with Iran, the Invasion of Kuwait, the gassing of the Kurds, the efforts to procure and produce WMDs, and the establishment of a brutal authoritarian dictatorship were "taken out of context."

He also offered to apologize for anything the court wants him to apologize for, if it means that they won't hang him.
Posted by: Anonymoose   2005-12-08 11:04  

00:00