You have commented 358 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Iraq-Jordan
Jaafari criticises Arab League
2005-08-31
Either Amr Moussa or Jerry Lewis. I'm not sure which.
Iraqi Prime Minister Ibrahim al-Jaafari has criticised the Arab League over what he called its disregard for Iraq, after its chief demanded to know why a draft constitution failed to refer to the entire country as an Arab nation. "The Arab League must feel the Iraqi people's problems, and I told its secretary-general (Amr Moussa) during a telephone conversation that his organisation has been very slow to take an interest in the Iraqi people," al-Jaafari said in a statement on Tuesday. "We have not seen any Arab envoys in Baghdad while foreign officials are coming here one after another," he said, adding that Arab League leaders "have no right to cast doubt on Iraq's (political) experience ... they should change their position."

The contentious article of the draft constitution states that "Iraq is part of the Muslim world and its Arab people are part of the Arab nation". Moussa, who last week said the 22-member Arab League was disturbed by the charter, responded to al-Jaafari's comments saying he "has the right" to criticise. "But the occupation and the security situation have made blurry the Arab League's role in Iraq ... and al-Jaafari understands this," Moussa said in Cairo.
I'm still trying to figure what use the Arab League is to Iraq. Are they afraid the Kurds and Assyrians are going to take over? Even if they did, wouldn't the inhabitants still be the same people? If they spent less time on "maintaining stability" and fondling their "Arab identity" and more time on trying to figure how to improve the lot of The Masses™, the region would be a lot better off. I don't see the organization as anything more than a mutual masturbation society. I don't think Jaafari does, either — with the proviso that we're talking about the Middle East, where memories are long but attention spans are short.
Posted by:Fred

#7  "Either Amr Moussa or Jerry Lewis. I'm not sure which."

Either way, a hero in France.
Posted by: Xbalanke   2005-08-31 12:31  

#6  dan, you might want to read Daniel Pipes, "Greater Syria: The History of an Ambition"

Basically the Arab league served two purposes. 1. It was used to clamp down on identity changes that threatened arab nationalism. Since Jordanian king Abdullahs project for a Greater Syria, with himself as king, ran counter to arab nationalism (since it emphasized greater Syrian identity instead, and attempted to subordinated the arab nationalists among the palestinians to Abdullah) the Arab league was a tool against Abdullah, and to restrain Abdullah. It was also a tool wrt then Maronite dominated Lebanon - which in the 40s was flirting with a Francophone, European identity, rather than an Arab one. The deal was that Lebanon had to stay arab, and declare war on Israel, in return for which the League would guartantee Lebanons territorial integrity - IE Lebanon would get to keep all the mainly non-Maronite lands the French had gifted them with. (of course this was a bad deal for the Maronites long term, and I suppose Arik Sharon has been contemplating that precedent)
2. It was a way of expresssing arab national identity that didnt threaten individual regimes. So rather than a more aggressive arab nationalism, that would attempt to destroy individual arab regimes in favor of a pan-arab state, the force of arab nationalism was diverted into safer channels, esp the war with Israel.
Posted by: liberalhawk   2005-08-31 09:54  

#5  The Arab League is extremely unpopular with many ordinary Iraqis. Its best use is as a bogeyman. Al-Jaafari could win points if he could bring himself to denounce the League in forceful language.

Posted by: mhw   2005-08-31 08:56  

#4   I don't see what use the Arab League is, period. I mean what does it actually do?

For one thing, it took a pass on Saddam for a couple of decades while he killed millions.
Posted by: Captain America   2005-08-31 00:51  

#3  According to this site, it says in the Arab League charter:

The League has as its purpose the strengthening of the relations between the member-states, the coordination of their policies in order to achieve co-operation between them and to safeguard their independence and sovereignty; and a general concern with the affairs and interests of the Arab countries. It has also as its purpose the close co-operation of the member-states, with due regard to the Organisation and circumstances of each state, on the following matters :

A. Economic and financial affairs, including commercial relations, customs, currency and questions of agriculture an industry.
B. Communications; this includes railroads, roads, aviation, navigation, telegraphs and posts.
C. Cultural affairs.
D. Nationality, passports, visas, execution of judgments and extradition of criminals.
E. Social affairs.
F. Health affairs.


Sounds like the African Union with a bit more cash.
Posted by: Pappy   2005-08-31 00:33  

#2  That's Jerry. No self respecting Arab Leaguer would be caught dead without a 'stache.
Posted by: ed   2005-08-31 00:31  

#1   I don't see what use the Arab League is, period. I mean what does it actually do?
Posted by: Dan Darling   2005-08-31 00:07  

00:00