You have commented 339 times on Rantburg.

Your Name
Your e-mail (optional)
Website (optional)
My Original Nic        Pic-a-Nic        Sorry. Comments have been closed on this article.
Bold Italic Underline Strike Bullet Blockquote Small Big Link Squish Foto Photo
Europe
Court Refuses to Free Sept. 11 Plotter
2003-12-16
A German court ruled yesterday that the only man convicted anywhere in the world over the Sept. 11 attacks must remain in custody despite new evidence said to cast doubt on his involvement. Lawyers for Mounir El Motassadeq, sentenced to the maximum 15 years earlier this year on more than 3,000 counts of accessory to murder, had asked for his release after a fellow Moroccan was freed from custody last week.
Score one for the German courts: they're not into committing national suicide...
It followed evidence passed through Germany’s federal crime office quoting an informant saying that neither Motassadeq nor the other accused, Abdelghani Mzoudi, was part of the Al-Qaeda cell involved in the 2001 attacks. Motassadeq’s lawyer, Josef Graessle-Muenscher, confirmed yesterday’s ruling but did not want to give further details. His appeal against conviction is currently going through Germany’s federal criminal court. Although Mzoudi was unexpectedly freed from custody last week, his trial is still going on. He also faces charges of accessory to the murder of more than 3,000 people, based on the death toll in the suicide attacks in New York and Washington, and membership of a terrorist organization. The evidence last week is thought to have come from Ramzi Bin al-shibh, also known as Ramzi ibn Al-Shaiba, an alleged senior Al-Qaeda operative who is now in US custody, although no name has been officially given. The informant named only four people involved in the Al-Qaeda cell in Hamburg, northern Germany — three of the hijackers, including their alleged ringleader Mohammed Atta, and Binalshibh.
Posted by:Fred Pruitt

#6  I remember times when courts weren't bothered with technicalities like evidence and boy they were stormy!

Germany elected Hitler. The military and internal security apparatus supported him. His ascension to power had nothing to do with changes to the legal system. He used paramilitary thugs to intimidate and liquidate the opposition and enforce his rule.

Until the past several decades, the British used indefinite detention to quash terrorist activity without any ill-effects to its government. Lots of ex-British colonies have these laws on the books, and not a single Hitler has materialized. Like I said, dictatorships have to do with the national ethos, not creeping changes in a nation's laws.
Posted by: Zhang Fei   2003-12-16 5:13:52 PM  

#5  Zhang Fei, we still need some tiny bits of evidence to convict people. The US cant jeopardize trials in Hamburg with secrecy and then blame the Germans for not doing their job.

I remember times when courts weren't bothered with technicalities like evidence and boy they were stormy!
Posted by: True German Ally   2003-12-16 3:15:49 PM  

#4  I see this more as a move of the court to put a little pressure on Washington... to hand over some more evidence

I understand Washington has been a little tight-lipped about intelligence material to protect sources and methods. And this is resented everywhere. Fine.

But any German court that is thinking of releasing these guys needs to consider the following - if another major terror attack occurs on US soil, and these guys are linked to that attack, US-German relations are going to be set back for decades. In the wake of a major event like that, today's somewhat stormy relationship is going to seem positively sunny compared to what comes afterwards.
Posted by: Zhang Fei   2003-12-16 2:33:56 PM  

#3  I see this more as a move of the court to put a little pressure on Washington... to hand over some more evidence... just enough to bag the guys for the next decades. In 15 years or so we'll send them back to Morocco and you can have some more fun with them.

Ok we could still send them to Morocco right away with exact flight details?
Posted by: True German Ally   2003-12-16 1:54:03 PM  

#2  Sanity reigns over the German version of our very own 9th Circuit Court of Appeals?
Posted by: Frank G   2003-12-16 12:37:21 PM  

#1  It looks like freed Mzoudi might be back behind bars pretty soon as well...
Posted by: True German Ally   2003-12-16 10:38:11 AM  

00:00