| Submit your comments on this article |
| Britain |
| We must be free to criticise without being called racist |
| 2004-08-21 |
| Polly Toynbee, the Queen of the Morlocks, grows a clue. What is the rationalist to do? Atheists, feminists and anti-racists are paralysed by Islam. Whichever way they turn, they find themselves at risk of alliances with undesirables of every nasty hue. Last month, the website of an organisation called the Islamic Human Rights Commission made me the "winner" of their "Most Islamophobic media personality" award. It has caused me a bombardment of emails of both extreme pro- and anti-Islamic poison, each one more luridly threatening than the last. The occasional note of reason from moderate Islamic groups is so weak it hardly makes itself heard. I had challenged the legitimacy of the idea of Islamophobia and warned of the danger to free speech of trying to make criticism of a religion a crime akin to racism. I pointed out yet again that theocracy is lethal. Wherever religion controls politics it drives out tolerance and basic human rights. The history of Christianity has been the perfect exemplar, a force for repression whenever it holds any political sway. It only turns peace-loving when it is powerless. People led by some unalterable revealed voice of God cannot be tolerant of the godless. At present it is Islamic states that head the danger list - though the dread power of southern Baptists in US politics endangers world peace, as do extreme Jewish sects holding power in Israel. Women are always the main victims, since extreme religions express their identities through male priestly supremacy and disgust of women. To give a flavour of the Islamic Human Rights Commission awards, Nick Griffin of the BNP won the most Islamophobic British politician award, Jacques Chirac and Ariel Sharon shared the international Islamophobic politician award and Islamophobe of the year was George Bush. That's the company I found myself in. |
| Posted by:tipper |
| #5 Thanks Carl! Now I remember. |
| Posted by: Shipman 2004-08-21 2:08:37 PM |
| #4 This is the left's greatest idiocy: they will believe anything coming from someone of a darker hue than themselves. |
| Posted by: Bryan 2004-08-21 1:46:28 PM |
| #3 Note to those recently joining us: Polly Toynbee is the Grauniad columnist who is so stupid she actually fell for a Nigerian scam -- and wrote about it in the newspaper. |
| Posted by: Carl in N.H. 2004-08-21 1:37:12 PM |
| #2 This cracks me up. Did she honestly think that she wouldn't be targetted? It really couldn't happen to a more deserving person. Note the dig at the southern Baptists and the Jooos. On a positive note, if someone as LLL as Polly Toynbee is starting to think "hang on, they're not playing by the game!" then there is hope that even the left might realise we're playing for keeps here... |
| Posted by: Tony (UK) 2004-08-21 12:46:35 PM |
| #1 Whatsa matter pollyanna - turned on ya, did they? Looks to me like she was ok with calling people Islamophobes until they put her in the same Islamophobe league as Sharon, and Bush. Well, at least it's encouraging that she finally manged to get a clue. |
| Posted by: B 2004-08-21 11:51:45 AM |