You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Admiral Nelson sunk by PC raiding party
2005-05-22
ADMIRAL NELSON saw off the mighty Franco-Spanish fleet at the battle of Trafalgar but 200 years on, he has been sunk by a wave of political correctness. Organisers of a re-enactment to mark the bicentenary of the battle next month have decided it should be between "a Red Fleet and a Blue Fleet" not British and French/Spanish forces. Otherwise they fear visiting dignitaries, particularly the French, would be embarrassed at seeing their side routed.

Even the official literature has been toned down. It describes the re-enactment not as the battle of Trafalgar but simply as "an early 19th-century sea battle". A host of French dignitaries will attend the event, which will take place off Southsea near Portsmouth, the home of Nelson's fleet. The aim is to create a spectacular "son et lumiere" re-enactment with pyrotechnics, lights and effects from barges in the Solent. Tall ships will create the illusion of a real battle. But the organisers of the event confirmed last week that there would be no national "sides", a fact that has surprised some of the event's sponsors. One said: "It seems remarkable that we are not saying this is Britain versus France in this re-enactment. Surely 200 years on, we can afford to gloat a bit. Not even the French can try and get snooty about this."
Posted by:CTICM(NAC)Ret

#7  I still love the Horatio Hornblower books. Maybe it's time to make an investment... Thanks for the idea, Angie, and Happy Birthday! in advance. Hope the boyfriend does good ;-)
Posted by: trailing wife   2005-05-22 22:48  

#6  I'm asking my boyfriend for them, is what I meant to say. The "no reason" comment only referred to the title of the second book, Death to the French.

I read O'Brian's The Wine-Dark Sea, and didn't like it; I thought it pretentious. I loved the movie Master and Commander, though, so I'll probably give them another try eventually.

Alexander Kent (real name: Douglas Reeman) also writes naval fiction of that era.
Posted by: Angie Schultz   2005-05-22 21:49  

#5  I don't think Angie was hoping to buy them herself LOL
Posted by: Frank G   2005-05-22 21:34  

#4  Buying all 20 Patrick O'Brian Aubrey/Maturin books too, Angie?
Posted by: Eric Jablow   2005-05-22 20:48  

#3  I'm asking for a bunch of C.S. Forester books for my birthday, including his biography of Nelson, and this book.

Why do I mention it? Oh, no reason...
Posted by: Angie Schultz   2005-05-22 16:32  

#2  I'm guessin' it's a upcoming EU vote courtesy thing.
Posted by: Seafarious   2005-05-22 15:54  

#1  This is crazy. Veterans of Iwo Jima, both Marines and Japanese, have met on the island for a reunion or two without either group getting their nose out of joint or fistfights breaking out. Someone correct me if I am mistaken but we really hated each other then. Actually, 'hate' is putting it mildly. I doesn't get any more brutal or inhuman than it was there.

AFAIK, we didn't refer to the Marines as 'Blue Team' or the Japanese as 'Red Team' either during those reunions.

Apparently, two mature cultures can do it.

Oh, I see the problem now. Grow up France and we might let you sit at the adult table. Or not.
Posted by: Doc8404   2005-05-22 15:15  

00:00