You have commented 358 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Africa: North
Binny's videographer to sue Michael Moore
2005-02-06
A FORMER close associate of Osama Bin Laden is to sue the film-maker Michael Moore for using his footage of the Al-Qaeda chief in the documentary Fahrenheit 9/11. Essam Deraz, an Egyptian, spent almost four years in Afghanistan filming Bin Laden at training camps and fighting, gaining unprecedented access to the terrorist leader. He was the only person to film Bin Laden during the late 1980s and has the only footage of the Saudi exile in battle in Afghanistan.

Deraz has started legal action in Egypt and America to seek compensation for use of his footage in Fahrenheit 9/11, the biggest-grossing documentary in cinema history. Deraz claims he had not signed a distribution agreement with Moore or anyone else. "I was the only cameraman with the Arabs. All of those shots of Bin Laden talking in the cave, talking into his walkie-talkie, they were all my work. "I was there from 1986-89 and was in contact with Bin Laden on many occasions. I saw him in Peshawar in Pakistan and in Jalalabad in Afghanistan. The film clips in Fahrenheit 9/11 — five of them — were mostly shot in March and April 1989. I was wounded twice and on one of those occasions Bin Laden arranged for me to be taken to hospital in his vehicle. These are the only film clips ever taken that show Bin Laden on the battlefield."

Film of the Arab mujaheddin fighting against the Russians in Afghanistan is rare because they did not take part in many large-scale engagements. The fighting around Jalalabad, shortly before the Russians withdrew, is one of the few occasions where Arab fighters were involved in large numbers. Deraz, who worked for the BBC in the 1970s and lived in London, said he had no sympathy with Al-Qaeda, which had not yet come into existence when the footage was shot. At the time it was Egyptian policy to support the uprising by Afghans against the Soviet forces that had invaded the country. Following his return to Egypt, he wrote a number of books about the anti-Soviet jihad and made three films.
Posted by:Dan Darling

#7  Well...sounds like the guy should really take his case up with al-Jazeera. Though, suing them in an Egyptian and Qatari court could prove...troublesome. Much better to use the American system to go after a target with lots of money.

And jeez, the movie's been out for a good while now. Couldn't he have said something a bit earlier, like, say, two days before the DVD release date?
Posted by: gromky   2005-02-06 5:38:24 PM  

#6  Moore is full of bullshit if he is claiming Public Domain. The stuff was copyrighted under international and US law the second Deraz filmed it. Using it without permission, attribution or compensation will get you in a world of hurt. Mr Moore is about the find out that his lawyers are wrong. He may have a deal with Al Jiz but if they don't own what he claims he gave them he is double plus screwed. I am keeping my fingers crossed.
Posted by: Sock Puppet of Doom   2005-02-06 2:18:44 AM  

#5  Moore's defense: The Images are so far in the Public Domain and subscribed to posterity, that compensation to Essam Deraz would be tantamount to "fining history for it's own revelations". Even the Zapruder film could only be sold for viewing only once!
Posted by: smn   2005-02-06 1:44:39 AM  

#4  Moore’s next project, a film called Sicko....
Is that an autobiography?
Posted by: GK   2005-02-06 1:18:32 AM  

#3  Wonder if this will result in some kind of fatwa . . .
Posted by: The Doctor   2005-02-06 1:17:51 AM  

#2  Damn, when your career goes ice-cold in Hollywood, it's brutal. First no Oscar nods, then this. Good thing Mikey will always have donuts.....
Posted by: Desert Blondie   2005-02-06 12:52:36 AM  

#1  Well, I am for this guy suing the skin off Moore's ass (or appropriate chunk of moolah--$1000 per square millimeter). Same, as Al-Jihadiyya is concerned.
Posted by: Sobiesky   2005-02-06 12:33:12 AM  

00:00