You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Caucasus
No large armed groups left in Chechnya
2004-01-15
No large illegal armed groups under single command have been left in Chechnya, Colonel General Valery Baranov, Commander of the Joint Army Group in the Northern Caucasus, has said in an interview with the Voenno-Promyshlenny Kurier (Military-Industrial Courier) weekly. According to Baranov, “the militants changed their tactics radically.”
"I mean, like, they got out of Dodge!"
“They are operating in small groups, which tend to be dispersed, and are avoiding open armed clashes,” he said.
Here's the dichotomy: a well-trained military force of, say, 100 men with beat the living crap out of a random group of tough guys approximately 100.00 percent of the time. This is why soldier armies always defeat warrior armies. In a one-on-one, however, the tough guys will beat the snot out of individual soldiers approximately 50 percent of the time, or even 60-40 if the tough guys are from a warrior culture. The same applies to small groups — under ten, or maybe up to a dozen. The only way warrior cultures (like the Chechens or Islamists in general) stand a chance of beating disciplined, professionally led armies is through breaking into small groups and going for attrition. The assumption there is that the warrior culture is capable of sustaining equal losses with the more civilized culture during the course of hostilities. Sometimes they are, sometimes they aren't...
Baranov set forth his understanding of the recent incident, when a gang of Chechen gunmen penetrated to Dagestan and was destroyed there. “It was Ruslan Gelayev’s illegal armed unit, made up of 37 men. It was going from the Shatoi district of Chechnya to Georgia,” Baranov continued. In his opinion, “the gang planned to go to Georgia for the purpose of creating special conditions on its territory during the elections. In other words, they planned to destabilise the situation there.” General Baranov pointed to the fact that the gang under the command of Ruslan Gelayev, who is now in Georgia, included foreign mercenaries. This is confirmed by the evidence given by the captured gunmen. “A gang was destroyed recently near the village of Serzhen-Yurt, which included mercenaries even from Western Europe. A ramified network of recruiters is functioning in the world. They recruit only real professionals, as a rule, former servicemen,” Baranov said.
I'm not sure that's a true statement. A lot of the cannon fodder we've seen recruited have been more in the street tough category...
Commenting on the prospects of capturing Maskhadov and Basayev, Baranov said it was just a matter of time. “I hope soon they will be captured. Now Chechnya is no place for Basayev and Maskhadov. This is why either they surrender voluntarily, or they will be destroyed,” he said.
I think I'd go for "destroyed," myself...
Posted by:Dan Darling

#8  Danke, Fred.. I'll post a link to my essay when it's finished.

Ed.
Posted by: Ed Becerra   2004-1-15 9:30:49 PM  

#7  The trick to doing it right is to draft Comanche warriors and train them in the way of the Soldat. Or you could just stick with luring Rednecks and teach them the way of the team.
Posted by: Shipman   2004-1-15 5:57:27 PM  

#6  That was my deathless prose. I don't mind.
Posted by: Fred   2004-1-15 3:28:43 PM  

#5  Oy, Dan.. would you mind terribly if I quoted you on that bit above, comparing and contrasting soldiers with warriors?

That's about the most succinct statement of an essential truth that I've EVER seen. It fits in well with an essay I've been working on for my own blog..

Ed Becerra
Posted by: Ed Becerra   2004-1-15 2:45:43 PM  

#4  Danke, Fred.. I'll post a link to my essay when it's finished.

Ed.
Posted by: Ed Becerra   2004-1-15 9:30:49 PM  

#3  The trick to doing it right is to draft Comanche warriors and train them in the way of the Soldat. Or you could just stick with luring Rednecks and teach them the way of the team.
Posted by: Shipman   2004-1-15 5:57:27 PM  

#2  That was my deathless prose. I don't mind.
Posted by: Fred   2004-1-15 3:28:43 PM  

#1  Oy, Dan.. would you mind terribly if I quoted you on that bit above, comparing and contrasting soldiers with warriors?

That's about the most succinct statement of an essential truth that I've EVER seen. It fits in well with an essay I've been working on for my own blog..

Ed Becerra
Posted by: Ed Becerra   2004-1-15 2:45:43 PM  

00:00