You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Europe
Survey: 60,000 French Jews want to move to Israel
2005-03-08
Some 60,000 French Jews are interested in immigrating to Israel, according to Bar-Ilan University research conducted by Dr. Arik Cohen. The research was based on questionnaires given to the 125,000 Jewish tourists from France who visited the country in the past summer. They constitute a third of the total population of French Jews. Of those asked, 52 percent said they see their future in Israel. Half of those aged 15-18 said they had personally experienced instances of anti-Semitism in the past four years. A third of the youth said they are considering immigration to Israel in the near future.

The findings were presented at a press conference in Jerusalem on Thursday, where the inauguration of AMI, an organization of French Jewry, was announced. The group will work toward increasing Jewish immigration from France. In the past year, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has called on French Jewry to immigrate to Israel. He angered the French government and a number of leaders of the Jewish community in France. The chairman of the Jewish Agency, Sallai Meridor, said Thursday that AMI constitutes an expression of support for immigration to Israel by the French Jewry. In the past three years, only 7,000 French Jews immigrated to Israel. AMI officials argue that many French Jews avoid immigration because of the difficulties experienced during their absorption - particularly in finding jobs.
It's okay to say you want to immigrate, but when it's time for rubber to hit the road few do, always hoping things will get better at home. It's only when you realize that home is shithole -- or that your neighbors are planning to kill you -- that you pack your bags.
Posted by:Steve White

#2  And considering there are only 58,000 Jews in Phrawnce.... ;-p
Posted by: Barbara Skolaut   2005-03-08 8:18:59 PM  

#1  1. France, for its problems is an advanced first world country - GDP per capita similar to Israel, if not higher. Not a sh*thole (other than geopolitically)

2. While antisemitic incidents have increased, and are nasty, its not like people are being killed except for rare, international headline grabbing incidents. Look, how many people stayed in or moved TO new york during its high crime years? Is living in Paris, or even Marseilles, NOW, more dangerous than living in New York in the late 70s? Is it more dangerous than living in Tel Aviv in 2002?
And of course the more affluent can insulate themselves - why would an affluent French Jew go near the banlieus? Its the less affluent, sephardic and orthodox French jews who are more exposed.

3. Making aliyah is a BIG decision. It involves uprooting ones whole life, to move to a country that is different in many ways - and the change of language is a huge issue, and bigger the older you are. Finding job in Israel is a big issue, even if you know Hebrew, depending on your field. And of course the language thing is even harder for the French than it would be for an American - English is virtually the second language there (more so that Arabic, the official second language) and an anglophone can get a job in international business there - for a francophone its that much harder. I saw an article some months back on French Jewish families that had moved, but the breadwinner kept his job in Paris, and visited the family in Israel on weekends.

It does look like french aliyah may increase, and thats good, and it will get easier as there are more French Jews in Israel. But I wouldnt derogate people making hesitating.
Posted by: liberalhawk   2005-03-08 11:13:13 AM  

00:00