You have commented 358 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Home Front: Culture Wars
Ralph Peters on Jim Mattis
2005-02-06
We've come to a sad state when a Marine who has risked his life repeatedly to keep our country safe can't speak his mind, while any professor who wants to blame America for 9/11 is defended by legions of free-speech advocates. If a man like Mattis hasn't earned the right to say what he really believes, who has? Had Gen. Mattis collapsed in tears and begged for pity for the torments war inflicted on him, the media would have adored him. Instead, he spoke as Marines and soldiers do in the headquarters tent or the barracks, on the battlefield or among comrades. And young journalists who never faced anything more dangerous than a drunken night in Tijuana tried to create a scandal.

FORTUNATELY, Lt.-Gen. Mattis has three big things going for him: The respect of those who serve; the Marine Corps, which won't abandon a valiant fighter to please self-righteous pundits whose only battle is with their waistlines; and the fact that we're at war. We need more men like Mattis, not fewer. The public needs to hear the truth about war, not just the crybaby nonsense of those who never deigned to serve our country.

In my own far humbler career, the leaders I admired were those who had the killer instinct. The soldiers knew who they were. We would have followed them anywhere. They weren't slick Pentagon staffers anxious to go to work for defense contractors. They were the men who lived and breathed the warrior's life. Table manners don't win wars. Winning our nation's battles demands disciplined ferocity, raw physical courage — and integrity. Jim Mattis has those qualities in spades.

Semper fi, General.
Posted by:Mrs. Davis

#6  I absolutely guarantee you that the Commandant called him and demanded his letter of retirement. It will likely delay for a few weeks to let the furor die down, and to give the appearance he is retiring on his on.
Posted by: anymouse   2005-02-06 11:56:46 PM  

#5  I'm not certain of the best venue for this, but I think that one thing all of us should do is "bombard" various "opinion makers" including our members of Congress with parise for Mattis. One of the things that's happened over the years is that whenever some one in the PC side of life gets offended by something they get a lot of attention for their self-righteous opinions. If we flood Congress, etc with POSITIVE comments, much of that political power can be nullified.
I'm not suggesting that we can "cure" it in a single attempt, but even a first attempt will go a long way toward brining balance to these issues.

Posted by: Ralph   2005-02-06 5:50:53 PM  

#4  And drag the non-story out even more?
Posted by: Tom   2005-02-06 5:05:47 PM  

#3  Patrick, that's a good comment, but if I had been in Mattis' position I think I would have wanted the SecDef to say a few words in my defense.
Posted by: Matt   2005-02-06 5:04:24 PM  

#2  Maybe, Matt, but if Rummy had done that what would have changed? All the people who currently respect Mattis would still respect him, and all the people with access to the airwaves who have it in for the military and for Rummy would have gone to town, Abu Ghraibing this thing. Mattis doesn't need defending against pin-pricks, and no-one on the left would have been persuaded to understand Mattis's comments just by having Rummy defend them. It was probably as well to just deprived the MSM of their little toy.
Posted by: Patrick Brown   2005-02-06 4:53:14 PM  

#1  Uncharacteristically, Rummy missed a chance on one of the talk shows this morning. When asked about General Mattis' remark by one of the Bighairs (Wolf Blitzer, I think) Rummy basically said that the Commandant of the Marine Corps had dealt with the issue and that was the end of it. I would much rather have seen him come out swinging with a defense of Mattis' very considerable achievements (taking Baghdad, for example.)
Posted by: Matt   2005-02-06 4:23:45 PM  

00:00